One team is likely headed to the playoffs for the fourth consecutive season, the other is headed for a season of flirting with the 1962 Mets record for the least amount of wins by a major league team in the era of the 162-game schedule.
So, it’s not really surprising that on day when both teams made a significant transaction, one team’s move is being celebrated as another stroke of brilliance while the other team has left a lot of people scratching their heads.
Let’s start with the Pirates, who are 20-18 and one of the five or six best teams.
The Cubs are better, the Nationals and Mets are probably better and the Giants will probably win the National League West, which in all likelihood leaves the Pirates to fight with the Cardinals and Dodgers for a wild card spot.
That’s amazing because this was supposed to be a “bridge year” for the Pirates (Neal Huntington’s words, not mine) where they moved away from some of the veteran core of their previous three teams and made room for their next wave of young talented players to restock the major league roster.
Yet, here they sit again in playoff position, and it’s mostly because of the way that Neal Huntington and company have managed this organization, have been patient with prospects and have made moves like this one.
Read More
Catcher Francisco Cervelli was due to be a free agent at the end of this season, instead it turns out he won’t ever make it to the market. The Pirates announced today he signed a three-year, $31 million extension.
That’s significant on a number of levels beyond Cervelli being a good catcher and seems to be a great fit for this team and clubhouse leader.
For one thing, the Pirates have a couple of good young catchers in the minors in Elias Diaz and Jacob Stallings, and now they have a mentor for the next year or two before one of them takes over.
They also now have the ability to move one of those two prospects if some deal comes along as keeping Cervelli around for three years strengthens their depth at that position.
But here’s the bigger picture: if you look at the contracts the Pirates have worked out with their players, there’s no reason to worry about the bigger market teams picking this roster clean because this team is going to be intact for at least a few more years.
With Cervelli in the mix, the Pirates now have seven of their eight regular position players (and a youngster named Josh Bell ready to step in at the eighth spot, first base) locked up through at least 2018.
That’s not a misprint. The outfield, Kang, Mercer, Harrison and now Cervelli are locked up through at least 2018. That speaks volumes to the creative and aggressive ways that the Pirates organization have found to make sure they can compete for the long term.
Look, I don’t like every move they make, and I’ve said often Huntington has been too conservative with prospects in some cases, but the plan that Frank Coonelly and Huntington have put in place from the day they arrived is falling into place better than anyone could have imagined.
The Pirates are going to be good for a lot of years, mostly because of the way the front office has operated.
Think about it: the Pirates’ next wave of prospects are almost all pitchers. If they are as good as advertised, this could be a World Series winning team in either 2017 or 2018.
The rotation could be Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon, Tyler Glasnow, Nick Kingham, and at that point, if those guys all pan out, who cares who the fifth starter is?
You add that to a veteran core of players who have played together for a couple of years and Josh Bell at first base — I’m not sure what’s not to like.
It is fun to kill Bob Nutting and company for being cheap, for not spending on big free agents, but when this management took over, it stripped it down and built it back up. It didn’t take shortcuts, didn’t go outside its comfort zone, and the results have been astounding.
That brings me to the second team in this discussion — the Braves — who, over the last two years, apparently went with the “strip it down and start over” model. As a result, they field a team that can be best described as Freddie Freeman and the Gwinnett Braves.
There was no question this Braves team was going to be awful. It was only going to be a question of just how awful, and many people believed 50 wins would be the best-case scenario for the team.
Which made today’s news, that manager Fredi Gonzalez was fired, quite silly.
I mean, he lost his job because he lost too many games with a roster that appeared to be put together with the purpose of losing lots of games.
We’ve heard it many times. “You can’t fire the players, so you have to fire the coach.” I’d disagree in this case. You could and probably should fire a lot of these players on the Braves roster.
Freeman is obviously a great player and one of the better first baseman in the National League.
Jeff Francoeur is a guy who has at least demonstrated some level of competency as an MLB player.
There are a couple of good young pitchers (eye on the future) on that staff, but beyond that, this is a team that makes most of the 2010 Pirates look like the 1927 Yankees.
I have a suggestion for the next manager of the Braves: Lou Brown, who took the Indians to the playoffs in “Major League” with guys who either are way past their prime or never had a prime.
I half expected the Braves to show up at PNC Park this year with Pedro Cerrano and Willie Mays Hayes — except those two actually had some talent.
That’s what makes the Gonzalez firing so bizarre and unfair, at least at this point in the season, even though their record is abysmal.
The Braves knew what kind of team they had, and if they didn’t think Gonzalez was the guy to get the rebuilding process started they should have fired him in the offseason.
Appropriately, the interim manager is Brian Snitker, who is the manager of the Braves’ Class AAA affiliate in Gwinnett, Ga. At least he should be familiar with a lot of the players, who probably should still be on his former team.
All is not lost, however, as Braves fans need only to look into the other dugout and see that it wasn’t that long ago that the Pirates were a disaster of an organization and team but pulled it together. They’re now one of the best franchises in baseball.
That’s called hope, and when you have a roster like the Braves do, hope is all you have to root for.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.