Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Actually, we begin today with our intergalactically popular Twitter Polls segment. Today’s question had drawn nearly 2,000 responses at the time of this writing:
Joe Starkey, @JoeStarkey1: Greatest play in Steelers history ...
45% Immaculate Reception
24% J Harrison Super Bowl TD
29% Ben to Santonio
Read More
02% Other?
What we learned: Man, James Harrison must have turned off a lot of fans. Part of that was defecting to New England (which was his right). Part of it was tales of his pathetic “leadership” last season. Leadership, one could argue, begins with a self-policing locker room, and what does it say when an accomplished veteran like Harrison sets the worst example of anyone on the team?
Part of it, too, has to be Harrison’s traitorous behavior since then:
I mean, the Immaculate Reception stands as the greatest play in Steelers history. I’m not surprised by the vote there. But I would have thought Harrison’s miraculous interception return would be second.
Then again, Ben to Santonio was an amazingly skilled play on both ends and WON THE SUPER BOWL
All things considered, I’m with this reader …
Terry Kelly, @kellytm: It was honestly a tough call for me between Immaculate Reception (one of the two or three most *famous* plays in NFL history), and Harrison’s return (one of the *greatest* plays in NFL history.) They are 1 and 1A in my book.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What was the worst part of the Super Bowl? The game, the commercials, the halftime show or the Pats winning again?
Starkey: The Patriots winning again didn’t bother me one bit. At some point, Mr. FakeHoltzy22, you have to stand back and admire their greatness. Do yourself a favor and read here how Belichick once again went a long way toward winning a game before it began.
Meantime, the commercials were frighteningly dumb, the halftime show was bizarre and even the postgame scene went off the rails, as Tracy Wolfson appeared to briefly disappear in a sea of humanity. I will say this, though: The chaotic postgame scene was more entertaining than the game.
Nothing was as bad as the game. Was it the worst Super Bowl ever? Yes. Yes it was. I will not remember a single play outside of Brady pass to Gronk to set up the only touchdown. And even that was just a nice pass. Nothing more.
This was probably the best play of the game:
The Five Worst Super Bowls of All-Time:
5. Dallas 24, Miami 3. At least Ditka scored.
4. Seattle 43, Denver 8. So bad they let Tarvaris Jackson throw a pass.
4. Broncos 34, Falcons 19. Wait, Cornelius Bennett started for the Falcons? And lost his fifth Super Bowl?
3. 49ers 55, Broncos 10. It was 41-3 in the third quarter.
2. Ravens 34, Giants 7. The winning quarterback (Trent Dilfer) went 12 for 25.

Craig Meyer, @CraigMeyerPG: You're walking down a dark alley late at night and fear for your safety. Which three athletes in Pittsburgh sports history do you want walking with you?
Starkey: Joe Greene, Gary Roberts, Sam Clancy.
Thank you Craig. Your Pitt basketball coverage has been sublime, as always, and this question sparked a number of responses among the readership, including one from our friend Chris LaSala at Pitt.
A sampling …
Chris LaSala, @cjlquips: Battleship Kelly, Georges Laraque and Gary Roberts
Boomer Heeter, @golfingbulldawg: Mel Blount, Mean Joe and Jack Lambert.
Yinzer4Life, @eckert1952: Fritzie Zivic, Bruno Sammartino, Joe Greene.
Orlando Carr: @MichaelKeaton “I’m Batman,” Arron Asham @TheRealAsham45, Hines Ward @mvp86hinesward
JeffandLisaWander, @LisaJeffand: That question is so idiotic, it doesn’t deserve a response
Jack Reidy, @jkmreidy: Ernie Holmes. Nobody else needed.
Jude Liptak, @PuckStopper86: Ditka, Georges Laraque, and Jay Caufield
David, @davidwkay: Dave Parker, Ed Ott, Jack Lambert
Tim McAloon, @tjmcaloonsr: This actually happened to my wife and me. We needed to walk through French Way downtown about 2:30 a.m. several years ago. As luck would have it, right before we turned down the alley, Max Starks exited his building and was walking right in front of us. We felt very safe.
David H, @dhodosrj: Ron Stackhouse, Lee Mazilli and Bennie Cunningham
Tim Bowers, @TimBowers62: Billy Conn, Casey Hampton, Chevy Troutman
John Turcovsky, @johnturk17: Kurt Angle, Bruno Sammartino, Marty McSorley
Ted, @karamazov_37: Arnold Palmer, Sergei Plotnikov, Honus Wagner (editor’s note: this is actually brilliant, because with Plotnikov around, you know absolutely nothing would happen).
Louis Diana, @LouisDiana1: 1) Greg Lloyd 2) Greg Lloyd 3) A Greg Lloyd-sized Greg Lloyd
Thomas Foster, @ThomasFoster12: Ernie Stautner, Joe Greene, Jack Lambert
Bill Gaughan, @BillGaughan: Tony Siragusa, Jack Lambert, Dave Parker
Tap, @tapbrrap: Mean Joe, Rick Tocchet, Al Villanueva
runningbeam, @runningbeam: Staying completely in WPIAL QUAD A EAST — Bill Fralic, Mike Halapin, Bob Buczkowski ... strength, size and just enough crazy in their eyes
Vince DeAugustine, @VinnyD16: Paul Spadafora, Jack Lambert, Kurt Angle
Davin13, @wdavin13: Jack Lambert, James Harrison, Greg Lloyd

chadgiron, @chadgiron: Does Julian Edelman’s PED suspension count as “cheating”? (The answer is yes).
Starkey: Why wouldn’t it? He cheated, got caught, served his punishment. Are people saying he didn’t cheat? What is your point?
On Edelman, by the way, a plea to the populace: Let’s pump the brakes on the Hall of Fame talk — which Adam Schefter started with a tweet the other day. Jericho Cotchery has more career catches than Julian Edelman.
Joey Wagner, @TheTruthSwagner: Do you think Tom Brady and Bill Belichick win their 7th Super Bowl before the Steelers do?
Starkey: Tom Brady will not win another Super Bowl. You read it here first. That doesn’t mean I believe the Steelers will win another before Belichick does.
Tim Sackski, @SackskiTim: How big is your mailbag?
Starkey: Bigger than yours.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.