The sight of Gerrit Cole pitching against the Pirates might have stirred some emotion in you Tuesday night. Maybe anger. Maybe sadness.
It stirred an old question in me, and a desire to set the record straight.
What really happened to the 98-win Pirates of 2015?
That team still had a relatively young core. It boasted a perennial MVP candidate in Andrew McCutchen, a bona fide ace in the 24-year-old Cole, and several enticing 20-somethings in the likes of Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco and Jung Ho Kang. Even Francisco Cervelli hadn’t yet hit 30. Three straight playoff appearances seemed like a beginning, not an end.
What happened?
The reflexive answer, and I’ve heard it a million times, is to say the Pirates “dismantled” the 2015 team. The second reflex, directly related, is to blame Bob Nutting for everything that went wrong.
Read More
Nutting’s not blameless. Not by a long shot. The Pirates failed to add to that club. But that doesn't make Nutting the key figure in the sudden demise of a 98-win team. General manager Neal Huntington isn't the key figure, either (though he, too, must share blame).
The cause of death was the players themselves, whether through natural attrition (A.J. Burnett, Francisco Liriano), sudden plunge in performance (McCutchen, Cole), sudden inability to play baseball (Pedro Alvarez), rotten luck (Cervelli), or, eventually, idiotic behavior (Kang, Marte).
Other factors were not minor. They included Nutting’s persistent parsimony and the organization’s arrogant belief it could take any pitcher in baseball, be it the broken down (Ryan Vogelsong), the underperforming (Jon Niese) or the underqualified (Juan Nicasio) and magically transform them into impact starters.
Here’s the thing, though: Even if the Pirates weren’t so cheap, and even if they did purchase a significant player or two, and even if they didn’t let their pitcher-rehab success go to their heads, the 2015 team was headed for a painful fall. We know that now.
We should, anyway. The hard truth is that the 2013-15 Pirates were bound for the same heap as so many other talented, promising teams across sports history — the one labeled, “Gone Too Soon, Didn’t Get it Done.”
So let’s set the record straight, once and for all: The Pirates did not “dismantle” a 98-win team; a 98-win team dismantled itself.
This is what happened …
• McCutchen, the franchise centerpiece, shockingly disintegrated. He had the worst year of his career in 2016 and hasn’t been the same player since. What was going to make up for that?
• Maybe the rise of Marte and Polanco could have made up for that, but after a stellar 2016, Marte got himself suspended for most of 2017, helping to wreck that season, and Polanco basically flat-lined. He’s still not nearly the player the Pirates projected him to be. These two were paid to secure the future and did not deliver.
• Alvarez, seen as another core player, woke up one day and couldn’t throw or catch a baseball anymore. He was gone after 2015. Who could have predicted that? And if you consider getting rid of Alvarez part of the “dismantling,” I got nothin’ for ya.
• Neil Walker, another key piece, and a lightning rod for hindsight criticism, would finish the following season on the New York Mets’ injured list. You had people calling for the Pirates to spend $15 million a year on Walker after 2015. The club wisely declined and unwisely brought in Niese. But to look back and include Walker as part of the “dismantling” is silly.
Two facts …
1. Teams weren’t exactly breaking down the Pirates’ door with enticing returns for Walker, for the same reasons the Pirates weren’t offering him, say, a three-year, $45 million deal. He was into his 30s with a recent injury history (though he did play 151 games in '15).
2. He hasn’t played in more than 113 games since 2015. He would have been a bad investment.
• Burnett was the stunningly unexpected key to the 2015 season, making the All-Star team with a 2.11 ERA. That was blind luck on the Pirates’ part. Nobody expected that performance. Burnett wound up with a 3.18 ERA and a dead arm. He retired after the season.
• Kang, who had the look of a star, was having a stellar 2015 season when he suffered a horrific injury against Chicago. He ran into major legal troubles after that and wasn’t seen again until this season. He is a shell of his former self.
• Cervelli — tremendous in 2015 —hasn’t played in as many as 105 games in any season since.
• Cole, one of the better pitchers in baseball in 2015, was not that in 2016 and was flat-out bad in 2017.
• Liriano, a stud in 2015, went into rapid decline.
Then, of course, there is the J.A. Happ story, and its lack of a Happ-y ending. The Pirates absolutely should have made a good-faith effort to retain him. But if your definition of “dismantle” rests on the chance Happ would have stayed in Pittsburgh, please refer to the end of the Alvarez section.
That team was headed south no matter what. The core had run its course. We just didn’t know it at the time.
The 2015 Pirates were not dismantled. They dismantled themselves.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.