Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions:
Thomas Glovier, @pittsburghkeys: Will the Pirates win the NL central? If so, will it be because NH made a deal or because he “stands pat”?
Chris Boehme, @Cboehme2: In order to compete with the Cubs, would the Pirates be more inclined to add another bat with power or a top of the rotation pitcher?
Starkey: God, do I miss Kyle Lobstein. I was looking over Neal Huntington’s transactions from last season when I stumbled across Lobstein, who must have been pretty steamed when he was traded.
Who clawed his way to the majors.
Who finally came out of his shell.
Read More
Who buttered up management the minute he got here.
Who never cracked under pressure (except for sometimes).
Who always attacked the meat of the order.
Who took a bisque walk to the mound every time he pitched.
And who is having a very nice year (1.32 ERA) with the Marlins’ Class AAA affiliate in New Orleans.
But forget about Lobstein. Let me get to the main point here: I included the questions above as a sampling of the many trade-deadline inquiries I received, and I feel compelled first to acknowledge something that I do not believe has been acknowledged in public, at least not emphatically enough: Neal Huntington positively crushed the trade deadline last year.
We all made fun of Huntington’s deals. We ripped them to shreds. We laughed at Ivan Nova’s ERA (4.90 at the time). We lamented the loss of a lights-out closer (Mark Melancon) in the middle of a playoff race. We racked our brains to see if we remembered the Pirates facing this Felipe Rivero guy. We justifiably blasted Huntington for exhuming Dave Littlefield’s favorite phrase — “Financial Flexibility!” — and for finally parting with “top-10” prospects not as a way to land a star player but only as a way to shed Francisco Liriano’s salary.
And for the most part, we were dead wrong.
That is not to excuse Huntington for a very poor season. His major mistake was coming to believe the Pirates could afford to lose J.A. Happ and could rehab any old pitcher who came their way. That is why they arrogantly started the season with Jeff Locke, Juan Nicasio and Jon Niese in their rotation — and if they faltered, well, there was always Ryan Vogelsong.
But looking strictly at the deadline? The Pirates lost nobody of value and acquired Rivero and Nova, who’ve been the two best pitchers on the team for most of this season. Rivero has become a star, a player every team in baseball would love to have.
The guys the Pirates lost?
Well, those “top-10” prospects, Reese McGuire and Harold Ramirez, are now nowhere to found among the Toronto Blue Jays’ top 25 prospects. Neither has advanced past Class AA. Liriano, after a brief stretch of competence, has seen his ERA soar to Locke-ian levels and is taking on the look of a guy who could be out of baseball soon. Melancon imploded in more ways than one in San Francisco then got hurt.
True, sending Niese back to the Mets for the one and only Antonio Bastardo was a reminder that Huntington did not have a good year overall — and let’s not forget that McGuire was taken 18 picks before Aaron Judge in 2013 — but the idea that Huntington never does anything bold or dramatic or correct at the trade deadline is flat-out false.
Huntington brought in Happ two years ago. He fooled everyone last year, mostly by way of stealing Rivero, who is about as close to vintage Aroldis Chapman as you’ll find and is under Pirates control for several more years.
Maybe this year, he’ll bring back Lobstein.
Thomas Glovier, @pittsburghkeys: Will the Pirates win the NL central? If so, will it be because NH made a deal or because he “stands pat”?
Starkey: Oh yes, back to your question. The problem here is that the Chicago Cubs already beat the Pirates to Jose Quintana and apparently are not finished. I was just watching Buster Olney tell the world the Cubs are looking at Yu Darvish, Sonny Gray and Zach Britton.
What, not Bob Gibson?
It’s depressing. Even at last year’s deadline, while Huntington was quietly doing excellent work, Theo Epstein was reeling in the big fish that was Chapman.
The way I see it, Mr. pittsburghkeys, the Pirates must find a front-line starting pitcher to compete with the Cubs down the stretch. That won’t be Darvish or Gray or any of the high-profile commodities, but it might be the next Happ or Nova.
They could also use an outfielder. Matt Joyce return? Jay Bruce? Something better happen, because standing pat isn’t going to get it done.
Mark, @MarkPGH: Isn’t the story for pirate management is they built the team around the outfield and they played all of 8 games together this season?
Starkey: Was it that many, Mark? I look at the Pirates outfield the way I do the Steelers offense: I’d just like to see it together for one season, at the height of its powers, and I fear it will never happen.
One problem, of course, is Gregory Polanco’s constant injury issues. It’s as if that Greek God body is part blessing, part curse. So many long and lanky parts, all seemingly going in different directions. Whenever Polanco reaches full speed, be it in the outfield or on the base paths, I feel like a dad watching my kid suddenly speed up on training wheels, to the point where both of us are yelling, “Noooooooooooo!”

T. W. Barker, @TimBtheReferee: Would you ever officiate a sport? If so, which sport?
Starkey: I was a Little League umpire a very long time ago, Mr. TimBtheReferee, and I can tell you, it was a horrible experience. I thought it would be easy, but I quickly gained an appreciation for everything from proper positioning — I didn’t know where to stand at first base — to calling a consistent strike zone.
Listen, 90 percent isn’t good enough when it comes to major league umps correctly calling balls and strikes, but the fact that they get it right 90 percent of the time (approximately) at that level is nothing short of mind-blowing.
I’ve done a little basketball, and the eye opener there is the conditioning aspect. If you want to do it right — and I imagine it’s the same for hockey — you better be in shape.
I have tremendous respect for all officials at the youth levels, dealing with crazed parents and win-obsessed coaches. Their numbers, to no surprise, are dwindling.
John @jawnoftime: If the Pirates can win the division, they will __________ in October.
Starkey: Not have Starling Marte.
charles nestler, @charlesnestler: Why does Mullsey (sic) go right back to the same place he just came from for vacation?
Starkey: I rather admire Mullsy (proper spelling) for this gigantic move, and I don’t admire him for much, Charlie. Dude went to a North Carolina beach two weeks ago, came back, pretended to work with me for a week, and returned to the EXACT SAME BEACH for another week’s vacation.
Amazing.
Creative Name, @fireballsdeep: If you could pick a 6 man pgh media basketball team, who do you take?
Starkey: Very nice, Mr. fireballsdeep, and a lot of this depends on who qualifies as media. Are we talking analysts such as Tunch Ilkin here? How about part-timers such as Dorin Dickerson, who is doing wonderful work at 93.7 The Fan these days? He lettered in hoops at West Allegheny and would do serious damage to all of us, I’m sure.
For now, though, I’ll stick with full-timers in TV, radio and newspapers.
Center: Paul Zeise. He played basketball at Point Park, where he was a Rodman-like rebounder and defensive demon from what I understand. I beat him in a one-on-one outside of a hotel the day before Pitt’s terrible loss to Utah in the Fiesta Bowl many years ago, but he was hungover and I was hitting 3’s. I wouldn’t like my chances in a rematch.
Power forward: Ray Fittipaldo. He’s 6-2, 240 and played left guard — as in, football — at Holy Cross. I’m thinking he could grab the rebounds Zeise misses.
Forward: Andrew Fillipponi. He’s a pretty good athlete, and if that fails, he can simply annoy the living hell out of his opponent by arguing sports. I should point out that Poni and I played a legendary one-on-one six years ago, ending with me being carried out of the Settler’s Ridge LA Fitness on an orange gurney. I tore my left Achilles tendon.
I should also point out that in that three-game series, I won Game 1 (Poni is 20 years younger than me) and was winning Game 2 late when I took a jumper and heard my Achilles explode like a broken baseball bat upon landing. Poni made sure the front desk called 9-1-1 but did not accompany me to the hospital. Should he have? I honestly don’t know. It’s a question for next week’s mailbag. He has a pretty good mid-range game and can run the floor.
Actually, I’m cutting Poni in favor of Josh Miller, who is tall, in shape and a very good athlete. He was a high school hoopster in New Jersey, and I saw his skills when he helped me train for the Poni showdown. Lefty. Would probably be our best player, now that I think about it.
Guard: Mike White/Jason Mackey. I’m not sure how much Mike has left, but last I saw him play (20 years ago), he displayed an all-round game that rivaled Draymond Green’s. If he has deteriorated like me, I’ll go with Mackey, who apparently was a good high school quarterback at Brentwood and played low-level college baseball. I don’t know how that translates to basketball, but I’ll bet he can throw a mean outlet pass. He’s also 6-4.
Guard: Brian Batko. I didn’t know until this minute that Batko was captain of Shaler’s basketball team his senior year. He says it was not because of his skills but rather his veteran leadership. Whatever. It’s good enough for me. And if he can’t do the job, Rob King probably can. Another former college quarterback (Division III Washington, St. Louis), he was rated the No. 1 local media basketball player by none other than former Pitt basketball PR man Greg Hotchkiss, who organized media pickup games.
Sixth man: Me. I can still shoot 3’s at a very high rate — I set the daily record every time I do the Kennywood shoot — although I can no longer sprint on account of the Achilles issue, a disgusting gut and a general lack of motivation. I make Pedro Alvarez look like an elite defender.
If I am unavailable, which is highly likely, Tim Benz could step in. He has the most irritating game of any human being I have ever competed against. But it’s effective. I’ll tell you that. It’s effective.
Mascot: Mullsy
Coach: Bob Pompeani.
I apologize if I missed anyone. Please tell me if there is a Batko-like secret weapon out there that I should know about. Is ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler considered Pittsburgh media? I think so. He’s around 6-5, too, I think.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.