Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Chris Mueller, @ChrisMuellerPGH: Who is the best “big game” athlete from each sport that is NOT in the Hall of Fame.
Starkey: Hi Chris. I like that question, and I will get to it sometime in the very near future, but I like this one better: Why are other teams’ heroes going into the Steelers Hall of Honor?
Seriously, picture a father and his 8-year-old son, 20 years hence, sitting at newly christened Kevin Greene Stadium watching a Steelers game and discussing the 3,563 names in the team’s Hall of Honor …
Son: “Dad, who’s this Walt Kiesling guy?”
Father: “He was one of the Steelers’ first coaches, bud. Coached ’em three different times.”
Read More
Son: “Did he do anything really big?”
Father: “Well, he cut Johnny Unitas, who became one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. You know what he told the Rooneys about Unitas? He said, ‘He’ll never amount to anything.’ ”
Son: “Everybody makes mistakes, right dad? I’ll bet Kiesling won a lot of games.”
Father: “Actually, he hardly won any. Says here his record was 25-41-4.”
Son: “Did he play?”
Father: “Hall of Famer. Offensive lineman. Played on a famous Chicago Bears team called ‘Monsters of the Midway.’ They went 13-0 in 1934 before they lost in the championship.”
Son: “Did he play for the Steelers?”
Father: “Let’s see here … He started one game, late in his career, back when they were called the Pirates.”
Son: “Did those Pirates sell off players the way Bob Nutting does?”
Father: “I’m not sure, buddy. I’d have to look it up.”
Son: “Dad?”
Father: “Yes, son.”
Son: “Why is Walt Kiesling in the Steelers Hall of Honor?”
Father: (Stares blankly at the field and hopes the kid doesn’t ask about Johnny “Blood” McNally, who, like Kiesling, barely played for the Steelers, coached them horribly — 7-25-1 — and somehow wound up as a first-ballot Hall of Honor enshrinee next to the likes of Franco Harris and Mean Joe Greene).

Listen, Mullsy, I really was determined not to get worked up over the Steelers’ inaugural Hall of Honor class. I understand the absurdity of the task at hand — singling out prominent figures from a franchise history positively littered with them. I’m sure you do, too.
I respect all the voters, and I think I understand what happened here: Art Rooney II wanted to kick the whole thing off by including all of the Steelers already enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He wanted to include these so-called “Steelers in the Hall of Fame” because who do you leave out if you start picking and choosing?
“That was Art’s reasoning, and everybody agreed,” one of the voters, Stan Savran, told me.
Here’s the problem, which long predates the formation of this committee: The Steelers claimed, or were given credit for, Hall of Famers who didn’t really belong to them, men who made their names with other organizations or simply weren’t here very long.
Those include Kiesling, McNally, Bobby Layne and Kevin Greene. Bert Bell, who counts as a “Steeler in the Hall of Fame,” was left off the list presumably because he made his name elsewhere (as NFL commissioner). Why couldn’t the same logic have applied to the others?
A Los Angeles Times story from 1988 said of McNally, “He wasn’t much of a coach, but he had been a helluva player, and (franchise founder Art) Rooney liked his style.”
McNally was a helluva player … for the Green Bay Packers. He started only seven of his 137 NFL games for the Steelers and was an erratic coach who, legend has it, once failed to show for a game because he thought the Steelers were off that weekend. Must he be immortalized next to Chuck Noll in the very first Hall of Honor class?
Layne had his moments in Pittsburgh but is a Detroit Lion forever.
Kevin Greene was here for 10 minutes. He played just 20 percent of his career with the Steelers. Three seasons.
I mean, LaMarr Woodley had a more profound impact on this franchise than Greene. The proof is in their playoff resumes.
Greene: 1.5 sacks in six playoff games.
Woodley: 11 sacks in 10 playoff games.
The committee could have made the minimum requirement five full seasons with the Steelers, instead of three (which also would have eliminated Bullet Bill Dudley). After that, reasonable arguments could have eliminated McNally and Kiesling.
Joe Starkey, JoeStarkey1: What about the rest of the class?
Starkey: The rest of the class is solid, even if it did swell to the size of the national deficit. I like that the committee included four non-Hall of Famers — essentially the first real class — in L.C. Greenwood, Donnie Shell, Dick Hoak and Andy Russell.
I thought Art Rooney Jr., Bill Nunn and Rocky Bleier (Savran said he argued passionately for him), among others, deserved serious consideration, if we were going mostly with a 70s theme.
Something just seems off when those names and more were put on a waiting list while Walt Kiesling and his 25-41-4 record go in with the very first class.
It didn’t have to be that way.
Tim, @timmshady: Where does Ben rank in the top 25 QBs right now? Not considering money, how many QBs would you trade Ben for?
Starkey: We have to very precise about this question, Mr. Shady, because they are many ways to look at it.
First, I believe Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady represent the Elite Class of NFL quarterbacks. They are on an island by themselves. After that, it gets tricky. I mean, Alex Smith is off to a tremendous start. If you’re ranking quarterbacks by their performance through four games, he’s an MVP candidate.
But would I choose Alex Smith over Ben to lead my team starting tomorrow? God, no.
On the other hand, if I were starting a franchise from scratch tomorrow, I would consider several younger quarterbacks over Ben, because of the age factor. It wouldn’t make much sense to start a franchise with a 35-year-old threatening retirement, would it?
Have I confused the issue enough here?
Let’s phrase it this way: If I had to rank quarterbacks on the basis of who I would want for the rest of this season, and the rest of this season only, I would rank them like this:
• Tom Brady
• Aaron Rodgers
• Drew Brees
• Matt Ryan
• Ben Roethlisberger
So yes, he’s still in my top five. I just can’t put Jared Goff, Kirk Cousins or Smith ahead of him. Ben’s been rusty, I get that, but he still has six TDs and only two picks. He’s still very good. And I expect this offense to get better and better.

Matt dicicco, @DiciccoMatt: How about putting together the worst Pirate trade lineup of the last 10 years. I will spot you Matt Morris as your starter.
Starkey: Thank you for that, Dr. dicicco. Here we go …
Catcher — Robinson Diaz. The deal that sent Jose Bautista to Toronto was slightly lopsided, at least in terms of home runs. Bautista leads at the moment, 288-1.
First base — Jeff Clement
Second base — Aki Iwamura. Got nearly $5 million for hitting .182 and running around in a knee brace.
Shortstop — Jose Hernandez. Yes, this happened in 2003, but we need an honorary member of the infamous Aramis Ramirez trade on here somewhere. He provides valuable experience.
Third base — Andy LaRoche.
Outfield — John Bowker, Andrew Lambo, Jose Tabata (who actually wasn’t bad and should absolutely be named captain of this team).
DH for Interleague matchups — Jaff Decker.
Rotation — Morris, Jon Niese, Drew Hutchison (he takes two of every five turns), Tim Alderson. Niese could complain about infield shifts while giving up titanic home runs, and the Pirates could pay Hutchison $2.3 million to pitch in the minors.
Set-up Man — Joaquin Benoit.
Closer — Joaquin Benoit.
Player-manager — Joaquin Benoit.
Orlando Carr, @OhCarr84: Can you imagine a better MLB player that could sail the Caribbean for the rest of their lives than John Jaso?
Starkey: No, Mr. @OhCarr84. No I couldn’t.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.