I don’t pretend to be a football schematics expert. I leave that to people in the arena and to colleagues such as the Post-Gazette’s Christopher Carter, who posed a rather esoteric question to Steelers coach Mike Tomlin on Tuesday.

Carter basically asked why the Steelers were in a certain defense Sunday against four vertical pass routes, one of which went uncovered on a laughably easy touchdown pass to DJ Moore.

Tomlin declined to answer, which continued a pattern. He had no answers Sunday, either, against the play-calling of Chicago coach Ben Johnson.

“I am not going to peel back the layers of how we function from a schematic standpoint,” Tomlin told Carter, “although I am impressed by the depths of your question.”

Advertise with us

Me, too. Here’s what I’m not impressed with: the Steelers’ $170 million defense, highest-paid in the NFL. And I don’t need to read “Football for Dummies” to understand that when a cast of average receivers is open all over the field, all day long, you’re doing something very wrong.

That was clearly the case in Chicago. If Bears quarterback Caleb Williams had been more accurate, he might have thrown for 350 yards and five touchdowns instead of 239 and three.

Something was wrong. Something has been for much of the season. And for much of the past decade, to be honest, and the only thread that runs through it all is Tomlin. The defense is his baby. He believes games are won with dominant defense and careful, turnover-free offense.

And to be sure, his defense will deliver its share of gems, like the recent ones against Indianapolis and Cincinnati. It does every year. But it cannot establish consistency and often falls apart in the biggest moments, always in playoff games.

Nobody should be surprised if the defense delivers a command performance against the Buffalo Bills on Sunday. That is what the Steelers do. They tease people just enough to believe big things are possible.

Advertise with us

In the end, though, the defense always disappoints — and in the wake of the Bears debacle, the coaching critiques aren’t just coming from sportswriters. They are coming from ex-NFL players all over the place.

More notably, they are coming from within the house.

The Post-Gazette’s Brian Batko asked linebacker Patrick Queen after the game about all those open receivers. Queen seemed to be biting his tongue on the response — but what he actually said was eye-opening, to say the least.

“I think sometimes it was schematic issues that we had,” Queen said.

That means coaching. Which means Queen was politely calling out Tomlin. Queen went into an esoteric explanation of his own about how underneath defenders were put in terrible spots, when Batko followed up with, “Was that something you could have adjusted in-game?”

Advertise with us

“Yes,” Queen said.

It’s never good when the players are openly questioning the scheme. If Queen says it publicly, imagine what they’re saying privately. This type of thing often portends a storm. The Steelers clearly had schematic/communications issues late last season. Minkah Fitzpatrick was scapegoated. Maybe he wasn’t the problem.

Again, I’m not going to break down in-game adjustments, or the lack thereof, like I’m Jimmy Johnson. But I know this: The Steelers usually stink after halftime. Things usually get worse. The Packers put 28 on them in the second half. The Seahawks had 17, the Bengals 16, etc.

I also know this: Ex-NFL players don’t like what they see with the Steelers’ defensive approach.

This was former Steelers linebacker James Harrison on the “Deebo and Joe” podcast with Joe Haden, after he ripped the offensive coaches for using Darnell Washington to pass protect against the Bears’ best pass-rusher (Montez Sweat) on Sunday:

Advertise with us

“Defense. Soft. I’m tired of seeing the offensive linemen pushing our defensive line 2-3 yards,” Harrison said, his voice rising. “We’re undisciplined, poorly coached, or both. We have a horrible defensive scheme. It’s trash, it’s garbage. We can’t adjust.”

Other than that, he’s a big fan. This was ex-Steeler Trai Essex on 93.7 The Fan on Tuesday, talking about the defense:

“It’s definitely the scheme because the talent is there. This points strictly to the coaching and the positions [players] are being put in on a play-to-play, game-to-game basis because it’s not consistent. And these guys seem to be confused.”

Finally, ex-NFL tackle Brian Baldinger, who could not believe the Steelers only used two down linemen (Cam Heyward, Keeanu Benton) in a goal-line situation in the second half. Ben Johnson took advantage by calling a run right up the middle for an easy score. Essex couldn’t believe this, either, saying Benton is terrible against double-teams in such situations.

Baldinger broke down the video, pointing out that the Bears had three receivers on the field on 3rd-and-goal from the 2 and that the Steelers countered with a defensive back-heavy, nickel defense.

Advertise with us

“Things that make you go, ‘Hmmmmm,’” Baldinger said. “What do you think the Bears are going to do here? Like, they’re going to attack those two defensive tackles. And here it is, two double-teams at the point. … It’s a walk in the Soldier Field park right there for the game-clinching touchdown.

“Is that how you want to defend your goal line, in a nickel? I’m just asking. Is that how you’re just matching up, at the 2-yard line?”

Maybe Tomlin could answer that question.

Or not.