In many ways, Felipe Vazquez is the Pirates’ perfect player: fairly young, very cheap, awfully good and entirely controllable. He is under club control through the 2023 season, including the next two years at the bargain-basement rate of $13.5 million (total).
Bob Nutting dreams of players like this.
But all of what makes Vazquez so desirable to the Pirates makes him desirable elsewhere, as well, in a league where contenders are dying for shutdown bullpen arms. Vazquez is the ideal trade chip, and unless the Pirates believe a World Series run is imminent, they have to at least be open to dealing him.
What good is a lights-out closer if you’re not a legit contender?
The Pirates are in a great position here. Maybe they buck the odds and make a run before the July 31 trade deadline, don’t get an offer that blows them away and keep Vazquez. Nothing wrong with that. Maybe they keep him for two more years, believing they will have a contending team. They might. There is some interesting young talent on hand here.
But they can also ask for the world, right now, and you know what? They just might get it.
Read More
That’s where the Los Angeles Dodgers come in. They have inquired about Vazquez, according to a report from MLB.com’s Jon Paul Morosi, and they are desperate. They are becoming the Buffalo Bills of the 2000s — the “Lose Again” Dodgers, as they’ve been called (unfairly, if you ask me).
The Dodgers keep winning division titles (six in row) and keep losing the biggest games. They fell in the NLCS three years ago and have lost each of the past two World Series. The way things are trending, they might forget about Vazquez and trade for Thurman Thomas next month.
There is tremendous pressure on the Dodgers to finish the deal, and everybody knows what they need: bullpen help. One could easily make the case that Vazquez is the missing piece, the one player who could end all that postseason misery.
Now the great news: The Dodgers have a deep and widely acclaimed minor league system. The Pirates could set a price and not budge. Maybe the Dodgers offer the kind of package the Cubs offered for Aroldis Chapman a few years ago.
Meanwhile, great as Vazquez is, the Pirates could always find another qualified closer. Their recent history indicates as much. They more or less went from Joel Hanrahan to Jason Grilli to Mark Melancon to Vazquez.
Some successful teams don’t even use a traditional closer. Others change closers and hardly suffer. Consider the fact that seven consecutive World Series champions changed closers between opening day and the end of the season before the Red Sox won it all with traditional closer Craig Kimbrel.
That all tells me there are plenty of pitchers capable of finishing games. The Pirates would need to find another if they traded Vazquez. I’m guessing they would. It’s also fair to note that bullpens in general and closers in particular can be wildly unpredictable from year to year. Will Vazquez be this dominant in 2022? Who could know?
None of which is meant to diminish his rare talent and production. He’s amazing, and everybody knows it.
The Pirates would be foolish not to listen, at least.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.