Ben Roethlisberger talks about his duties as captain

It’s always fascinating to see how leaders use the media to deliver a message to their locker room.

Penguins coach Mike Sullivan has at times been critical of his team, but he chose a very different approach during a recent slump. Even as general manager Jim Rutherford publicly ripped the players, Sullivan consistently and emphatically backed them. He wasn’t going to “pile on,” as he put it, and they have responded.

Steelers coach Mike Tomlin uses both methods, as well. If he feels somebody needs a kick in the rear end or a pat on the back, he will artfully use his pulpit to those ends.

Team captains and respected veteran players also possess that kind of power. The question with all of them is, how well do they pick their spots, and to what end?

Advertise with us

Which of course brings us to Ben Roethlisberger and an old saying: The Ben is mightier than the sword.

His words matter — and his words made national news Tuesday when he criticized teammates during his radio show on 93.7 The Fan (a show he does with Post-Gazette columnist Ron Cook and myself).

Roethlisberger bluntly critiqued rookie receiver James Washington and said star receiver Antonio Brown ran a bad route on the Steelers’ final offensive play. He didn’t blame Brown for the interception, by any means, but he also said he wished the Steelers had called for four straight throws to Ju-Ju Smith-Schuster at the goal line.

It’s hard to believe Brown was thrilled when he heard that. I’m guessing he wasn’t overjoyed, either, that when Ben was asked Wednesday to identify his No. 1 receiver, he basically rattled off the entire roster.

So here’s the first question: Has Roethlisberger “earned the right,” as he put it Wednesday, to call out teammates?

Advertise with us

The answer is a resounding yes. He’s the quarterback. A 36-year-old star quarterback. The very top of the food chain. He has literally earned the right.

When somebody asked Roethlisberger on Wednesday how his critiques might play with teammates, he said, “Ask them.” So I did. And I couldn’t have agreed more with guard David DeCastro when I asked if Ben has “earned the right” to be critical.

“Talking about a Hall of Fame guy who’s played 15 years here, who’s won Super Bowls,” DeCastro said. “So people listen. You respect that resume and what he has to say. No doubt.”

Veteran center Maurkice Pouncey told ESPN he was “totally fine” with it, and guard Ramon Foster said, “It doesn’t bother me much at all. If I got some issues I’m getting called out on, it’s probably rightfully so. You can’t ever take it too personal. It’s also one of those things, like, ‘Hey, let’s find a way to talk about this [privately], also.’ ”

Foster confirmed that private conversations have taken place.

Advertise with us

To be fair, I did not conduct a comprehensive poll during a limited time in the locker room. I did not talk to any defensive players. Brown is only available to the media on Fridays. Washington said he had no problem with Ben’s critique. (What else could he say?)

Which brings us to the next question: Did Roethlisberger use his power wisely in this case?

Best answer: We’ll see, but I'm sure glad he speaks his mind (it makes for pretty good radio).

Let’s refer to a recent case for insight. I was critical of Roethlisberger early last season, when he used his show to rip Brown for his “temper tantrum” in Baltimore. I felt like the quarterback unwisely ignited a story that would’ve died quickly, but guess what? His method seemed to work. Brown pretty much piped down for the rest of the season.

Roethlisberger isn’t afraid to back players, either, as he did with Martavis Bryant through much of his troubles, and as he has on occasion with Brown.

Advertise with us

It’ll be interesting to see how Brown reacts this time. Clearly, their “WiFi” still is going in and out. Nine times this season a Roethlisberger pass to Brown wound up in enemy hands.

Roethlisberger didn’t have to point out that Brown ran a bad route (and we’re not even sure if Brown agrees). He didn’t have to critique Washington or the play-calling, either. He could have included himself in the criticisms. (He often does).

But he said what he said, and you know what?

It makes for pretty good radio.