You can’t be wrong.

On the other hand, you can’t really be right.

Go ahead. Try it. Pick the 10 greatest Steelers of all-time, in order. I dare you.

I double-dare you.

Advertise with us

I double-team you with Rod Woodson and Mel Blount.

I’d never thought to attempt a feat like this until the Steelers last week unveiled plans for a “Hall of Honor.” The Post-Gazette’s Ed Bouchette reported the inaugural class (size unknown) will be revealed Aug. 29 and introduced Nov. 26 at Heinz Field during halftime of a game against the Green Bay Packers.

Bouchette’s reporting was impeccable, as always, but he did err in one statement.

After suggesting the first class could include “their own Mount Rushmore of franchise founder Art Rooney Sr., his son Dan Rooney, coach Chuck Noll and the acknowledged most important player in team history, Joe Greene,” Bouchette added: “There would be few arguments with that inaugural class.”

I agreed, then quickly realized “few” could only be accurate if it were translated into “billions of.” When I raised the topic on the radio — fully backing Bouchette — people immediately raised issue with the first-ballot induction of The Chief, Art Rooney Sr. (wait, the Steelers wouldn’t exist without him, right?) and suggested several helpful alternatives.

Advertise with us

I’m sure somebody wants Tyler Matakevich in there. Or at least Dan Kreider.

Point being, you can’t win.

But you can’t really lose, either.

So I sat down to make my "10 Greatest Steelers" list, in order, no wishy washy compromises, and then set out to find a couple of stubborn old war horses to disagree with me.

I wanted to find media types who’d seen pretty much every game since 1970. Preferably, they would be retired, as I found the active ones either don’t like to make lists or want to publish their own.

Advertise with us

I found two of the best, and most stubborn: Bob Smizik and Sam Nover.

Smizik was a longtime and legendary newspaper man, Nover a longtime and legendary TV personality. I’m sure some are already ripping these choices, and my characterizations of them, but that’s kind of the point here, right?

All three of us soon realized the enormity of the task.

“Great fun, and we had some family arguments over it,” Nover said. “But I prevailed.”

Smizik: “I changed my list every day.”

Advertise with us

So did I.

The only thing we could agree on — and I truly believe, perhaps naively, “few would argue” — is that Joe Greene is the greatest Steeler of all. He changed everything.

After that, all NF-hell broke loose.

I mean, do you prioritize talent? In that case, Antonio Brown and Le’Veon Bell are in (with Brown arriving at the induction ceremony in a burgundy, chauffeur-driven 1931 Rolls Royce Phantom, of course, and Bell skipping it altogether). But have they played long enough? Have they won enough?

Do you automatically put Ben over Bradshaw, or vice-versa?

Advertise with us

Which of the Steelers’ great wide receivers belong? Any?

Dermontti Dawson or Mike Webster? Neither? Both?

Franco Harris or Jerome Bettis? Neither? Both?

Jack Ham or Jack Lambert?

Woodson or Blount?

Advertise with us

What about the pre-70s stars, such as Ernie Stautner, John Henry Johnson or Jack Butler?

What about Troy Polamalu, James Harrison or Hines Ward?

My God, it’s torture. I don’t envy the Hall of Honor’s stellar selection committee — Art Rooney II, former team PR man Joe Gordon, Bob Labriola of Steelers.com, broadcaster Stan Savran and retired club executive Tony Quatrini.

Anyway, I had lunch with Smizik and exchanged emails with Nover and this is what happened:

Starkey’s 10 Greatest Steelers

Advertise with us

1. Joe Greene

2. Terry Bradshaw

3. Ben Roethlisberger

4. Franco Harris

5. Jack Lambert

Advertise with us

6. Jack Ham

7. Troy Polamalu

8. Mel Blount

9. Rod Woodson

10. Hines Ward (don’t you dare laugh; I will explain this pick below).

Advertise with us

Smizik’s 10 Greatest Steelers

1. Joe Greene

2. Rod Woodson

3. Ernie Stautner

4. Jack Ham

Advertise with us

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Mike Webster

7. Troy Polamalu

8. Franco Harris

9. Jack Lambert

Advertise with us

10. Dermontti Dawson

Nover’s 10 Greatest Steelers

1. Joe Greene

2. Jack Lambert

3. Terry Bradshaw

Advertise with us

4. Troy Polamalu

5. Jack Ham

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Franco Harris

8. Jerome Bettis

Advertise with us

9. Mel Blount

10. Dermontti Dawson

I would encourage you to make your list below. Just remember, you can’t really be wrong. And you can’t really be right:

The first point of contention was myself and Nover selecting Bradshaw so early. Smizik hated this. He believes Bradshaw is “overrated.” He wouldn’t go so far as to call him a cheerleader, but he’s not a huge fan.

“My argument is that if Dan Fouts quarterbacked the [‘70s] Steelers, they still win four Super Bowls,” Smizik said.

Advertise with us

Maybe. It’s possible several quarterbacks could have won with that team. My argument is that Bradshaw is the greatest clutch deep-ball passer of all-time and is 4-0 in Super Bowls with two MVP awards. Without his gutsy, spectacular bombs-away acumen (and remember, he called his own plays), the ’70s Steelers might have only one ring. The first one.

When I relayed Smizik’s distaste for placing Bradshaw so highly, Nover fired back an email (keep in mind, Smizik and Nover respect and like each other … at least I’m pretty sure they like each other):

“What the hell does Bob know!! LOL. He probably had Ben listed ahead of Bradshaw. One cannot penalize Bradshaw for throwing the ball a lot less than Ben. It was a different era that placed an emphasis on running the ball. … I am very comfortable making Bradshaw the 3rd greatest Steeler of all time.”

I wondered about Smizik choosing Ernie Stautner in the third round. He made a convincing argument, pointing out that Stautner was a first-ballot Hall of Famer and the only Steeler for many years to have his jersey retired.

“I remember in high school, football players would fight over who’d get No. 70,” Smizik recalled.

Interestingly, Smizik’s team featured three non-70s picks in the top five (Woodson, Roethlisberger, Stautner).

“An overriding philosophy of my voting was that players not accompanied by other greats deserve more credit,” he said. “It is harder to achieve greatness when your supporting cast is ordinary. That's one of the reasons I had Woodson so far ahead of some of the ’70s Steelers. I covered so many of his games and he just made so many big plays.”

I’ll buy that. The only reason I had Woodson lower (No. 9) is that he spent nearly half his career with other teams. When you look at his NFL record 12 interceptions-returned-for-touchdowns, for example, you’ll find that seven occurred elsewhere.

Woodson spent 10 years in Pittsburgh but really played only eight full seasons here (he started one game as a rookie and only one in 1995 because of injury). He played seven seasons with other teams.

Not that I’m taking anything away from the man. He's a legend. He's also ninth on my list, while the likes of Mike Webster, John Stallworth and Dawson did not even make it. Alan Faneca didn’t make anyone’s list, which could be considered shameful considering no Steeler can top Faneca’s six First-Team All-Pro nominations (Dawson, Ham and Lambert also have six).

Other tidbits:

■ How can anybody not have Franco in their top five? He was poised to break the NFL’s all-time rushing record in 1984 — he trailed Jim Brown by 362 yards — before he abruptly retired in Seattle. And he was as good a money back as anyone who ever played.

■ Lambert and Ham put up such mind-blowing and varied numbers. Besides a whole bunch of tackles, they combined for 60 interceptions, 38 fumble recoveries and nearly 50 sacks (unofficially). Sacks weren’t an official stat until 1982, but one stat that blew me away — I’m not sure why — was an aging Lambert recording four in 1982 and again in ’83.

Lambert is always the older fans’ choice among all-time favorite Steelers. He also has the greatest face in franchise history (toothless, raging) — and you know what? I believe those facts actually obscure his greatness.

Yes, he crushed people. Yes, he body-slammed Cliff Harris in the Super Bowl. The bigger story is that the Steelers needed a smart, rangy middle linebacker, a guy who could cover, to play their style of defense. And remember this: Lambert was the NFL’s Defensive Player of the Year in 1976, when the Steelers had their best defense ever (yes, I know they didn’t win it all, so that couldn’t have been their best defense … there’s a comments section below).

■ I must defend my choice of Hines Ward, and I do so with a Hines-like smile on my face. It’s really quite simple: He’s one of the best all-around football players I’ve ever seen. He factored into almost every play, between his pass-catching ability and his ferocious blocking. Ask Keith Rivers. Or Ed Reed.

I’ll leave you with a couple of other “10 Greatest Steelers” lists.

NFL Network’s 10 Greatest Steelers

1. Joe Greene

2. Terry Bradshaw

3. Jack Lambert

4. Franco Harris

5. Rod Woodson

6. Mike Webster

7. Jack Ham

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. John Stallworth

10. Mel Blount

Sports Illustrated’s 10 Greatest Steelers*

*This is the order in which Steelers players were taken in recent all-time draft of NFL players. Twelve men, including Peter King, Bill Polian, Gil Brandt, Dan Fouts and Ernie Accorsi, participated in the draft:

1. Joe Greene

2. Jack Lambert

3. Jack Ham

4. Terry Bradshaw

5. Rod Woodson

6. Mel Blount

7. Dermontti Dawson

8. Mike Webster

9. Troy Polamalu

10. Jack Butler