Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:
Mike White, @mw_ste3lcity: What are your thoughts on Martavis Bryant?
Starkey: Well, when he’s not baking more than Rachael Ray, Mike, he is a game-changing receiver (in an unrelated note, I think, I just discovered that Martavis spellchecks to “Martinis”). He is a player of such rare quality, in fact, that he transforms the entire offense by his mere presence. Do you know of many 6-foot-4 receivers who run like that?
Bryant has 14 touchdown catches in 21 career games, not to mention a 17.3-yard average. That mark would have put him third in the league this season. As you probably know, he has applied for reinstatement and will be subject to a meeting with commissioner Roger Goodell (assuming Goodell is not booed to death in Houston) or his representative, along with a league medical advisor who will make a recommendation to Goodell.
The question on a lot of minds seems to be this: Would a clean Martavis be the No. 1 receiver who could make Antonio Brown expendable?
My answer: Be serious.
Read More
How can you trust a guy who already got himself suspended for a year? Besides which, I seriously doubt Bryant could be as consistently productive and electric as Brown. Not many could.
The narrative on Brown has become borderline unfathomable, by the way. You know when you make one of those Pros-Cons ledgers when considering a new job or a new school or some such thing?
The one on whether to keep Brown would read like this:
CON: Took inappropriate Facebook video
PRO: Won division with legendary play
CON: Sometimes pouts
PRO: Won a playoff game in first quarter
CON: Is concerned with numbers
PRO: Puts up historically significant numbers
CON: Twerked in end zone
PRO: Found end zone 14 times
CON: Makes Ben mad
PRO: Turns 5-yard Ben passes into TDs
The game-changer in the Cons column would be if Brown did, in fact, intentionally run the wrong routes — even just once — in the AFC title game. My Post-Gazette colleague Ron Cook, in his provocative column Sunday, suggested it might have happened.
If that is proven true, then it should be an A-1 story under the headline: “Brown sabotaged Steelers in AFC championship,” and Brown should immediately be traded. That is a fireable offense.
It’s one thing to run the wrong routes because you’re not focused (and I’m sure Brown has done that). It’s quite another to sabotage your team by intentionally running the wrong routes in a conference championship game (I refuse to believe that happened).
In the meantime, I’m sticking with the Pros and putting Brown maybe third on the team’s Most Selfish Player List (behind guys who regularly get suspended) and second or third on Most Dramatic Player List — definitely behind the quarterback, who, as you might have heard, is thinking about retiring. Ben Roethlisberger also ripped the coach in public when the Steelers won to improve to 4-1.
You know, it’s funny: Tom Brady sets the tone in New England by basically demanding that the coach reprimand him like everyone else. Here, the quarterback reprimands the coach!
Check out this story on how the Patriots’ culture runs through Brady.
Nick Bartley, @Bartl3y: Why are the Penguins treating MAF like trash?
Starkey: I don’t think they are treating him poorly, Nick. I think this is what happens in pro sports. Mike Sullivan has decided to go with the guy who’s been the better player in essentially the same amount of games this season, not to mention the guy who won him a Cup last season.
Lookie here:
Player | GP | W-L-T | GAA | Sv. Pct.
Murray | 26 | 17-6-1 | 2.42 | .921
Fleury | 27 | 13-7-4 | 3.23 | .904
Once again Tuesday night, it looks like Murray's net, even though he has given up seven goals over his past two outings, both losses. You might counter: Why shouldn’t Fleury get a chance? The same could have been asked after Murray gave up a touchdown in D.C. earlier this month and started the next game. At that point, it became clear that Sullivan had identified his guy and was going to ride with him as we hit the home stretch. I can’t blame him for that, although I wouldn’t let Fleury rot on the bench.
Now the question is: How much longer for Fleury in Pittsburgh?
At this point, I’m keeping him for the rest of the season. I don’t think the Penguins are going to net a king’s ransom in return at the deadline, so to me it’s worth having a solid insurance policy in case Murray gets injured (again). Fleury had an excellent month of December. The Penguins are lucky to have a backup of such high quality.
The best move now, in pursuit of another Stanley Cup, is no move at all when it comes to the goaltenders.
Big Large, @BigLarge2: Please, Joe, do you happen to know Victoria’s Secret? #Perplexed
Starkey: I dated Victoria in college and promised I would never tell.
Kevin Benedict, @KevinBenedict1: Genny Cream Ale or Pabst Blue Ribbon?
Starkey: Genny Cream in a Patriots-over-Steelers-like blowout, and of course that again brings me back to my college years (when I dated Victoria). This was back in the mid-1980s, before Mullsy or craft beers were born. Both have been a horrible blight on America.
And it leads to a list. The five greatest old-school, very cheap but very effective college beers at Cortland State circa 1984:
Genny Cream
Meister Brau
Milwaukee’s Best (or Old Milwaukee)
Narragansett
Kohler Lager
A special mention to fire-brewed Stroh’s and the 15-pack — the best American invention since the light bulb.
abb, @mini_abb: What would your 'walk up' song be?
Starkey: “Tangled up in Blue,” perhaps, or maybe “Cowgirl in the Sand.”
Thanks, Dan, @dkviper: If Evgeni Malkin was named Evan Martin and was born in Saskatoon would he have made the #nhl100 list? #NHLAllStar
Starkey: Of course he would have, Mr. Thanks, Dan. Did you see the list of 58 voters? I haven’t seen that many ancient Canadians since Gordon Lightfoot played Maple Leaf Gardens in ’89. It’s not even worth going into. Malkin compared to Johnny Bucyk or Brendan Shanahan? Please. Every coach and GM in the history of the game, if their job depended on winning a Cup in a given season, would choose Malkin over many players on that list.
Malkin has won pretty much everything there is to win. He is 14th all-time and second active in points per game. I have tremendous respect for a lot of the voters, but every single one of them, including Patrick Lalime — wait, Patrick Lalime was a voter? — should be embarrassed that Malkin was omitted.
However, I would hate to end on such a negative note, Mr. dkviper, especially in regard to Gordon Lightfoot, who is a bona fide legend. I saw him play the IC Light Amphitheater about 10 years ago and might never recover.
Top 5 Lightfoot songs:
5. Early Morning Rain.
4. Rainy Day People (rain is certainly a theme so far)
3. Sundown
2. Carefree Highway
“If You Could Read My Mind,” incidentally, is the finest song or poem ever written on the ultimate unknowability of our partners, our desperate and futile search to know others and to be known and the inherent hopelessness of all relationships.
I don’t know where we went wrong but the feeling’s gone and I just can’t get it back
Have a nice Valentine's Day.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.