Moderate buyers, kicking tires. That is how one general manager, in a piece on MLB.com, described the Pirates’ current approach to Monday’s 4 p.m. trade deadline.
Sounds about right.
Certainly, it sounds more plausible than the Pirates making a legitimate play for Sonny Gray, though the San Francisco Chronicle’s Susan Slusser reported they were one of seven teams with a scout in Toronto on Tuesday to see Gray pitch against the Blue Jays.
Maybe it was just for show, who knows? We’ve all seen that movie before. Pirates said to be legitimately interested in hot-commodity pitcher (David Price, Jose Quintana, Sandy Koufax, etc.) only to fall out of mix at last second. But darn it, they tried!
One of these centuries, maybe they really will go for it in the truest sense of the phrase and land such a pitcher. And to be fair, GM Neal Huntington has acquired starters who tore it up after the deadline each of the past two years in J.A. Happ and Ivan Nova. They were better than most or all of the high-profile guys other teams acquired.
But I’d say Huntington is pressing his luck if he expects his next dumpster dive to go as well. I’d rather the Pirates step to the plate and take their best cut at more of a sure thing. I’d rather they finally part ways with some of their precious prospects and go for the fences while the face of their franchise, Andrew McCutchen, is still around — and he’s only under team control through next season.
Read More
Why not Gray? The Pirates would have control of him for two more seasons (he’s arbitration-eligible both years and is making $3.575 million this year). They could flip him for more precious prospects at the 2019 deadline. McCutchen and eventually Gerrit Cole could also bring back tons of prospects (yippee!) if that’s what you’re worried about.
The issue — and this might have been an issue in pursuing Quintana, as well — is that the Pirates might not have the prospect packages other teams desire. Not after the way this past year has unfolded. They have graduated some top prospects (Jameson Taillon, Josh Bell) and seen the stock drop on others (Tyler Glasnow, Austin Meadows).
Those developments, combined with Huntington’s questionable drafts, left this franchise with only three prospects in MLBPipeline’s midseason top 100 ranking, none in the top 15. McCutchen’s apparent heir apparent, Meadows, pulled in at No. 20, followed by pitchers Mitch Keller (22) and Shane Baz (88).
Baseball America’s midseason Top 100 also featured only three Pirates: Keller (15), Meadows (22) and shortstop Kevin Newman (88).
Meadows, while still a tantalizing talent, has been injured or under-performing at Class AAA Indy, hitting .248 with four home runs in 254 at-bats. Keller has played well, but in high-A ball. Tim Tebow’s playing well at that level, too. And Keller missed most of June with a back injury. Baz, the Pirates’ first-round pick, is 18 years old, fresh out of high school. Newman recently was promoted to Class AAA after he hit .259 and played well defensively in Altoona.
I have no idea how any of those guys will pan out, but I know this: Anyone selling you on the idea the Pirates’ farm system is loaded is lying.
Glasnow was not included in the rankings, presumably because he has “graduated.” In reality, he almost graduated but earned an ‘F’ in two disastrous major league stints and was sent back for more schooling. He remains an enticing prospect, just not the one he was considered to be a year ago. Here’s hoping Huntington isn’t holding up deals because he can’t let go.
It’s more likely a team would want one of the Pirates’ young major leaguers. Bell, for example. And that would be problematic because they don’t have anyone to replace him at first base. They also need another outfielder before Monday’s deadline.
I haven’t even mentioned the Cubs yet. They already beat the Pirates to Quintana, and ESPN’s Buster Olney mentioned the following names in connection with the Cubs over the past week: Yu Darvish, Gray, Justin Verlander, Zach Britton, Justin Wilson.
Help for the rotation. Help for bullpen. You just know it’s coming. One or more of those guys will land in Chicago. For the Pirates, it’s an uphill battle, and it always will be against the Cubs.
Now, if the likes of Sonny Gray comes walking through that clubhouse door, I’d like their chances a whole lot better. I’m not just not sure the Pirates have the stomach, or the prospects, to make a legitimate play for him.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.