Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started soon.
Waldo Jeffers: The Rams should probably fire Sean McVay, right? That’s what you do when your coach doesn’t make half-time adjustments and loses the big game, right? You fire him. His team also got hit with a too-many-men-on-the-field flag, so clearly they’re all undisciplined divas.
Ray Fittipaldo: Sean McVay, like hundreds of coaches before him, was outclassed by Bill Belichick. Belihick stopped the run and forced Jared Goff to win the game. He failed miserably. I saw the Rams on a few occasions during the season and I never thought they had great WRs. That was proven last night. Brandin Cooks came up very small on the few occasions he had a chance to step up and make a play.
DW: Ray, were you surprised Faneca didn't get into the HOF this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: No because I had been hearing it was going to be hard for him to get in this year. I was surprised that Kevin Mawae got it. He was the only one of the four offensive line up for the hall this year that did get in. Faneca, along with Tony Boselli and Steve Hutchinson did not make it. As most of you know, Faneca had more Pro Bowls and All-Pro honors than any of the other four linemen. Mawae only had three All-Pro selections. The good news for Faneca is the only slam dunk first ballot Hall of Famer in the 2020 class is Troy Polamlau. That should allow Faneca and others an easier path next year.
DaquidoBazzini is: Hi, Ray - I know it’s probably not there, but at what point does the tampering line get crossed with Antonio Brown and the SF 49ers?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good question. For the most part, it's been mostly Brown making overtures toward the 49ers and not the other way around. 49ers TE George Kittle wrote something on Twitter, but he's a player and not a member of the front office.
BB: Ray - Thanks for the chats. In last night's game, it looked like both teams have defensive backs and linebackers who can actually run and cover their opponent.....and a coaching staff that game plans and makes adjustments....the Steelers are more than a player or two away?
Ray Fittipaldo: It was a good night for the defenses. The Rams were impressive. The only issue they had was covering Edelman and many others have failed in doing that. Littleton, the ILB from the Rams, impressed me. You're right. The ILBs on both teams were close to receivers all night. That's what the Steelers need. Devin White and Devin Bush are the two best ILBs in this year's draft. Both would look great in a Steelers uniform.
Sam: Is there any greater summary of the divergent direction the 2 franchises exist in than the fact that on the same day as we watch the Patriots match the Steelers with 6 rings, we have to read reports that the Steelers are actually considering using another tag on Le’Veon Bell?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's offseason business. The Steelers are trying to make sure they get max value in return for Bell leaving. If the transition tag does than then so be it. They would not be tagging Bell to keep him.
Jeff Haney: What are the Steelers top 3 needs (in your opinion) come draft day?
Ray Fittipaldo: ILB, CB, OLB. WR enters the equation if Antonio Brown is traded.
Ryno: Any chance Burnett announced he wants out of Pittsburgh because he figured the Steelers wouldnt keep him because of his performance and injuries? Maybe hoping other teams would have soe interest that way?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's a good assumption. He was injured a lot and the team could not depend on him. By asking for his release, he might have been trying to make himself more attractive to other teams. Either way, it was an odd move and one that did not put him in a very positive light.
SCL: Ray, if there is an equally rated first round corner and inside linebacker available when we pick, who do you think we pull the trigger on?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. I would say ILB because you might be able to find a good outside corner in the second round. The number of fast, three-down ILBs isn't that long. I have Devin White and Devin Bush as my top two, and I would not draft another one in the first round. Mack Wilson of Alabama is probably third in that list, but he's not as fast or explosive as the Devins.
PANTS: Hi Ray---- I understand when james harrison is killing tomlin and brown and bells issues but now Hines ward demolished them the other day basically laughing at them , doesnt that have to have rooneys seriously thinking of making a change?? Oh and i forgot about rocky bleier
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's part of the reason Art II did not commit to signing Tomlin to an extension in July. It's obvious there are some major issues facing the team and Tomlin will be challenged to right the ship. Other than Brown, I think all those other guys simply want what's best for the organization, and they're speaking their mind on what they see.
Ryan: Do you think the Steelers will go Draft or Free Agency to fill their ILB need? My guess is they will go with a combo but the starter will come via the draft.
Ray Fittipaldo: I could envision signing an ILB that could start but in an ideal world would be a top backup. I'm thinking Sean Lee if he's released and wants to come home to finish his career. He's older, but he's a leader and he can still run well enough. But make no mistake, they need to get a young three-down ILB in the draft if the right one is there.
Justin: When will the Steelers take notice of the Patriots running attack and deploy Nix more often?
Ray Fittipaldo: I tweeted a story on Bill Belichick last week. The premise was he zigs when the rest of the league zags. While the Steelers and a lot of other teams threw the ball more than they ever have Belichick figured out that these lighter/heavy defensive back packages were susceptible to the run. It's one of the things that makes him so great. He can see the future before it's here.

Steeltown: Do you think Steelers can be better without LB&AB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, did you see the Patriots win the Super Bowl with guys like Julian Edelman, Chris Hogan, James White, Rex Burkhead? It can be done. Can the Steelers do it? Well, that's another question entirely.
Sam: From 2001-2004 the Patriots won 3 of 4 Super Bowls. Immediately following that the Steelers went to 3 in 5 years while winning 2. Other than the head-to-head dominance of New England, the franchises were at least fairly close in success for the decade of 2000-2010. What in the heck has happened since? They both have the same QB that won those titles and it could be argued the Patriots have had several seasons with “weaker” roster composition.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Brady and Belichick for starters. They're two of the best to ever do it. We say it every year, but the Patriots will not be the same once he retires. As good as Roethlisberger is, Brady is better. When you look at from an organizational standpoint, I think in the last decade the Steelers embraced talent and the star system while the Patriots went after smart players that fit their system. They might not have the most talented roster, but they have players that can adapt on the run. They do that better than any other team in the league.
SCL: Is there something to be said about taking a smaller corner who makes plays on the ball (byron murphy
) as opposed to a bigger corner who is consistently sticky in coverage but lacks making big plays (deandre baker)?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have Byron Murphy higher than Baker even though he's smaller. First off, when you watch him he doesn't play small. He throws his weight around when he tackles. And he's more of a ball hawk.
Bones: Am I the only one that thinks the Rams probably have serious buyers remorse with the Todd Gurley extension? Why would the Steelers waste a single dollar on Lev Bell after watching younger/cheaper/hungrier backs succeed in the playoffs. That $10-$15 million/per would be a much better investment elsewhere. Even in the Rooney's pockets to carryover again if no free agent signings happen this year.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think we're going to hear that Gurley was dealing with some kind of major knee issue that will require offseason surgery. He was their Bell and he was on the sidelines for half the game. Something is amiss. To your larger point, yes I think they are having buyer's remorse. He had knee issues in college and now he has them in the pros. Running backs take a beating and they have short shelf lives.
SCL: Ray, talent wise it doesn't seem as though our defense is far off from New Englands... Is it realistic to think we can reshape this defense in an offseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Patriots have some very talented players on their defense. Stephon Gilmore is a first-team All-Pro. Dont'a Hightower continues to play at a high level despite his advancing age. But the rest of them for the most part are good players that fit their system. They find players that can excel in their system and make it work. JC Jackson was an undrafted free agent. He was a starting CB in the Super Bowl. They just have a knack for finding and developing defensive players under Belichick.
Steel: Still believe AB is gone week 1? Do you believe teams will refrain from offering a first round pick for him? Feels like we lose if we get anything less...
Ray Fittipaldo: I've said from the beginning you have to get fair value in return for him. And I agree anything less than a first-round pick wold be disappointing. However, the way he's acting the Steelers might be better off without him one way or the other. When Terrell Owens and Chad Johnson are your mentors then you're beyond salvaging.
Kyle: Do you think the HOF would elect 2 former steelers in the same year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, why not? A couple of years ago they had two go in at the same time. I believe it was the year Bettis and Jack Butler got in.
Steel: Would we take a slightly higher rated defensive tackle/end, or go with best corner/inside linebacker available first round?
Ray Fittipaldo: The only problem with taking a DE in the first round is Heyward and Tuitt are signed to big contracts and are entrenched as starters. This is a good year for DEs and DTs so they could be in a position where one with a high grade does fall to them, but all things being equal I think they take an ILB or CB if the right one is available at No. 20.
Steel: DK metcalf seem like a possible first round target?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but only of Brown is dealt. Mississippi has two very good WRs in this draft. Metcalf is smooth and some projections have him going in the top half of the first round.
PorterHouse55: Unlike last year, I think ILBs M.Wilson or D.Bush will be there at 20, & if so, is that the pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would take Bush at No. 20. I would not take Wilson there. We'll see how he tests at the combine, but Devin Bush and Devin White both play faster than Wilson, who is very good. He's just not at the level of Bush or White in my opinion.
Ryno: Couldn't a case he made for the Steelers to get some money back from Antonio Brown (specially if they ship him off)? After all, couldn't a case be made that he didn't even have an injury that he claimed to have? Can't imagine faking an injury wouldn't be breach of contract.
Ray Fittipaldo: That ship sailed a long time ago. Art II even said a few weeks ago that Brown probably did enough to earn his paycheck that week. Now one could argue there must be a very low bar for earning an NFL paycheck, but the point is Art II did not feel it was worth pursuing.
Utah Jim: Adam Schefter says the Steelers are considering transitioning Bell and trading him. Assuming the Steelers would get a 3rd rounder in 2020 if he leaves as a FA they would need to get at least a 4th rounder in 2019. Do you think a team is willing to pay Bell what he wants and give up a 4th rounder or better?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers would never use the tag without knowing for sure someone would give them the pick they want. And I disagree. I'd want a third-rounder in 2019.
John Strange: Do you think the players lost respect for Tomlin when he tripped a player on the field of play and then lied about it being on purpose? How can you preach accountability when you blatantly cheat and then blatantly lie about it? The players must think they can do and say anything they want.
Ray Fittipaldo: I can think of a few other instances where players lost respect for him other than episode, which took place in 2013. Such as letting Antonio Brown do as he pleases and allowing him to play by a different set of rules than everyone else.
Zach B: After watching Belechek’s complete schooling of McVay and with the the constant circus that Art II, Colbert and Tomlin has allowed to fester and grow within this organization it became very clear to me that our Championship Window is now closed for good. We will never win another SB as long as Tomlin leads this team, what day you??
Ray Fittipaldo: They certainly seem farther away than previous years. The wise guys feel that way too. The Steelers are 22 to 1 to win next year's Super Bowl. Ten teams opened with better odds.
JS: The Patriots are disciplined and prepared for games. Their coach isn’t cocky. Their about isn’t an egomaniac. RB isn’t an egomaniac. WR isn’t an egomaniac. Do you think the Steelers will ever learn or change?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not as they are currently constructed, no. But keep in mind, the Patriots are different than most teams.
Baghdad_Ben: Interesting point earlier about the Steelers embracing stars while the Pats went for people who can get the basics done. What would it have looked like if the Steelers did the same? Trade LB and AB for draft picks already?
Ray Fittipaldo: Right but you better have the system and the coaches in your staff to pull it off. It's not easy.
Greg: I understand how wide receivers can lose a step, but how could Boswell have forgotten how to kick in one year? He was even missing extra points. Makes no sense to me.
Ray Fittipaldo: It was a mental thing with him. Kickers are a different species. They're tough to figure out.
AugustWest: I didn't notice a lot of strutting, chest-beating and posing from the Patriots after they made plays against the Rams. How much of the Steelers' failures in recent years do you blame on the look-at-me attitude that seems to permeate the current roster?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, it certainly doesn't make them look good when they fail. That's for sure.
CHOTTY: Is the Patriots' success this year not the most damning indictment of the Steelers' performance this year? The Steelers, by any standard, are immensely more talented this year's Patriots. However, the Steelers are undisciplined, selfish and inconsistent. What would happen if Tomlin totally transformed his coach philosophy next and ruled with a Belichick- like iron fist? Is it not worth a shot?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think all of a sudden he can become an authoritarian. It doesn't work like that. He's developed into the coach he is after 12 seasons. For good or bad, this is who he is.
Jeff M: Do you think the Seahawks could be a suitor for AB? They don't seem to shy away form big personalities and could use a WR. They could take the approach the Saints and Rams did and go all in if they think there close.
Ray Fittipaldo: I haven't heard their name all that much, but you're right about Pete Carroll. He's never shy about going for it.
TXSTEELER : History of production for rookie WRs in their first year is awful in the league (JuJu being an exception). With Steelers wanting to contend wouldn’t it make more sense to sign a serviceable free agent instead of drafting a WR of Brown is traded.
Ray Fittipaldo: Perhaps provided that player doesn't break the bank. But they still would have to draft a WR high to replenish the position.
Mill st: White LB, or Baker CB, or Greedy Williams is available who would you take?
Ray Fittipaldo: Devin White.
Jeff G: Love the chats. So much complaining over Tomlin, Butler and Defense. Do you think we grossly underestimated the impact of losing Shazier? I think we don't give up 45 points to Jax last year and definitely make the playoffs this year. Colbert/Tomlin needed a better plan to replace him, but he is a special player and drafting at 30 isn't going to find another Shazier - @20 may not this year either. None of our current ILB's would even play for any of the other playoff teams.
Ray Fittipaldo: All true although Vince Williams is solid vs. the run and is a good blitzer. I'm fine with him as a two-down LB for another year. But they desperately need a three-down ILB that an do some of the things Shazier did. He could cover, drop into zones and blitz.
NickFromVA: A lot of folks say the number 2 pick is too high for AB, what about AB and our first pick for the 1 and 2 picks from SF?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would do that in a heartbeat. I just don;t think San Francisco would.
Wilro: When things didn't get any better for Steelers after 17 season why should fans believe they'll get better after this past season.
Ray Fittipaldo: They're certainly in prove-it mode for a lot of fans. Ad it's asy to see why. They had one of the best rosters in the NFL and missed the playoffs.
Epiballo: Who gets the seventh Lombardi first ... Pittsburgh or New England? Or Dallas or San Francisco?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not betting against New England. No one has figured them out yet and Brady says he wants to play a few more years.
Epiballo: I know you play the hand you are dealt, but the Patriots have been in a terrible division that assures 5 or 6 wins against division foes. Go 5-5 against the rest of the league, and they are guaranteed a 10-5 or 11-6 record at least! That is why they have won their division every year for the last decade, and win enough to get a bye and home field. Shouldn't this also be considered when assessing how 'great' they are?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure that's fair. They really haven't been challenged by the Jets, Bills or Dolphins during this 18-year run. Maybe the Jets fora year or two but that was short-lived. The Steelers, meanwhile, have to contend with the Ravens, who are very consistent in their approach and always are in contention. The Bengals, for much of the past two decades, had above-average teams. The same can be said for other divisions.
International steeler: Don't you think bell is more valuable than AB and that the organization should try to keep him
Ray Fittipaldo: Bell doesn't want to be with the Steelers. Time to move on.
NickFromVA: Is there any reason to think that the Pats can't win another title or 2 before Brady retires?
Ray Fittipaldo: None whatsoever. They're 6 to 1 favorites to win it again next year, the best odds of any team in the league. I'd be surprised if they don't win another one with Brady.
412: Are we still the favorites to win the division this season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe the slightest of favorites. I could see the Steelers, Browns and Ravens all having between 8 and 10 wins next season. It's going to be a very competitive division.
NickFromVA: I just want to say great comment by Bones on Gurley! I feel like the Steelers dodge a bullet by not coming to terms with Lev Bell.
john: Steelers will resign Bell and keep Brown and win the Super Bowl in Miami next year.
Ray Fittipaldo: You're quite the optimist on this Monday after the Super Bowl.
student: Do you think Rams were not a good matchup for NE and Saints would have better opponent vs NE?
Ray Fittipaldo: Drew Brees is a much better QB than Jared Goff. He most certainly wouldn't have been so ineffective against the Patriots defense. What we don't know is if the Patriots would have had an easier time against their defense.
Michael E: The officials did a somewhat better job in the SB. What are your thoughts on an extra one in the replay box area upstairs. Doesn't seem like it could hurt. College & CFL do that.
Ray Fittipaldo: There was not a game-changing call, but there were a few bad calls that affected the game in my opinion. The one personal foul early on Robey-Coleman was ridiculous. All he did was tackle Burkhead hard. There was a holding call on John Sullivan that wiped out a long gain and put the Rams in a first-and-20 situation in the fourth quarter when the score was still tied at 3. That was a huge call. And Sullivan did not hold. Then there was Gilmore holding Cooks' arm in the end zone. Cooks still has to catch that ball no matter what, but the official missed that... And yes, I'm in favor of anything that will help officials get calls right. The game has to have some integrity and that was brought into question the past few years.
Guest: I think people are using the Patriots' success to extrapolate too much from the Steelers' problems (which are real). The Patriots have talent. Maybe less than the Steelers, but they aren't a bunch of scrubs. And the Patriots are better at the two most important positions: head coach and quarterback. So this idea that the Steelers don't need to worry so much about talent is silly. You need talent to win in the NFL. But you also need discipline and focus. You can have that along with talent. That's what the Steelers need to add; they don't need to subtract talent.
Ray Fittipaldo: But they're not going to be more focused or disciplined if Antonio Brown is on the roster in 2019 either.
Mark: Hypothetical for you, Ray: two teams are making serious offers to the Steelers for AB. One of the offers is significantly better than the other, but that team is in the AFC North. Take the better deal, or trade him outside the division?
Ray Fittipaldo: I take the better deal no matter what.
NickFromVA: Odds that Brian Flores will be another so so HC from the Pats? Seems to me Bellichick has a very heavy hand in the D. Perhaps Tomlin is trying to emulated him?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Belichick coaching tree might have a lot of limbs, but not many of his former assistants have been successful head coaches.
Ron: I have been anti-Tomlin for a while, so perhaps I am a bit biased, but I see him defended despite some very strange in game decisions over the years, along with gross underperformance in games against inferior opponents. During these strange last few years, incidentally, the argument defending his poor in game decisions and management is his record, understandably, and secondarily, the fact that he is such a good player's coach. That second rationale disappears for me as per his contributions to the recent player culture. Do you foresee a new head coach in 2020 with a low level playoff appearance and early elimination or do you think the playoff return will save him regardless? I personally don't see how you miss the playoffs with this level of talent, particularly with a hall of fame QB and a well above average offesvice line.
Ray Fittipaldo: Honestly, it depends on what happens in 2019. Winning cures a lot.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next Monday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.