Penn State came out flying against Michigan on Saturday night. That’s sort of what you would expect from the Nittany Lions in their annual White Out game.
The defense, specifically, set the tone. The Wolverines’ first five drives ended: punt, punt, punt, turnover on downs, interception. By the time Michigan got the ball back for its sixth possession, the Nittany Lions were up 21-0.
Mainly, what Penn State did defensively was play with a sort of aggression appropriate for the occasion. In simpler terms, the Nittany Lions sent blitzes early and often.
By the time the second quarter rolled around, they had Wolverines quarterback Shea Patterson seemingly shook.
The Nittany Lions’ aggressiveness messed with everything to the point that simple dump-offs to the running back...
... and screen passes...
Read More
... weren’t all that simple.
But as the game wore on, Patterson settled in. Michigan employed a lot of bubble screens and quick-hitting plays to get the ball out of his hands faster, and it eventually got him in a rhythm.
In the second half, Patterson was unfazed and started finding receivers in big spots, even when the Nittany Lions blitzed.
In total, Michigan ran 82 offensive plays and possessed the ball for at least nine minutes in every quarter, thanks in large part to the groove Patterson found.
By the time the Wolverines’ crunch-time, potential-game-tying drive came around at the end of the fourth quarter, Penn State didn’t blitz on late downs, dropped back into zone and couldn’t really stop Michigan.
Then, the Nittany Lions’ defense stiffened up and saved the game.
On first-and-goal, they blitzed and stuffed a run:
On second-and-goal, they blitzed and stuffed a run:
On third-and-goal, they blitzed, nearly got to Patterson and forced a throw out of the back of the end zone:
On fourth-and-goal, the result likely overshadows what happened on the play. Sure, Michigan receiver Ronnie Bell probably could have hauled in the pass and tied the game, but the play was actually quite well defended.
Watch cornerback Tariq Castro-Fields on the far side. Patterson clearly wants to throw that way, but Castro-Fields has it snuffed out, defending against the back-shoulder fade and forcing Patterson to go elsewhere.
Now watch defensive end Yetur Gross-Matos. He didn’t have a single quarterback hit all night, and yet, here he is, busting tail around the tackle and forcing Patterson to move.
The result is what it is. Safety Lamont Wade said he tipped the pass, but it was probably still catchable. Nonetheless, it was, inarguably, a well-defended play.
What all of this means schematically is that Penn State’s aggressiveness was good, but it leaves it open to certain things. If the Nittany Lions don’t consistently get home for a few sacks, a good quarterback can settle in and have success, potentially with the help of quick-hitting plays.
In a more important sense, though, the Nittany Lions’ defense bent, but when the chips were down, they didn’t break. So for all the flaws that might have shown up in the second half, Penn State’s defense did enough to win.
Matchup mashup
Michigan runs, largely, a man-concept defense. The Wolverines have implemented a bit more zone coverage recently, but they are mostly an aggressive, blitz-heavy team.
Anyone who has seen the Wolverines play in the last five seasons knows this, which, obviously, includes the Nittany Lions.
So early in Saturday’s game, Penn State seemed to run a bit of a feeling-out process.
Just as much as it is no secret that Michigan mostly plays man-to-man, it is no secret that the Nittany Lions want to get wide receiver KJ Hamler the football. Here, they line up Hamler in the backfield and motion him to the outside. Wolverines cornerback Lavert Hill, their best pass-coverage player, follows Hamler.
So Penn State now knows the Wolverines are in man, and they know the matchups. Hill has Hamler and Michigan linebacker/nickle Khaleke Hudson has tight end Pat Freiermuth. The Nittany Lions like the latter pairing, so they hit Freiermuth on the quick out for a positive gain.
The first sort of play sets up Penn State for this sort of play. Again, Freiermuth has a favorable matchup against Hudson.
Freiermuth sets up his man with a stutter, then runs a fade route, and quarterback Sean Clifford doesn’t hesitate at all, hitting his tight end to open the scoring.
Sure, Freiermuth might have gotten away with a push-off to create some separation in the end zone, but it wasn’t called, and as they say, rubbin’s racin’.
All of this — the threat of Freiermuth, the patience with Hamler, the fade route from the slot position — begets Penn State’s third touchdown.
Here’s the same formation as the first touchdown, just flipped.
Now look at the routes.
Freiermuth is one on one with Hudson again. He gets off the line, fakes to the outside, then cuts in on a slant route.
Hamler, on the other hand, fakes inward on the safety who is covering him, then bursts to the outside. It’s his turn to run the fade route. Again, Clifford knows what he has, and he doesn’t waste a moment, putting the Nittany Lions up three scores halfway through the second quarter.
Penn State knew it was going to get one-on-one coverage on Saturday night. So the Nittany Lions set it up perfectly, made sure they knew exactly what they were looking at and took advantage of their matchups early.
Running into walls
Penn State ended Saturday’s game with just 101 rushing yards on 29 carries, averaging 3.5 yards per rush.
Of those 101 yards, 44 came on one play, a second-quarter burst from running back Ricky Slade. Take that big gain away, and the numbers get worse.
It’s interesting, because it’s a departure from what Penn State has been able to do so far this season on the ground, averaging 192.7 yards on the ground in the first six games of the season.
Part of it can be chalked up to the fact the Wolverines, who allow less than 130 yards per game on the ground. The concern, however, is that the Nittany Lions still have to play two teams — Michigan State and Ohio State — which have even better rush defenses than Michigan’s.
It can be hard, though, to break down offensive line play, but an extremely basic view of things would be to look at the kind of push a line is getting and whether or not they are getting to the second level to put blocks on linebackers.
For example, here is Slade’s 44-yard burst:
This just open up like the Red Sea. Guard Steven Gonzalez and center Michael Menet do wall off the defensive tackles well, though, to create the hole.
But the Wolverines don’t exactly defend it well. Their linebackers fill the wrong gaps and get caught up in the wash. Penn State right guard CJ Thorpe does get on to Michigan’s Cam McGrone, No. 44, but Hudson doesn’t really get touched, he just reads it wrong.
Meanwhile, the Wolverines’ safety covers the threat of Clifford pulling the ball, and suddenly there’s nobody on the second level to stop Slade.
So while this was Penn State’s best play on the ground, it might not be the best play to illustrate the Nittany Lions’ line’s play.
This seems to be the same play design but flipped. Here, Gonzalez is at right guard, and defensive tackle Michael Dwumfour beats him and blows up the entire play. The linebackers fill from there, and running back Journey Brown is done before he even starts.
Contrast that with this:
Same play design again. Gonzalez, now at left guard, holds his own against Dwumfour, forcing him outside. Right guard CJ Thorpe takes on defensive tackle Carlo Kemp by himself, and Menet is allowed to move up to McGrone to spring Cain for a four-yard carry. No, four yards aren’t all that much, but it is the difference between keeping an offense on schedule and getting behind the chains.
Plus, it allowed this first down to happen:
This is a different play, and it’s one that Penn State hasn’t run often, if at all.
Nonetheless, it is well blocked against a defense that knows that the Nittany Lions are going to run the ball.
Thorpe and Freiermuth pull around to lead the way for Hamler. Freiermuth gets a good block on Hudson, but Thorpe is the star here. With a single shove, he pushes Michigan linebacker Jordan Glasgow 3 yards backward. The combination of that, along with tight end Nick Bowers’ kick-out block, gives Hamler just enough room to fight forward for the first down.
So, this point is oddly similar to the one made earlier about Penn State’s defense. In the end, the Nittany Lions did enough to win the football game, and that is what matters. But there are still some holes that can be seen throughout Saturday’s game.
The positive news is that when Penn State diagnoses its problems after a win, it will be a lot more palatable than it would have been had it lost.
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.