Mike Tomlin talks competition at the kicker position and Devin Bush

Why the rush?

Mike Tomlin had two years left on his contract, and last season was calamitous enough to justify making him wait and earn another extension.

Tomlin presided over one of the worst collapses in franchise history. He helped create the monster that was "Big Chest." He admitted he could have put an injured Ben Roethlisberger back into the catastrophic Oakland game a “series or so earlier,” a move that might have prevented all the late drama. He has three playoff wins — one a gift-wrapped miracle, another against Matt Moore — in the past eight years.

What would have been the harm in discarding the franchise tradition of extending a coach with two years left on his deal? Why not see if Tomlin could re-affirm his authority and return his team to legitimate Super Bowl contention?

Advertise with us

Was the concern that Tomlin might win the Super Bowl and price himself out of town? That he might bet on himself with one year left on his deal and refuse to sign an extension?

Those are risks I would have taken.

One could still label this a “prove it” season for Tomlin, considering the extension announced Thursday is only for one guaranteed year. But the Steelers termed it as taking Tomlin “at least” through the 2021 season, and that’s because there’s an option year at the end, as the coach confirmed Thursday.

The good news is that Tomlin’s contract status won’t be a constant storyline. Then again, it quickly will return to one if the Steelers struggle, given the fact that Tomlin would go into the 2020 season with … all together now … two years left on his contract.

I don’t know if I can take another offseason filled with Tomlin contract hot takes (including mine).

Advertise with us

In the meantime, believing the Steelers should have held off here is not the same as predicting they will stink. To the contrary, they have a chance to be really good. They still have an elite quarterback, a Pro Bowl running back, a star receiver, a high-quality offensive line, and an intriguing defense featuring some new pieces.

It’s also a defense that is more and more Tomlin’s — and this is the year it must take a giant leap forward.

Change can be good. The biggest one was the “cleansing” of the locker room, to borrow Tomlin’s phrase. That was obviously a reference to Antonio Brown, although Tomlin seemed less than enamored with Le’Veon Bell by the end, as well, even if Bell was just a ghost last season. You might remember the “we need volunteers, not hostages” quote.

Another interesting change: New assistant Teryl Austin will help with challenges, offering advice from the press box. Tomlin hasn’t won a challenge since Dick LeBeau played cornerback in Detroit. The potential problem is that Austin also is the team’s senior defensive assistant and secondary coach. So will he be analyzing the defense overall and the secondary in particular during games, in addition to his replay duties?

How will that work? I wonder, because the new interference policy alone would require one’s undivided attention on every pass play, attempting to determine if calls and non-calls are challengeable.

Advertise with us

Why not just hire a full-time replay person? I also would have hired an analytics expert for input on clock management and other specialized situations. Other coaches have them.

The Steelers seem to believe last year’s meltdown was mostly a matter of a few missed field goals. The Oakland loss and the Cleveland tie stand out, but from this vantage point, it wasn’t as simple as “Boswell blew it.”

The Steelers never should have been mired in death struggles with two terrible teams (and the pre-Baker Browns were terrible). Blaming Chris Boswell ignores the fact that the Steelers blew a 21-7 lead at Cleveland and that his late miss in Oakland only would have tied the score.

Think they were gonna stop A.B.’s close personal friend Derek Carr in overtime?

Many of the past eight Steeler seasons have ended in abject humiliation, whether it was missing the playoffs two years in a row or Tim Tebow lighting them up or Tom Brady destroying that soft little zone or the mouthy Jaguars putting 45 on them or what happened last year, when a dispirited bunch barely beat the Bengals’ JV team and was reduced to praying for help from the Cleveland Browns.

Advertise with us

Tomlin’s done plenty of winning in that time, too, and he might do plenty more this season — even after December.

I just didn’t see the harm in waiting to find out.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.