Neal Huntington didn’t put together a bad baseball team this season. He could have done more, obviously, and really should add a player or two. But he put together a decent baseball team, and his best players screwed it up.

That is the undeniable, inconvenient truth.

So no matter how many livid talk-show callers lead off with “Nutting …” or “Huntington …” or “Clint Hurdle …” the story of the 2017 Pirates thus far is that most of their better players have either radically underachieved or never showed up.

It’s astonishing that more people aren’t willing to acknowledge as much.

Advertise with us

Bob Nutting is cheap. We get it. But a bottom-10 payroll is not a death sentence. Milwaukee has a smaller one, and it leads the division. Arizona has a smaller one, and it was 52-33 through 85 games.

Huntington hired Phil Gosselin to play baseball and then exhumed Max Moroff for another spin. Two of several questionable moves. Manager Hurdle maintained a monk-like devotion to Tony Watson and stubbornly fills out that Sunday lineup card (the Moroff Special) in order to rest players for a late-season run that probably won’t happen. Highly annoying.

But none of it compares to this jarring fact: The Pirates’ top two hitters from last season, Starling Marte and Jung Ho Kang, two still-blossoming talents, literally disappeared! Their mindless, selfish acts practically sabotaged the season before it began.

Which team out there survives the absence of two top-four bats for the first 85 games of a season?

Marte wore a uniform for 13 of those games but admittedly was a shell of himself, knowing he’d been busted for steroids and would be suspended. Kang can’t even get into the country because of his drunken-driving habit.

Advertise with us

The list hardly stops there.

The club’s two biggest stars, Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole, also made large contributions to a lousy first half.

It’s awesome that McCutchen went Ted Williams-crazy in June. He is playing as well as he ever has. But he was awful for the first two months. He slumped badly from the 3-spot in the order, helping put the Pirates in a hole.

Cole has been all over the place. Terrific some nights, like Wednesday in Philadelphia, awful others.

His performance in June was a good example. Cole had three excellent starts and three others where he allowed seven earned runs and once blew up at his manager in the dugout. His ERA stands at a thoroughly unimpressive 4.43.

Advertise with us

There is more.

Gregory Polanco — another player who easily could have been projected as one of the five best on the team — has only begun to show signs of life, and the once-reliable Watson has come apart like a Lego character.

Watson leads the majors with seven blown saves. Some of those weren’t legitimate save opportunities, because they occurred before the ninth inning, but if he’d done his job just four of those seven times, the Pirates likely would be a .500 team and a good weekend out of first place in the NL Central.

Now imagine Marte and Kang batting, say, first and fourth. Imagine a halfway decent April-May McCutchen, a non-comatose Polanco and a typical Cole, and where are we?

It’s not like anyone else is far outperforming expectations, to the point where you could say, “Yeah, the stars haven’t done much, but (fill in the blank) are having such ridiculous years that it balances out.”

Advertise with us

Somebody’s always going to have a bad year, or a bad first half or a bad few months. But not this.

That is not to absolve management or ownership. It must stink to be a baseball fan here because the Pirates are constantly worried about saving a buck. The minute somebody shows promise, the question immediately becomes: How soon before they get rid of him? Nobody can enjoy McCutchen’s renaissance because he could be tossed out the window any second.

That’s no way to live.

But that’s not the story of the 2017 Pirates.

The lousy first half was mostly on the players — and if there’s going to be a turnaround, well, that’ll be on them, too.

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.