Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Foote and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him at @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which this week were laced with angst over Mike Tomlin’s defense ...

J, @Crossland895: Good evening, Joe! Would firing (defensive coordinator) Teryl Austin be a catalyst for this organization to finally move on from Tomlin? I know it’s beating a dead horse, but I feel like if they do indeed fire Austin, they’d have no one else left to blame except for Tomlin. At the same time, I think that’s exactly why the Steelers won’t make a move. Canada was an easy scapegoat because that’s not Tomlin’s side of the ball. Thoughts? Feelings?

Starkey: First, know this, Dr. Jay — Austin was elevated to defensive coordinator in 2022, and the Steelers, despite having the first- or second-highest paid defensive unit each year since, have yet to finish in the top 10 in total defense since the move, are currently ranked 30th and allowed 478 rushing yards in two terrible playoff losses.

Yes, 478 yards rushing in two games. Look it up.

Advertise with us

The Steelers have bottomed out defensively in their past two games, allowing 68 points and 924 yards. It was especially disturbing that with extra time and allegedly extra motivation to prepare for a Sunday night home game against the Packers — the motivation provided by an embarrassing Thursday night showing against Cincinnati — the defense surrendered 28 second-half points and allowed 454 yards in all.

That sounds like rock bottom to me. That sounds just as bad, if not worse, than all the events leading up to offensive coordinator Matt Canada’s midseason firing two years ago.

Now, we all know this is really Mike Tomlin’s defense and that Austin is largely a figurehead. But that is actually the point here. That is why team president Art Rooney II should make this move. He should fire Austin today and make Tomlin fully responsible for the defense — totally unshielded — and attach Tomlin’s fate to the unit.

Tomlin designed this defense, from scheme to personnel. He has at times called the defensive plays, although Austin is largely responsible for that at the moment. Tomlin should be. Let’s see if he can stop the free fall and get Rooney his money’s worth from the highest-paid unit in the league.

If he can, great.

Advertise with us

If he can’t, then even Art II might see that it’s time to move on (though I wouldn’t bet on that).

It was also Tomlin who wrote the giant check before the season, saying this defense was capable of “historic things.” He meant that in a good way, of course, but the unit has actually been making all the wrong kinds of history. That would include being the first Steelers team since 1985 to lose a home game by 10 or more points that it led by 10 or more entering the fourth quarter.

I don’t remember too many quarterbacks completing 20 or more passes against the Steelers, either, as Jordan Love did Sunday.

As for Austin, it’s time, regardless of his limited power. Some combination of Rooney and Tomlin fired Canada two years ago. In some ways, this defense is worse than Canada’s offense.

Example: The Steelers were 31st in passing offense when Canada was fired. Their pass defense is 32nd at the moment.

Advertise with us

In two playoff games, the Tomlin/Austin defenses have allowed a combined 42 first-half points to the Bills and Ravens, not to mention 832 yards and 69 points.

The Ravens piled up 299 yards rushing in last year’s win (the most the Steelers have ever allowed in a playoff game) and scored touchdowns on first-half drives of 95, 90 and 85 yards. Which makes it even more incredible that anybody involved with this defense — whether they were here for that game or not — had the gall to come to camp and brag about being historically great. I wonder what Rooney thought of that, or if he thought of it at all.

What we have seen is more of the same: rampant miscommunication, blown coverages, shoddy run defense, inconsistent pass rush, etc.

This defense has been failing in the biggest moments for years. It hasn’t played a respectable playoff game since 2016. Does Rooney know that? At the moment, it is at least as bad as Canada’s offense. Tomlin should be made to fully own that and be charged with full responsibility to fix it.

Make it truly his, from top to bottom. And if he can’t fix it, then Rooney would have another obvious decision to make.

Advertise with us

@GolfmanBrian: The Steelers defense has never been the same since Dick Lebeau left despite having several high end talent players. Biggest mistake since he left was letting Brian Flores leave, am I wrong?

Starkey: LeBeau’s later years weren’t so great, either, Dr. H. I’d say the Steelers defense hasn’t been the same since Aaron Rodgers torched them in the Super Bowl and guys like Troy Polamalu, James Farrior, Casey Hampton, Aaron Smith and James Harrison left.

But you are correct here: Flores should have been retained and been given full autonomy over the defense.

@Get2theCH0PPER: To quote a wise-man from today: "Where the hell is Alex Highsmith?!” Has anybody found this man?!

Starkey: I sure haven’t, Dr. Chopper, and it’s hurting the team badly. We talk plenty about T.J. Watt and his paltry sack totals of late (four in 11 games dating to last season), mostly because he makes the big bucks.

Advertise with us

But check out this Highsmith number: He had 14.5 sacks in 2022, signed his four-year, $68 million extension, and has just 14.5 sacks in 33 games since! He had five forced fumbles that season but just three since.

Highsmith has been completely invisible the past two games with three solo tackles and zero sacks. Yet, he plays the vast majority of the snaps over Nick Herbig. That needs to change Sunday.

@dawatchman: Let’s be honest they aren’t winning anything meaningful with Rodgers. So if the Vikings now regret their decision not to sign Aaron, would you make him available via trade? What would you want back?

Starkey: Hmmmm. I hadn’t thought of this, Dr. Watchman, and I suppose it’s fair to point out the Steelers are in first place in their division, albeit a horrible division. But I’ll indulge you and say if Minnesota offered a first-round pick — and I wouldn't accept anything less — I’d entertain a trade.

That would be quite something. The Steelers could ride off with Mason Rudolph.

Advertise with us

At the moment, I’m fully in favor of bringing Rodgers back next season. Let’s see what happens over the next 10 games.

@LadyEsquire412: What are the chances that Rodgers is QB1 on week one next year? Has he shown enough so far to merit consideration to return?

Starkey: Please see above, Dr. 412. Rodgers has exceeded expectations, I’d say. It might depend on whether he wants to play another season here. I wonder what he thinks of the defense.

@ohMadnessYT: Any chance we see Slay get benched or Ramsey move primarily to safety? How about Ramsey at safety, JPJ & Trice on the outside & Echols in slot?

Starkey: All ideas are welcome here, Dr. Madness. This is a disaster. The problem with moving Jalen Ramsey primarily to safety is that he’s still their best cover guy, although hardly a perfect one. Anything and everything else is on the table.

Advertise with us

@jaseo224: Hey Joe. We listen every day at work. Im curious to hear your opinion. In what order would you rank blame from management for Steelers lack of success between Rooney, Khan and Weidl and Tomlin?

Starkey:

1. Rooney

2. Tomlin

Omar Khan and Andy Weidl are a distant third, Dr. 224. Rooney runs the show. Tomlin has as much power as maybe any NFL coach there has ever been.

Advertise with us

Keep this in mind, though: I don’t think Rooney believes his team has had a “lack of success.” I believe he thinks it’s pretty darned successful even though it is mired in the franchise’s longest playoff-win drought in 60-some years and hasn’t been competitive in a playoff game in nearly a decade.

@Steve3209839331: Who is the most overpaid member of the Steelers, coaches included?

Starkey: Great question, Dr. 3209839331. I’d say Tomlin, at a reported $16 million per year, and Watt, at a documented $41 million (cap hit) per year. And thank you for asking.

zdubz, @WWZ2k: Is there actually a significant difference between the current Rooney in charge and Bob Nutting?

Starkey: Well, the Steelers win more than they lose, Dr. zdubz, but neither franchise has won a playoff game in going on nine years — and the Steelers have the benefit of a league salary cap. That’s a big advantage. At points not long ago, this would have been a ridiculous question. Now, not so much.

Advertise with us

simmer, @globalsimmer: Let’s please retire Renegade. It's overused and overplayed. It provides no spark obviously and has in the past only made the opponent fired up. If Pittsburgh is known for anything it's for playing classic rock over and over again! Pgh radio has thrived on that for 30+ years.

Starkey: Well, that and sports talk, Dr. simmer. You might have heard that 93.7 The Fan won a Marconi Award last week. The Marconi Awards are essentially the Oscars for radio. To your main point, I think you’re onto something. I will throw this out as a radio topic and get back to you.

Yinzersaurus, @jbfrompgh: We always hear how quickly Tomlin will get a new job if he gets fired. But after what’s happened these past few seasons, would he really be hired that quickly?

Starkey: Yes, but so would Mike Vrabel, Jim Harbaugh, Ben Johnson, Andy Reid, Sean Payton, Nick Sirianni, Matt LaFleur, Sean McVay, Kevin O’Connell, Kyle Shanahan and others, Dr. Yinzer — many of them, plus some offensive coordinators, ahead of Tomlin.

Johnny Chite #ManiacJC, @JohnChite: Hey Joe... Do you believe there is a possibility that Roger Goodell and the NFL are and have for Years now Conspired and Colluded against the Pittsburgh Steelers? I have Evidence to say they Have and at Accelerated Levels in the very recent History ... Ty Joe...

Advertise with us

Starkey: I don’t believe that for a second, Dr. Maniac, but I’ll wait to see the evidence.

DC Pitt Fan, @hailtopitt2005: Alright, Joe. Everyone’s gonna zig and talk about the Steelers so I’m going to zag. How about Pitt? Mason looks like a legit program changing qb. Maybe a freshman all American? If Pitt can somehow win out, is the playoff possible? Can Pitt afford to keep him? Give me hope!

Starkey: I know that Pitt has every intention of keeping Mason Heintschel, Dr. DC, and I’m guessing it’ll take at least a couple of million dollars to do so. He is a unique talent. He gives Pitt a chance. I wouldn’t bet on a playoff spot, but anything is possible. They’re still alive.

Cdawg2022, @Cdawg2022NC: Big fan Joe. W/the Steelers season over (unofficially for now but just wait 2 weeks) let’s move r attention to Pitt: Question can Pitt get into playoff conversation? Final 3 ranked opponents. Yes they have to run the table but they are the best team in this area and so lets dream.

Starkey: I’m not sure about all of that, Dr. 2022, but please dream away. It’s good for you. And the fact is, after a trip to Stanford, Pitt finishes the season against No. 12 Notre Dame, No. 8 Georgia Tech and No. 10 Miami. That is called opportunity.

Advertise with us

I didn’t think they’d play any truly big games this season. If they take care of business against Stanford, they’d be 7-2 overall and 5-1 in the ACC. As such, the Notre Dame game — even if out of conference — and the Georgia Tech game would absolutely qualify.

Chris Mueller, @ChrisMuellerPGH: Joe, how much longer will the Penguins’ fast start have to last before you start believing that they have something legit going?

Starkey: Thanksgiving seems like a decent marker, Mullsy. I keep thinking they are getting outplayed in a given game and won’t win, but they keep winning (or at least get a point). I’m quite surprised. Can you imagine if they make it back to the playoffs before the Pirates do?

I can.