Everybody hates them, with one tiny caveat: Everybody loves them.

I’m torn, too.

I’m talking about shootouts, and you know why I’m talking about them if you stayed up past 1 a.m. Thursday and you’re any kind of hockey fan.

One of the great shootouts in hockey history happened around that time, decided in Round 6 with as gorgeous a goal as you will ever see, a goal that will play on the same eternal loop as Peter Forsberg’s “Postage Stamp” winner from the 1994 Lillehammer Games.

Advertise with us

Forsberg struck gold for Sweden with a one-handed shootout move that stirred a 6-year-old Swede named Carl Hagelin, who remembers every detail.

“Still a classic,” Hagelin said Thursday after Penguins practice.

Peter Forsberg flips the puck past Canadian goalkeeper Corey Hirsch in 1994. (Al Behrman / Associated Press)
Jocelyne Lamoureux-Davidson scores the winning goal past Canadian goalkeeper Shannon Szabados on Thursday. (Bruce Bennett / Getty Images)

Team USA’s Jocelyne Lamoureux-Davidson deserves a postage stamp of her own — and maybe a “30 for 30” special — for the move she made to sink Canada. I won’t even try to describe it. I’ll simply reference ex-Penguin Colby Armstrong’s tweet the instant it happened: “What in the .... OMG. What a move.”

Even if you claim to despise shootouts, I’d bet good money you were riveted. It’s impossible not to be riveted, whether it’s an NHL regular-season game or the Olympic gold-medal game.

I know this: When I’m in an arena and a shootout breaks out, nobody stays seated.

Advertise with us

In spite of ourselves and our noblest intentions, we love it.

Yet, when Canada failed to answer Lamoureux-Davidson’s goal, and the game suddenly ended, “purists” everywhere predictably erupted, ridiculing the idea that such a critical game could be decided by a breakaway contest — and failing again to realize there is nothing purer than watching this wonderful game boiled to its essence: Shooter versus goalie.

They should see Oshie’s comment in The Washington Post.

“I think it’s a really, really cool way to win,” he said.

That’s how I feel, although I must admit, I’m conflicted — and just as hypocritical as the so-called purists, because I wouldn’t want a Stanley Cup playoff game decided in a shootout.

Advertise with us

Let me think out loud here.

Why does 3-on-3 overtime, which barely resembles a regular hockey game, pass the purists’ test when shootouts are cast aside as a gimmick?

And what kind of world would this be if shootouts had never existed?

No Forsberg. No Sidney Crosby roofing that backhander (and popping up the water bottle) his rookie year against Montreal. No Dominik Hasek stoning Canada in the 1998 Nagano Games (Oh, Marc Crawford, did you really not use Wayne Gretzky?). No T.J. Oshie single-handedly beating the Russians. And no Jocelyne Lamoureux-Davidson scoring the goal of the millennium.

Yeah, maybe it was a bogus way to end a championship.

Advertise with us

It was a beautiful way to end it, too.

Those of us who remember “Showdown in the NHL” or grew up on both ends of endless rounds of one-on-one battles in street hockey or pond hockey have to love the way that game ended.

Right?

“I guess. I don’t know. I mean it’s the gold medal. It’s not street hockey,” Penguins goalie Matt Murray said. “You work for four years and it all comes down to that? Comes down a shootout? You’d like to see it come down to a hockey game, not a shootout.”

Hagelin pretty much seconded Murray’s take. Phil Kessel, whose sister Amanda saved the United States with a shootout goal, said, “I mean, I liked [the shootout] last night” but added he believes they should “play out overtime” in a championship situation.

Advertise with us

And then Crosby completely bummed me out when I asked if he likes the gold-medal game coming down to a shootout.

“No,” he said. “I mean, I can see in the round-robin maybe. You have to get so many games in. But I think when you get to that point, 4-on-4 [should be] enough to get it done. But that’s the way it is, and you have to give them credit. They had some great moves in the shootout.”

Sid also said the bloom has worn off a bit on NHL shootouts, which are much less frequent thanks to 3-on-3 overtime (which is awesome).

But doesn’t he still get a rush when he winds up for a one-time chance to win a game?

“Yeah. Oh yeah. Definitely,” Crosby said. “That doesn’t change. When you’re in that situation and you know how important it is, you get up for it. But it might not have the same effect when it was newer, for the pure fact that nobody had seen it before.”

Advertise with us

Fair enough. That’s a perfectly reasonable take from the best hockey player on the planet.

But you know what? I can’t help myself. The next time a shootout happens, no matter when or where, I’ll be as riveted as a 6-year-old Carl Hagelin.

I’ll bet you will be, too.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.