Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Princell Brockenbrough and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Donald Hilenbrant, @Hildebeest24: What percentage odds do you give Pitt of running the table and going 10-2?
Starkey: Around 30%, Donald, and thank you for asking.
Part of me believes Pitt is finally done “Pitting,” a word defined as snatching defeat from the jaws of victory in spectacular and mind-bending ways. Pitt has turned that word into performance art for the better part of the 2000s, but I wonder if the Panthers finally hit rock bottom against Penn State, when Pat Narduzzi capitulated at the goal line, and might never Pitt again.
Look at what’s happened since: They nearly Pitted in every game only to pull a Reverse Pitt and win each time. They blew a 21-0 lead against UCF, needed a late score to stave off Delaware, blew a 26-3 lead against Duke and nearly a 24-6 lead against Syracuse and lived to tell about each adventure.
That could either be worrisome or heartening. Or both. Maybe the Panthers’ best football is in front of them. Or maybe they will Pitt away a game they should win.
Read More
Who can tell for sure?
The defense is outstanding. Kenny Pickett clearly is making progress. Pitt might be favored in every game from here on out. It might well win all five.
But I have to see it to believe Pitt — and to believe that all the Pitting is done.
Which brings us to a brief Twitter Poll. I posted the following question for one hour Monday:
“Pitt win total before bowls … 10, 9, 8, other.”
Of the 432 responses, 49% said 9, 32% said 8, 12% said 9 and 7% said other.
What we learned: That many others have to see it to believe Pitt, as well.
Nick Bertoni, @dani3lt0sh: Where do you rank the Steelers defense this year overall so far?
Starkey: I’d make them a borderline top 10 defense at the moment, Nick. They were bad in two games (New England, Seattle), just good enough to not win in two others (San Francisco, Baltimore) and really good against teams with horrendous offensive lines — the Chargers and Bengals. They have a lot of proving to do.
The rank eighth in the meaningless category of yards allowed and 14th in the important category of points allowed. They have created a ton of turnovers and are seventh in sacks. They are 18th against the run and haven’t closed games when given the opportunity. A decidedly mixed bag so far, but the arrow is pointed up.
MattK IX, @MattKriz: Is Marc Andre Fleury a Hall of Fame goalie? Even with 3 Cups I think it was iffy as a Penguin but he’s truly been elite in Vegas and I think that has put him over the top in my mind.
Starkey: Marc-Andre Fleury is absolutely a Hall of Famer, Mattie, even if his career goals-against average (2.55) and save percentage (.913) won’t blow anyone away.
Fleury still has a chance to finish his career with the second-most victories of all time. He is seventh at the moment, with 445. The only active goalie ahead of him is Henrik Lundqvist at 450. Nobody’s going to catch Martin Brodeur at 691, but if Fleury wins 100 more games, he will be within six of Patrick Roy’s 551. That is quite possible.
As for how much goalie wins should be valued, well. that’s a good conversation. Much like pitching wins in baseball, goalie wins are often the product of a good team. Fleury has played on many good teams. But he didn’t always play on teams that were especially interested in defense. He usually faced tons of high-quality chances. And he won a ton of games.
It’s not easy to play 60-plus games year after year and deliver a consistently high level of play. Fleury did that here.
He also won a Stanley Cup and did the heavy lifting on the way to another, stoning the Washington Capitals in 2017.
And yes, you’re right, his numbers in Vegas have been mostly outstanding. He’s a Hall of Famer in my book. We’ll see someday if voters agree.
Brett C. Williams, @BrettCWilliams: Best uniform in the 80s...any sport. I’ll start...MLB - St.Louis Cardinals.
Starkey: Nice pick. I’ll go with …
5. Sacramento Kings beautiful blue:
4. Vancouver Canucks insanity:
3. Cleveland Cavaliers white with orange lettering:
1. Los Angeles Lakers purple (and look here at the original Lakers jerseys; not bad)
Hank Hill, @HankManager: Why do the Pittsburgh media still not giving the Ravens credit?
Starkey: It’s always interesting when people speak of the “Pittsburgh media,” or any town’s media, as if it’s a single entity with one brain. Who do you speak of, Henry? Who in particular?
I can only speak for myself, and I give the Ravens immense credit for beating what appears to be a decent Seattle team in a difficult environment. I give Lamar Jackson credit, although his offense only scored 16 points. He is incredibly entertaining. I give the defense all kinds of credit for scoring twice and stifling the great Russell Wilson.
Do you want me to give the Ravens credit for a division title they haven’t yet won? Do you want me to call them a great team? They lost to the Browns, 40-25. They have one really good win (Seattle). I’m not sure what you’re looking for here. I’m looking for more, though the Ravens, clearly, have become the AFC North favorites. Credit them for that.
Enola Fan, @Enolafan: Have a favorite NBA over-under bet?
Starkey: Yes, EF, I do: Steph Curry over/under 30 ppg: OVER.
Steph will be on a mission from the Basketball Gods. He will light people up like a pinball machine: 30.1 ppg.
Bonus play: D’Angelo Russell over/under 20 ppg: OVER. DeAngelo will be on a mission from the Basketball Gods. He will light people up like a pinball machine. 20.5 ppg.
Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Sign up for our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed, for free.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.