Bill Brink: Good morning (afternoon I guess in Pittsburgh) and thanks for stopping by today's Pirates chat. Thanks for the questions you've already submitted, and keep them coming. Here we go ...
Al In The Swamps of Jersey: After last night's loss is the state of things still so tenuous that how the team does over the next 4 games could determine whether Cutch stays or goes?
Bill Brink: I don't think the next four can sway them to trade McCutchen. Their recent play and the market for outfielders makes it seem like he's staying.
HB: could the pirates look to the orioles for what we need we can trade for machado and gausman who could probably turn it around with the magic of the pirates pitching coaches it would cost alot but he makes the team competitive for the next two seasons
Bill Brink: Machado and Gausman would help almost every team, which is why they would cost an arm and a leg and the other arm and the other leg. Orioles could trade Machado, but Gausman's young and controllable. Don't see it.
sean from cumberland md: Best guess, who comes out of the starting rotation if we trade for a starter? After Tallions performance last night could it be him?
Read More
Bill Brink: Don't think it'll be Taillon, with his upside and (albeit brief) track record.
Guest: do you or anyone else believe that the Pirates will only do whaNutting allow them to do ?As long as he runs the show I believe mediocracy will rule this team. What do you think?
Bill Brink: I believe -- I know -- that the baseball ops people can only work with the budget he sets. That is the case with every team. The Pirates have succeeded under such a budget (see 2013-15) but it's harder to do, and hard to sustain.
Avogel549: when polanco comes back does brault get sent down? He had a good outing last night and I'd like to see him stay up.
Bill Brink: Possibly. Or they might re-balance at seven relievers and five bench players at some point prior to Polanco's return.
Mark from Curve Country: Would the team be interested in acquiring a multiplayer package to address a number of areas, or looking at more one player deals? I'm thinking specifically about a deal for Jay Bruce (move Polanco to LF if there's a postseason), Neil Walker (he's supposed to back soon and either he or Harrison could go to 3B), and Josh Edgin (short term bullpen help, possible Watson replacement longer term). What would it take to get those 3? Drew Hutchison and a 15-20 organizational guy, with the Pirates taking on some remaining salary (they still have the extra cash from Marte, Kang, & Hughes).
Bill Brink: The premise is sound. Bruce makes the most sense to me, but he won't be cheap. It'll take more than a starter already into arbitration who didn't make the roster out of spring and an organizational guy. And the Pirates need help now, not in a few weeks when Walker's back.
BurghBall: Off topic, but, nomenclature curious here. Is there any fundamental difference between the following: purchased the contract of, recalled, promoted? And the converse: outrighted, sent down, optioned?
Bill Brink: Good question. Recalled applies to someone on the 40-man roster; purchased the contract of, or selected, refers to someone who is not (goes back to the days before the current player development contracts with minor league affiliates, when teams would literally send money to the minor league team when they promoted a player). Optioned refers to a player remaining on the 40-man roster but sent to the minors; outrighted means a player has cleared waivers and been removed from the 40-man before being sent to the minors.
Aging Fan: It seems as if Newman is more highly regarded than Tucker? Do they have different strengths, weaknesses, position flexibility?
Bill Brink: Well, Newman is older and closer to the majors. Both can stick at short. Newman has excellent contact skills. I'd say both are quite promising (easy to say after they were both promoted, I know).
Hank: If the Cubs would have offered those top 2 prospects for Gerrit Cole, instead of Quintana, do you think the Bucs would have pulled the trigger? Would you have?
Bill Brink: I don't think the Pirates would have done that to a division rival when they still think they can contend next season, no.
Mike: Bill - with Taillon and Nova's recent struggles is there even more pressure on management to add a starter before Monday? Could they entertain the idea of a 6 man rotation moving forward?
Bill Brink: Hurdle's not a fan of six-man rotations, so I don't see that happening. I don't know about pressure. I think their recent track record says they can improve. But it might make them think harder about it.
Mark from Curve Country: Any idea what type of starting pitcher, maybe a couple examples, the team might add? I can't see them standing pat.
Bill Brink: Lynn, Hellickson, Richard, Holland, Estrada, Anibal Sanchez if the Tigers kick in some money for next year's option.
Dan: Also why did Rivero trade rumors start? Did the Dodgers actually ask his price?
Bill Brink: That deal was mentioned in a predictions column about the trade deadline. Whether they actually asked or not, it's not going to happen.
Dan: JD Martinez albeit a rental, was too cheap in my opinion. Doesn't seem like there are teams who want to pay high price for an outfielder. Or are there?
Bill Brink: The deal was fair, it's the perception of Martinez that was too high. The Diamondbacks got two months of a good hitter who mashes lefties but plays bad defense. And no, it doesn't seem like there are many teams who want to pay for a top-shelf outfielder.
BobbyToledo: What's up with the hamstring injuries? Polanco multiple times this season, Meadows, and others. Lack of training, or something else?
Bill Brink: Good timing, we just talked to Todd Tomczyk about this this morning. It's not lack of training or laziness, he referred to it as more the type of training they're doing and put the onus on the strength staff to develop a better program. I'll have more on that in today's notebook.
Chris: How much will PR influence the deadline? Pirates pitchers struggle to go 6 innings, Polanco hurt, Marte inelligible. NH cannot seriously think they can make a WS run even if they somehow win division. Is there still a chance they sell?
Bill Brink: Still a chance they sell. I don't think they sell everything. Could they deal Watson and/or Nicasio? Sure. They might buy and sell.
Buc'nnutz: With Kang gone for this year, do the Bucs have any hope to see him in uniform again or should they be looking for a permanent replacement? anyone on the radar?
Bill Brink: they have to operate as though he won't return. It's the only prudent way to do it. And without any third base prospects in the system who are anywhere close, they will be looking elsewhere.
jack: taillon and nova's been poor recently. why is it? stuff's worsened?
Bill Brink: Up in the zone too much (particularly troublesome with sinkerballers who don't pitch up in the zone that much), and the NL is adjusting after seeing them for the second season.
jack: how's polanco? do you think 10 days will be enough for him to comeback?
Bill Brink: Hitting, throwing and riding an exercise bike, but not running yet. Might need a few more days.
RAS: Is Taillon physically OK.....?
Bill Brink: He said he was.
Ray: Any chance the pirates make a trade for Yu Darvish or Sonny Gray or is price too steep?
Austin: Is there any real interest in sonny gray?
Bill Brink: I'm sure they're doing their due diligence, and I've covered this club long enough that nothing they do surprises me, but acquiring either of them, with a 50-51 record, would go against the way Huntington has operated in 10 years since taking over.
TL: is the rotation still a priority at this point? huntington mentioned that they're also looking at outfielders to counterbalance the polanco injury as well as the potential for being without marte in the postseason (fingers crossed). is the focus in the outfield now? who's available at a price the pirates would be comfortable with?
Bill Brink: Hurdle spoke about outfielders this morning too. Some that could fit: Bruce, Granderson, Melky Cabrera, Revere, Rajai Davis,
Tyler: If they can't land a starter at the deadline could they go the route of landing a reliable 7th inning reliever in an effort to shorten games? The starters rarely get to the 7th as it is.
Bill Brink: They've added bullpen help in recent years and I'd imagine they do so again, especially if they trade Watson or Nicasio.
Aging Fan: Hate to be negative, but I find it hard to believe that Martes transgression was a one off. They guy has been ripped for years. Tell me I'm wrong?
Bill Brink: You can be ripped without PEDs. We'll never know (unless he changes his mind and answers the questions we asked when he returned). One thing I will say: If he used Nandrolone before, he likely would have been caught by now.
Alex: What do you think about attempting to add Howie Kendrick and Jeremy Hellickson?
Bill Brink: Certainly fills two needs and the Phillies are motivated to move them -- if Kendrick can stay healthy.
Ray: Are the Pirates going to extend Clint Hurdle?
Bill Brink: Excellent question, one I've asked him and Huntington in recent weeks. Neither have given much of an indication. But there's two months left and they haven't even guaranteed his option, so it makes you wonder, doesn't it?
Hank: Other than having Marte for a full season, what gives this barely .500 team the belief they can contend next year?
Bill Brink: Not missing Taillon for five weeks, a more consistent Cole, maybe one of the young starters takes a step forward and becomes reliable on a consistent basis.
Hank: Will the Bucs ever again have a true power hitter on their team or do the analytics guys "poo-poo" that idea?
Bill Brink: They might have the makings of one in Bell, but it's a good question. I don't think analytics necessarily dislike power, but when looking to construct a roster, power can be expensive to acquire. Even that might be changing -- NL home run leader Chris Carter got $3 million from the Yankees (notwithstanding his performance after signing).
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
Dan: How's the team atmosphere
Bill Brink: It's fine. These guys have won 13 of 18. No player is ever thrilled to lose 11-3 but they're good.
BobbyToledo: We'll see Glasnow in ...
Bill Brink: Barring injury, I think it'll still take him a bit. He needs to consistently prove his stuff will get major leaguers out while facing minor leaguers, no easy feat, and it'd probably take regression from Williams or Kuhl.
Mike: Do you buy into any of the "we can't make a trade because it will mess up the team chemistry" theory. These guys are all adults, no?
Bill Brink: I don't buy it -- most of the time. These guys are adults and they want to win, and if the team acquires someone to help them do that they'll be happy. They can't publicly say, oh yea we need help in left field, because then the left fielder won't be thrilled about it. But if they made a particular type of trade -- say, the Dodgers trading Kershaw's personal catcher in the middle of a division race -- that type of stuff can upset the clubhouse.
BobbyToledo: Williams and Kuhl seem to get the benefit of the doubt because neither is blue chip, where the Pirates want Glasnow to be extremely polished. Is that fair? Kuhl sure walks a lot of batters.
Bill Brink: Williams and Kuhl have both shown improvement and the ability to adapt at the major league level, while Glasnow did not. I think that gives them more leash from the coaching staff.
Joe in FL: I know there is a lot of talk about the overvaluing of prospects. Many prospects never make an impact with the club they were traded to even the ones considered elite. However, can't the same be said for the veteran players that are exchanged each year? We like to remember the homeruns but most of the time the trade has very little to no impact.
Bill Brink: You're right, it works both ways. Happ was huge. Ryan Ludwick didn't help much. Robbie Grossman is starting in Minnesota and Colton Cain has never pitched in the majors. But the acquiring team doesn't know until they get the player, and not getting the player usually doesn't help the club.
Jeremy Fuller : Nunez looked like the perfect fit for the pirates rental and didnt have to give up much. Them not making that trade and letting him go to Boston shows me they are leaning towards Selling. Your thoughts
Bill Brink: The fact that another team acquired a player the Pirates were said to have checked on in a media report has no bearing on whether they're buying or selling.
Robert : Do I have the right to be upset if they do nothing
Bill Brink: Absolutely. Up to you to interpret their actions or inactions and react accordingly.
WVUFAN: McCutchen has stated he wants to be a pirate. Has the front office even engaged with him what it would take finically, or have they just written him off as they cant afford him?
Bill Brink: I would imagine they've had the conversation but I don't think they're serious at this point. McCutchen's representative knows what he can get on the open market and what the Pirates are likely to be comfortable paying.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, with the early game time. We'll have a good long chat next week to debrief the deadline. Thanks for stopping by!





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.