Obviously, I’d love to see Pitt and Penn State renew their football rivalry.

I’m not one of the “move on” people. I don’t want to move on. I want Pennsylvania politicians to force Penn State to play the game every year on grounds that it’s good for the state at large.

Rivalry games are the best thing about college football — and Pitt-Penn State is epic.

Or at least it was epic.

Advertise with us

We were reminded of that when a record crowd of 69,983 packed Heinz Field for the renewal game on Sept. 10, 2016 — a 42-39 Pitt victory in which students from both schools had an incredible time, near as I could tell.

But guess which game topped that record? Six years later, the Backyard Brawl put 70,622 fans into Acrisure Stadium for a 38-31 Pitt victory. That still stands as the biggest crowd to witness a Pittsburgh sporting event. And from this vantage point, it was symbolic:

The Backyard Brawl is the better rivalry.

Is that a popular opinion? Hard to tell, although more than 500 people responded to a poll I put on X the other day, asking which is better — Pitt-PSU or Pitt-WVU — and a whopping 68.6% picked the latter.

Sure, that number might be skewed by the fact that Pitt-PSU is dead — we might never see those schools play again — while the Brawl is very much alive. But I found it instructive.

Advertise with us

The Brawl feels more intimate and hostile on both sides. It’s like fighting your brother. That always means more than battling somebody outside the family. And we really are neighbors. Morgantown is 75 miles down the road. It’s basically the Hatfields and the (Shady) McCoys.

Maybe a lot of you feel like former Pitt linebacker H.B. Blades, who texted me his take Wednesday when I asked him the same question about WVU and Penn State: “I hate them both! I think it depends on the era you played in. I personally hate WVU more than Penn State because I only got to play against WVU.”

What did you hate about them?

“It’s only so long one can take someone yelling, 'Eat (expletive) Pitt’ — things get personal real fast haha,” Blades wrote. “It’s an awesome rivalry that’s great for the region and both universities.”

Other ex-Pitt players, such as Pat Bostick and Yogi Roth, chose WVU as the better rivalry, while Dorin Dickerson and Tim Lewis chose Penn State. Pitt historian Sam Sciullo picked Penn State, but not by much. He acknowledged, “There have been way more crazy games and stunning upsets in the Backyard Brawl.”

Advertise with us

My take is probably skewed, as well, because in my time covering Pitt sports (nearly 30 years), several incredible Brawl memories are seared into my psyche. I’ve barely seen Pitt and Penn State play.

If my career ended today (don’t you wish), the two sporting events I covered that stand above the rest have their own names: “The Cueto Game” and “13-9.”

I still can’t believe Pitt actually beat West Virginia on that fateful day — Dec. 1, 2007, with a trip to the national championship game at stake for the Mountaineers, who were 28.5-point favorites. They’d outscored Pitt over their previous two meetings, 90-40, and had rolled up 1,092 yards in the process. I think Pat White and Steve Slaton just ran for two more touchdowns.

At halftime of one of those games, a sideline reporter asked Pitt coach Dave Wannstedt what his team needed to do differently.

“Run faster,” he memorably replied.

Advertise with us

I was at WVU’s game the week before “13-9,” one where it posted 66 points and 517 yards on 20th-ranked UConn, while Pitt was giving up 48 points at South Florida.

I honestly believed, given the stakes, that WVU might score 70 on Pitt. Instead, we got the upset of a lifetime — and the scene I will never forget is walking over to WVU coach Rich Rodriguez’s postgame news conference and hearing the Pitt players screaming with joy through the walls behind him.

The stakes aren’t so high for the 107th Backyard Brawl on Saturday, though Pitt would move to 3-0 with a victory, and with Youngstown State next would be looking at its first 4-0 start since 2000.

But those are just numbers. This is about passion. I drag out the following quote just about every time this game is played, so I’ll do it again.

This was Pitt linebacker Scott McKillop, a few years after 13-9, when I asked how his interactions with West Virginians tend to go (ironically, he married a West Virginia girl):

Advertise with us

“I like to reiterate the fact that we basically ruined their whole entire college career,” McKillop said. “Nothing brings me more pleasure than when I say, ‘13-9.’ The face they give me is just priceless.”

So is the rivalry.

It’s the best Pitt has.