Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lee Lacy and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Bobby, @BuStA607: If you can make one renovation at Acrisure stadium what would it be? I like the idea of smokestacks for a steel mill feel.
Starkey: I like that, too, Dr. Bob, but I’d vote for replacing “Renegade” with the Antonio Brown hit “Whole Lotta Money.”
And I have a better question, now that David Morehouse has been promoted within the Steelers organization. It’s a move that has a lot of people believing the Steelers are angling for a new stadium.
Do they they need one anytime soon?
I realize Acrisure Stadium is aging and in seven years will be as old as Three Rivers Stadium was when it was replaced. But unless there is some serious dilapidation that I’m unaware of, I see no need for a new stadium. Especially not one that all of us will be asked to pay for (or at least pay for a lot of). Renovations would be fine as the facility ages.
Read More
The artist formerly known as Heinz Field is a no-frills football field in the middle of a pretty cool restaurant district on the North Shore. Yes, it was the most cheaply built NFL stadium of the 21st Century. Yes, it looks like it was built with LEGO. It’s not particularly attractive. It has none of the bells and whistles of the NFL’s modern-day palaces. So what? It’s a football field.
But I’m not a regular paying customer. You are. So I put the question to Twitter earlier today: Do the Steelers need a new stadium? The vast majority said no.
A sampling of responses:
Brandon Cleary, @BrandonCleary1: I’ve never liked Heinz field. But it is in desperate need of a renovation. Rip yellow seats out and modernize it. Possibly put a retractable dome overtop.
(Starkey: Please do not mention the word “dome.”)
Rlewicki, @RLewicky1417: That shouldn't be the question. The question should be will the Steelers need a new stadium in the next five to eight years. That answer is yes.
Pittsburgh, he walks by night, @dbuls: No, but we will end up paying for it anyway.
Tim DeVita, @pghfan13: I always thought it was terrible. When first built, looked like it they ran out of money and didn't finish.
Mike Seigworth, @mikeseigworth: No, if the Rooneys really want one, they should open their wallets and pay for one themselves.
72foreigner, @hamsun1381: If they pay for it, sure
Tyler Foster, @_Tyler_Foster_: My instinct is no but when you look around the league … it at least needs some major upgrades.
Thank you all.
The Jelly Roger, @BayTed1888: What are your thoughts on the Pirates catching situation? Does Hedges defensive strengths outweigh the offensive woes? Do you think starting Delay more often over the losing streak would have shortened it?
Starkey: They were outscored 44-9 during the losing streak, Dr. Jelly, so I’m not sure Johnny Bench would have helped. But yes, you can only live so long with a .140 hitter getting the majority of your starts. I love what Hedges brings defensively and energetically, but for a team that suddenly cannot hit — this is now eight straight games of two runs or less, which according to AT&T Sportsnet is one game shy of tying the club record — Delay’s bat would seem to be a necessity. And it’s not like he’s been bad defensively.
Martin, @martinrdrgz1986: Hello Joe… do you think Greg Lloyd would have been a HOF if injuries allowed him for a longer career? I personally believe he is in the top list of Steelers LBs. Thanks and all the best from Dubai!
Starkey: That’s a great question, Dr. 1986, and will tell you this much: From 1991 to ’96, Lloyd was a truly dominant player. He twice finished in the top three in voting for NFL Defensive Player of the Year. He was first-team All-Pro three times. Do you know how many players in Steelers history have exceeded that total in their careers?
Here’s the list: Jack Lambert, Jack Ham, Dermontti Dawson, Alan Faneca, Mike Webster, Joe Greene, Rod Woodson, Troy Polamalu, Antonio Brown. That’s it. That’s the list.
Here’s an incomplete list of prominent Steelers with fewer than three first-team All-Pro nominations: Mel Blount, Maurkice Pouncey, David DeCastro, Franco Harris, Jerome Bettis, James Harrison, Terry Bradshaw, John Stallworth, Lynn Swann, Ben Roethlisberger, Joey Porter.
So yeah, Lloyd had one incredible career even if it was somewhat shortened. Was he better than Harrison, who often is mentioned as a borderline Hall of Famer? Let’s take a look at some numbers.
Harrison played in 177 games for the Steelers, Lloyd in 131. Harrison had 80.5 sacks, 772 tackles, 33 forced fumbles, eight fumble recoveries and seven interceptions. Lloyd had 53.5 sacks, 727 tackles, 34 forced fumbles, 15 fumble recoveries and 10 interceptions. So Harrison obviously was more of a pass rusher, but Lloyd — in fewer games — had more forced fumbles, fumble recoveries and picks.
Harrison won defensive player of the year once and was first-team All-Pro twice. Lloyd, as mentioned, topped Harrison in first-team All-Pro nominations but never won DPOY. Both went to the Pro Bowl five times.
Holy bird milk, I think we’re building a HOF case for Greg Lloyd! Certainly, if he’d played longer he’d be a great candidate — and remember, all Halls of Fame these days are Halls of the Very Good. Lloyd was very good.
Blake Stover, @BStover22: What are the thoughts about Cutch’s future? He’s signed a one year deal for this year, more than likely gonna put up some average numbers, will be 37 next year, is he gonna retire as a Pirate? Should he?
Starkey: I say play another year here, Dr. Stover. He’s putting up decent numbers — most impressively, he is on pace for around 30 home runs — and I truly believe his leadership is invaluable to a young team. I’m not sure I want to see him as the automatic No. 3 hitter in the lineup anymore, but why wouldn’t you want him around for another season? Thank goodness for the DH, right?
chadgiron, @chadgiron: Who would be better/who’d you rather have as your QB: 2023 Kenny Pickett, Neil O’Donnell (Steelers prime) or Tommy Maddox (Steelers prime)? Each plays with the rest of the current 2023 offense and defense.
Starkey: Definitely this year Pickett, Dr. Chad, although I had to think about it. Prime Maddox (yes, there was such a thing) lasted for about 10 seconds, although he could definitely fling it around. But he couldn’t move. Neither could O’Donnell, although he had some very decent seasons here, including a Pro Bowl year in 1992.
Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: Has Mitch Keller finally turned the corner?
Starkey: Looks that way to me, Dr. Hilenbrant. Here are his monthly ERAs since the middle of last season:
July, 2022: 2.61 (28 Ks in 31 innings)
August, 2022: 4.70 (20 Ks in 23 innings)
September 2022: 1.80 (28 Ks in 30 innings)
April 2023: 2.90 (32 Ks in 31 innings)
And now, in his first two starts of May — including one of the few complete-game shutouts in 21st Century Pirates baseball — he has 16 strikeouts, two walks and a 0.64 ERA in 14 innings. I think it’s time to start talking contract with a guy who has two years left on his deal. You?
anthony ardestani, @AArdestani247: Pickens>AB….discuss
Starkey: Anthony has lost his mind ... discuss. Come on, Anthony! George Pickens could become a top-five receiver in the NFL and still never be Antonio Brown, who might have been a top-five receiver in NFL history.
You’re better than this.
Sean Gentille, @seangentille: What was your chosen method of grieving the loss of Gordon Lightfoot?
Starkey: Numbing myself any way I could think of, Dr. Gentille, then playing “If You Could Read My Mind” on my guitar. And thank you for asking.
James Kerestes: Why do you address those who write to you as Doctor?
Starkey: I don’t know.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). And subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.