Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Chisenhall (no, really, I got one this week) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Actually, we begin this week with our intergalactically popular Twitter Poll. The question I posed Monday night: Who is the Steelers’ midseason MVP?
I offered T.J. Watt, Bud Dupree, Chris Boswell and “other” as candidates for a two-hour poll. Nearly 1,200 people responded.
Envelopes, please …
Watt: 68%
Other (lots of Minkah write-in votes): 15%
Read More
Boswell: 10%
Dupree: 6%
What we learned: That I probably should have included Minkah Fitzpatrick, and that it’s pretty obvious T.J. Watt is the Steelers’ best player at the midseason point.
Which leads to another question: Is Watt a legit candidate for NFL Defensive Player of the Year?
I say yes, absolutely, although in surveying a bunch of national “Midseason Award” stories, I didn’t find his name one time. The popular pick is New England Patriots cornerback Stephon Gilmore, who is having a phenomenal year. But there is a caveat: The Patriots had played a bunch of pathetic offenses before they ran into Lamar Jackson the other night (Gilmore still graded out nicely). That is about to change with games against Philly, Dallas, Houston and Kansas City.
It’s also difficult to go apples to apples comparing a linebacker to a cornerback, but I’ll say this: When you put Watt against frequently named DPOY candidates in somewhat similar roles, his numbers rank favorably.
Take Nick Bosa, for example.
Bosa, the fabulous 49ers rookie, has seven sacks, 12 tackles for loss, an interception, a pass defensed, a forced fumble and a fumble recovery.
Watt’s overall numbers are better: 7.5 sacks, 11 tackles for loss, an interception, three passes defensed, three forced fumbles and three recovered fumbles.
This might be simplistic, but if you add sacks, tackles for loss, forced fumbles and fumble recoveries, Watt has 24.5, which is better than Aaron Donald (who, to be fair, has nine people blocking him on every play), Cameron Jordan, Jamie Collins Sr. (another popular candidate) and Joey Bosa. It’s just below Myles Garrett’s 25 and Shaq Barrett’s 26.5.
Or, as I look at Pro Football Focus, let’s add up quarterback hits, hurries and sacks and put it under “pressures.” Watt is 10th in the NFL with 42, two fewer than Joey Bosa and Jordan and four more than Nick Bosa.
Watt might not have the media momentum at the moment. But he has the numbers — and a full half-season to go. A Steelers playoff run would surely help his cause.
Brett Light, @brighttlight17: Who would be your choice for the Pirates’ new GM?
Starkey: Billy Owens, assistant general manager and director of player personnel for the Oakland A’s. I’d want somebody known for talent evaluation and acquisition. That is Owens’ job description with the small-market A’s, who continue to open new windows for winning.
Owens also knows all of Billy Beane’s secrets, presumably, which is a plus (and could lead to a movie about the Pirates that isn’t titled “Armageddon”). Not that proximity to greatness equals greatness, as we’ve learned from watching the Bill Belichick coaching tree. But if I’m the Pirates, I’m mining the Rays and A’s baseball operations departments for candidates. I want to know what they know, do what they do.
The Giants reportedly are after Owens, as well, and it’s no guarantee he leaves the A’s. But you asked me a question, and I answered it (which is, after all, the basic premise here).
Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: What do you think about Lonnie Chisenhall for the next Pirates manager? He could manage the team from his home like fantasy baseball. Thoughts?
Starkey: I like the way you think, Donald.
Accion Labs, @JobsAccion: Best Five Steeler Plays in Heinz Field?
Starkey: Off the top of my head, Labs, I’ll go with these five (feel free to correct me if you like) …
5. A.B. executes a flying face kick on punter Spencer Lanning during an epic punt return.
4. Ben to Mike Wallace — high degree of difficulty here — beats Packers on last play of the game.
3. Ben to A.B. fake spike TD pass vs. Cowboys, which, because the Steelers lost, doesn’t get its due as one of the great plays in franchise history.
2. Mr. Big Chest “Immaculate Extension” to beat Ravens — and I never knew there was an NFL Films piece about it. This is amazing stuff:
1. Polamalu pick to clinch AFC championship against Ravens. Go to 4:30 on this clip and relive it. Guarantee it will change your day:
chadgiron, @chadgiron: Better odds: Steelers to make AFC championship or Pitt men’s basketball team to make the NCAA Tournament?
Starkey: I’d say Steelers, based on their schedule, but I am eager to see Pitt. And I shall, on Wednesday night at The Pete. Can we revisit this question in about a month?
hebrew hammer, @hebrewhammer412: Steelers have a chance to go 10-6?
Starkey: There’s always a chance, hammer. I have them beating Cincinnati, Cleveland (once), Buffalo, the Jets and Arizona to go 9-7 and make the playoffs as the second wild card. The Buffalo Bills, by the way, will reach 7-3 before losing six in a row to finish 7-9.
Mark that down.
Edward Christy, @driheet07: Is it time to add the phrase “injury prone” or “oft injured” when mentioning James Conner?
Starkey: Absolutely, Edward — and that is not an insult to Conner. It’s simply a fact. He has suffered several injuries going back to his college career, when he suffered a torn MCL. The latest is the shoulder injury that currently has him sidelined. His physical running style just seems to lend itself to injury. This will factor in, obviously, when it comes time for negotiating his next contract (and that time could come as early as after this season; he has one year left on his rookie deal).
Robert, @base2626: When can we move on from Switz as a returner?????
Michael Edward, @MichaelEdward86: Do you see the Steelers looking to sign a kick returner at some point this season or are we stuck with the touchback being our best option?
Starkey: Funny you should ask, Robert and Michael. I was just looking at return stats. The Steelers are third-last in the NFL in average kickoff return, at a paltry 18.3 yards with a long of 26. Najeh Davenport could do that. They are fifth-worst in punt returns at a pathetic 5.1 and a long of 13. Ricardo Colclough could do that.
It’s past time to give someone else a shot. If the argument against keeping Diontae Spencer was that he was a one-trick pony, what is Ryan Switzer? Spencer has the ninth-longest kickoff return in the NFL this season (52 yards) and the fifth-longest punt return (42 yards). Bad move to cut him.
Sgt Rock, @SgtRock20: You call both Joe Kapp and Jim Colony “Horse.” May I suggest you call Joe Kapp “Bronco” to avoid any confusion?
Starkey: Yes, you may, Sarge. But that doesn’t mean I’ll do it.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for free for our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.