There’s no place like Heinz.

That much we know from the Steelers’ Heinz Field playoff history, which began with a violent discrowning of the defending champion Baltimore Ravens in 2001.

The Steelers are 8-4 at Heinz Field (5-4 on the road) over the ensuing 17 years. Going into the weekend, only the New England Patriots had played host to more playoff games in that span, and only the Patriots (17) and Seattle Seahawks (10) had won more home playoff games.

When you’re as successful as the Steelers, and you’ve played in the same stadium for 17 years — more than half the lifespan of Three Rivers Stadium — you’re bound to develop quite the playoff scrapbook.

Advertise with us

So let’s dive in. Let’s use aesthetic quality as part of our criterion and desired outcome (Steelers win! Steelers win!) as the other, and let’s rank the 12 Heinz Field playoff games from worst to first …

Hines Ward, left, and Marvel Smith sit on the bench after the team 41-27 loss to the New England Patriots. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

12. AFC championship, Jan. 23, 2005: Patriots 41, Steelers 27

It’s not often a team on a 16-game winning streak finds itself a home underdog, but the Steelers were a 3-point underdog in what would become as crushing a loss as just about any this side of a Super Bowl in franchise history. The only thing that would have made it worse was Jerome Bettis following through on his postgame pledge to retire.

Also, looking back, it’s quite possible the Patriots cheated their way to victory, having stolen the Steelers’ defensive signals from a regular-season matchup. I later asked Dick LeBeau if he felt the Patriots had benefited from the heist.

“I don’t see how it could hurt ‘em,” he said.

Advertise with us
Kordell Stewart after throwing a late interception. (Gene J. Puskar / Associated Press)

11. AFC championship, Jan. 27, 2002: Patriots 24, Steelers 17

Considering what the Patriots have accomplished since, it’s easy to forget they were a no-name underdog back then. It’s also easy to forget just how stunning this loss was. The Steelers were 14-3, had just crushed the Ravens and were favored by 91⁄2 points.

The culprits included special-teams disasters galore, a bull-headed game plan that unraveled as Bettis was held to 9 yards on eight carries, the Patriots possibly cheating, Drew Bledsoe replacing some kid named Tom Brady and a lot of bad Kordell Stewart passes.

Troy Polamalu sits on the bench in what would be his last game. (Julia Rendleman / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

10. Wild card, Jan. 3, 2015: Ravens 30, Steelers 17.

I’m sorry to even mention this travesty. There were horrifying sights everywhere: Jim Harbaugh joining his brother on the Baltimore sidelines (what, no Tom Crean?); John Harbaugh calling Joe Flacco “the best quarterback in football”; Ben Tate, Josh Harris and the great Dri Archer filling in for Le’Veon Bell; Roethlisberger and Heath Miller re-entering after apparent head injuries.

Advertise with us

Mostly, though, I’ll remember this as the last time the great Troy Polamalu ran through that tunnel. And even though he was a shell of himself, he led the Steelers in tackles that day.

Ben Roethlisberger scrambles in the Steelers' divisional round game against the Jets in 2005. (Lake Fong / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

9. Divisional game, Jan. 15, 2005: Steelers 20, Jets 17 (OT)

Yes, the Steelers won, but only by pure chance when Doug Brien missed not one but two field-goal attempts in the final two minutes. The first, from 47 yards, hit the post. The second, from 43 yards after a brutal Roethlisberger interception, sailed wide.

“I feel his pain,” said Steelers kicker Jeff Reed, who won it with a 33-yard kick.

This game, as it turned out, foreshadowed terrible things for the next week (see No. 12).

Advertise with us
Alan Faneca waves to the fans after his last game in a Steelers uniform, Jan. 5, 2008. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

8. Wild card, Jan. 5, 2008, Jaguars 31, Steelers 29.

This crazy affair served as Mike Tomlin’s playoff debut, and he did not exactly bathe himself in glory.

For starters, he ordered a two-point conversion from the 12-yard line (after a penalty) with more than 10 minutes left and his team down five, forcing him to try another after their next touchdown. Both failed. If he’d simply kicked extra points, the game would have gone to overtime.

A simple question emerged: Why?

“Playing the charts, that is not out of bounds,” Tomlin said. “That’s just baseball.”

Advertise with us

Tomlin and Bruce Arians lost their collective mind with the Steelers trying to run out the clock. On third-and-6, Arians ordered a Roethlisberger sweep — who knew there was such a thing? — behind third-string left tackle Trai Essex.

Shockingly, the play failed. The Jaguars drove the field thanks to a dramatic David Garrard scramble while James Harrison was blatantly held (at least he showed up for the game).

All of it, in retrospect, seems unremarkable when one considers this jarring fact: Najeh Davenport scored two touchdowns.

7. Wild card, Jan. 8, 2017: Steelers 30, Dolphins 12

The Steelers’ Big Three — Roethlisberger, Bell and Antonio Brown — finally took the field together for a playoff game. It went well. Brown scored twice in the first 10 minutes as the Steelers avenged a 30-15 defeat in Miami by pounding the frozen Dolphins into submission.

Advertise with us

Lasting snap shot: Bud Dupree nearly beheading Miami quarterback Matt Moore.

6. Divisional game, Jan. 11, 2009: Steelers 35, Chargers 24.

We won’t talk about the fake punt involving Mitch Berger, Ryan Clark and Antwan Applewhite. We will never mention it again. What we will talk about is Santonio Holmes electrifying the place with a 67-yard punt return and LaMarr Woodley body slamming chatty Phil Rivers on a play Woodley later would tell me was among the more satisfying of his career.

Joey Porter celebrates a fourth-quarter sack of Elvis Grbac. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

5. Divisional game, Jan. 20, 2002: Steelers 27, Ravens 10.

“We knew Grbac couldn’t beat us,” Joey Porter said of the Ravens’ terrible quarterback, the guy Baltimore hand-picked to replace the slightly less terrible Trent Dilfer.

Advertise with us

By the time Elvis left the building, the Steelers had throughly humiliated him (three interceptions) and the defending champion Ravens.

Bettis couldn’t play because of a pregame injection gone bad, but Amos Zereoue scored twice, and the Steelers controlled the ball for 41 minutes, handing Baltimore the worst defeat of any defending champion in 18 years.

William Gay celebrates the Steelers' 24-19 win in the AFC championship in 2011. (Ronald Martinez / Getty Images)

4. AFC championship, Jan. 23, 2011: Steelers 24, Jets 19.

How could a game that propelled the Steelers to the Super Bowl rank only fourth? Good question — but wait until you see the three in front of it.

The cocky, Rex Ryan-led Jets were coming off an emotional victory at New England and seemed overly respectful of the Steelers, almost patronizingly so. Tomlin took it that way, as if the Steelers weren’t worthy of Ryan’s disrespect.

Advertise with us

Tomlin had his team at the perfect emotional pitch. It physically pounded the Jets in racing to a 24-0 lead it would barely protect.

My lasting memory is how passionately Rashard Mendenhall ran the ball. If you could have bottled his first-half demeanor, you would have had a superstar.

3. Wild card, Jan. 5, 2003: Steelers 36, Browns 33.

Oh, what a cast of characters. Arians was Cleveland’s offensive coordinator, Foge Fazio its defensive boss (who raged when Butch Davis ordered him to stop blitzing).

Played in a snow globe, it goes down as the greatest playoff comeback in Steelers history. They trailed, 24-7, and stormed back from 12 points down in the final four minutes.

Advertise with us

Afterward, Dan Rooney told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Ed Bouchette it ranked second among exciting Steelers playoff games only to the Immaculate Reception victory against Oakland in 1972.

The winning run began with a kick when running backs coach Dick Hoak kicked coordinator Mike Mularkey in the shin in the press box and begged him to use a play called “42 Base.”

It worked. Chris Fuamatu-Ma’afala took a handoff out of the shotgun and ran 3 yards, straight into the history books.

2. Divisional game, Jan. 15, 2011: Steelers 31, Ravens 24.

Another stirring comeback, this one lighting the way to a Super Bowl. I remember the Ravens celebrating on their way to the locker room with a 21-7 halftime lead and thinking they seemed a little too happy.

Advertise with us

Heinz Field literally shook as the Steelers mounted their comeback. They won it when a fairly obscure rookie receiver named Antonio Brown made the first memorable play of a career that would be filled with them.

Facing a third-and-19 at their 38 with 2:07 remaining in a tie game, the Steelers decided to go for broke, figuring an incompletion would be as good as a punt. Of course, an interception by, say, Ed Reed, could end in disaster.

“Let’s send him,” Roethlisberger told Arians, referring to Brown. “Let’s just chuck it deep.”

Roethlisberger unleashed a moonshot down the right sideline. Brown pinned the ball against his helmet as he ran out of bounds, completing a 58-yard play that set up the winning touchdown.

This little tidbit remains embedded in my mind’s eye: T.J. Houshmandzadeh, one of the Terrible Towel stompers when he played in Cincinnati, dropped Flacco’s fourth-down pass at the Steelers 38 with 1:03 remaining.

Advertise with us

Karma, baby.

1. AFC championship, Jan. 18, 2009: Steelers 23, Ravens 14.

As violent a football game as I have ever witnessed, and with everything on the line. Two plays will be remembered …

• Ryan Clark’s frightening hit on Willis McGahee.

• Polamalu’s weaving, winding, 40-yard interception return for a game-clinching touchdown.

Advertise with us

If I had to pick one moment as the loudest in Heinz Field history, I would pick the latter, as Polamalu crossed the goal line and raised the football to the heavens, as if it were a sacred offering.

Which, of course, it was.

The football gods seemed pleased.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Click here for more Post-Gazette coverage of the Steelers’ playoff run