One day soon the Penguins brain trust will sit down and chart the course of the future. And while I do not pretend to know Mario Lemieux, Ron Burkle, Jim Rutherford or Mike Sullivan all that well, I know this: Each has a bit of ruthlessness in him.

I mean that as a positive. You don’t get to where those men have gotten without the ruthless gene — and when it comes to evaluating this roster, ruthlessness must rule the day.

First, the group must answer two key questions:

1. How do we want to play?

Advertise with us

2. How do we tailor the roster toward that style of play?

Before they start, the men might want to send the New York Islanders a thank-you note, because the Islanders exposed the Penguins’ primary issues. They shined a bright light on the Penguins’ declining mobility, advancing age and continued propensity for high-risk hockey.

I probably don’t need to tell you that the first two issues don’t mesh with the third.

The Penguins play in a division where young, quick teams such as the Islanders and Carolina Hurricanes are on the rise. … That doesn’t mean the Penguins need to form a track team. It doesn’t mean they need to skate circles around people, the way they did in 2016. But they need to get quicker, particularly on the blue line.

They also need to play a more structured, defensively conscious game. They don’t need to copy the Islanders or the mid-1990s New Jersey Devils. They just need to be more focused on making sound decisions with the puck.

Advertise with us

Sounds simple enough, but the Penguins keep relapsing. They still fall in love with themselves and that wondrous skill too often.

To that end, some impossibly tough decisions lay ahead. I suppose one could make the argument to take one more shot with the same group. Maybe this was just a bad matchup, right? Maybe. But combine it with with last year’s early exit, and the arrow clearly is pointing down.

Something has to change. Something significant.

In the same category as the obvious untouchable — Sidney Crosby — I would put Evgeni Malkin, Jake Guentzel and Matt Murray. That leaves a lot of roster to work with and would include the possibility of moving decorated and beloved veterans such as Patric Hornqvist, Phil Kessel and/or Kris Letang.

The first hard decision, however, must be to part ways with Jack Johnson. He was a good soldier, but the Penguins cannot move ahead with a plodding, 32-year-old defenseman whom Sullivan chose to scratch for the playoff opener even though Johnson played all 82 games. There might be a scant or nonexistent market for Johnson, who has four years left on his deal, but whatever it takes, the Penguins must act.

Advertise with us

Kessel might have hit his expiration date here. Nobody would be surprised if the Penguins move on from him, painful as that would be.

Hornqvist is in many ways the soul of the team. He also got pulled off the first power play, hit a major goal-scoring slump, was not given another opportunity to play with Crosby despite the Penguins’ scoring issues and is dealing with a growing concussion history. I’d be tempted to keep him in hopes of a bounce-back season — he still has three years at $5.3 million per season remaining on his deal — but I’d listen to offers.

That leaves Letang, a warrior if ever there was one but a player who seemingly cannot shake his high-risk habits and turns 32 next week. In many ways, Letang is the barometer for the rest of the team. He’s out there for nearly half the game. When he is right, he is sublime — and he was sublime for most of the regular season.

When he breaks bad, the whole ship sinks.

Fair or not, it’s a fact the Penguins won a Stanley Cup without Letang and flourished down the stretch this season without him. They were basically forced to play a more structured game, to take a reduced-risk approach with the puck.

Advertise with us

Letang is signed for three more years at $7.25 million per season. He has given his heart and soul to this franchise. Fans love him, and for good reason.

But if the Penguins find the right package (Letang has a limited no-trade clause), it might be best to move on.

Painful, yes. But necessary.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan