The contract extension signed by Nationals ace Stephen Strasburg is absolutely ridiculous.

The extension, which is expected to be announced today, is for seven years and $174 million, and there is an opportunity for him to earn another $14 million with various incentives.

Strasburg, when healthy, has been one of the best pitchers in baseball. At 27, he is still young enough that the Nationals should get four or five really good years out of him.

They hope.

Advertise with us

The key phrase is “when healthy.” Strasburg has been on the disabled list six times and has undergone a Tommy John surgery already.

Strasburg seems to have a fragile arm and is Exhibit A as to just how stupid the market has gotten.

That market is exactly why the Pirates cannot start paying to keep certain players around.

Which brings me to Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen, two players who probably won’t finish their career in a Pirates uniform. Given what the market is, that’s not a bad thing.

Let’s start with McCutchen, a fan favorite who took a bit of a hometown discount already to extend his time here. Many believe he’s the face of the franchise and thus should never be allowed to leave.

Advertise with us

People talk about how important it is to have McCutchen retire in a Pirates uniform, and I keep asking why.

In order for that to happen, the Pirates will have to go way out of their financial comfort zone and completely change the way they do business.

It also would require signing a player in his 30s to a deal that goes beyond his prime years.

They didn’t do it with Russell Martin, and his market value is not close to what McCutchen’s will be when he becomes a free agent at the end of the 2018 season.

Look at Jacoby Ellsbury’s deal (seven years, $153 million at age 30) and tell me what McCutchen (who will turn 31 in 2018) is going to be worth.

Advertise with us

McCutchen is going to command between $24-30 million per year for at least six years, if not seven.

Do you really believe the Pirates are going to offer anything close to that? And do you really believe McCutchen is going to agree to take a hometown discount of, say, $75 million over five years?

The Pirates shouldn’t pay McCutchen. They should ride him for two more seasons, then look to move him at some point between the end of the 2017 season and the 2018 trade deadline.

That would mean they got 10 years out of McCutchen — the best 10 years of his career — and at that point, it will be time to move on.

Gerrit Cole still has his arbitration years, so he isn’t going anywhere. But there will be a point where the Pirates must look to trade him too.

Advertise with us

There was some speculation that Cole could get bought out of a few years of arbitration in exchange for a couple years of free agency like McCutchen, Starling Marte and Josh Harrison did. But that wouldn’t make sense for the Pirates, either.

I hate the idea of long-term deals for a pitcher because pitchers have arm problems and career ending surgeries. Everyday players are different because they seem to bounce back from even the ugliest injuries — think Buster Posey and Jung Ho Kang.

The Pirates cannot afford to make the kinds of mistakes that teams like the Dodgers and Yankees can, and the best way to avoid them is to avoid locking up pitchers long-term beyond the age of 30.

Cole will be 29 years old when he is eligible for free agency following the 2019 season, and that means he will be on track for a huge deal.

People think the Pirates are cheap because they avoid these kinds of contracts and let their stars walk (or trade them) when they are at the end of their contracts, but that’s simply not true.

Advertise with us

It’s not being cheap to understand that tying up that much money for one player over that many years — no matter how good he is — is bad business, even if you have tons of cash to burn like the big market teams.

That doesn’t mean I agree with everything the Pirates do. There are times they could spend more money and take more risks.

But the one thing they have done right and will continue to do right is avoid long-term megadeals with players and instead work to get the most out of their best players in pre-arbitration and arbitration years.

The Strasburg deal may work out for Washington, but then again, it could be the most expensive pork chop they’ve ever had to eat.

Cole and McCutchen have been great players and are a huge part of the Pirates’ recent run of success — but that doesn’t mean they need to be Pirates for life.