Pittsburgh's championship expectations make it tempting to view every Steelers playoff loss through the same prism of disappointment. This is especially true when talking about the past two, the latest coming Saturday night in a 30-17 humbling of an AFC wild-card game defeat at the hands of the hated squad from Baltimore.

With that in mind, I posed the following question to my Twitter followers in the waning moments: “So, is a swift death-by-Tebow or a slow-motion car crash against the Ravens more painful for #Steelers fans?”

The former, of course, referred to the local team’s last playoff loss before this one, a 29-23 overtime stunner against the Denver Broncos and quarterback Tim Tebow, whose 80-yard touchdown pass to Demaryius Thomas abruptly ended Pittsburgh’s 2011 season.

As Ryan McElroy eloquently responded to my question, though, the stinging nature of these losses might be where the similarities end. “One was the end of an era, one is the first step in a new era,” he said.

Advertise with us

In fact, the 2011 team and the 2014 group have a lot of key differences that are important to keep in mind as the city digests that familiar cocktail of dejection this week.

The 2011 team relied upon the NFL’s No. 1 ranked defense, the same unit that had carried the franchise to three Super Bowl appearances — including two victories — in the previous decade. Quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, while considered one of the NFL’s great winners, was still in the shadow of his teammates on the other side of the ball.

That team was also old as sin. According to Pro Football Reference, seven of the 11 starters on defense were over the age of 30, while 35-year-old Hines Ward was still holding down a starting wideout spot on offense. By that point, many had already predicted for years that the Steelers were on the cusp of an aging-out process that ultimately resulted in a two-year playoff hiatus.

In contrast, this year’s team had an offensive identity. Whether it was Roethlisberger’s back-to-back six-touchdown performances against the Colts and Ravens, receiver Antonio Brown’s highlight reel catches, or running back Le’Veon Bell’s balanced approach to becoming an All-Pro at his position, there were few doubts that the Steelers were going to win by overpowering opponents with points.

And there was a great youth movement apparent on this squad, at least in comparison. The offense and defense combined to feature just four starters over the age of 30, not counting cameos by James Harrison and Brett Keisel, who were brought in following injuries that left the defense lacking depth.

Advertise with us

So today's Steelers stand in a very different place from when they last exited the playoffs as losers. Rather than ponder what damage another year of aging might do to an ancient roster, fans can look across the lineups and see promise in a group of younger players who still have time to show some upside.

On offense, they can look forward to the maturation of receiver Martavis Bryant, who broke onto the scene as a deep threat as a rookie this season opposite the dynamic Brown. And they can dream about seeing a healthy Bell in the backfield come next January after he missed Saturday's game with an injury.

Defensively, linebackers Jarvis Jones (a second-year player) and Ryan Shazier (a rookie) still are young enough to develop the potential the front office saw when it invested back-to-back first-round picks in them — if they can stay healthy.

Of course, this all can cut the other way, too. Maybe Jones and Shazier will turn out to be busts. Maybe Bell and Brown won't come close to matching their outstanding career years. And who knows the future of the secondary as general manager Kevin Colbert and company grapple with the deterioration of Troy Polamalu and Ike Taylor?

There's a distinct possibility that this younger group will never age into the greatness of the stalwarts who preceded them. After all, the Super Steelers of the 1970s ultimately became the mediocre-to-bad Steelers of the 1980s.

Advertise with us

But that sense of possibility — good and bad — as well as a legitimate step forward from mediocrity this season should be a welcomed departure from the impending sense of geriatric doom that accompanied Tebow's toss through a cold Denver night three years ago.

Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition.