Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:
Rotunda Renegades, @pghrenegades: How many Chris Muellers are roaming the city right now? How far does this conspiracy go?
Starkey: OK, there’s a lot to break down here, Mr. Renegades. First of all, what are the odds of two Chris Muellers writing sports for the Beaver County Times?
One of them is my radio partner Chris Mueller (’MULL-ER’), who writes columns. The other is a Steelers beat writer named Chris Mueller (’MULE-ER’), who broke a major story the other night, when he witnessed 260-pound Steelers linebackers coach Joey Porter — third on the team’s all-time sack list — apparently pull a Jarvis Jones by failing to get past a 5-foot-6, 145-pound blocker.
Of course, the blocker in question — officer Paul Abel — got a little help from his friends (you’d think Porter would be sick of being double-teamed by now) in protecting Jon Neskow, doorman at The Flats.
And I must interject here: Whenever I see the phrase “doorman” I think of the greatest doorman in doorman history: slam-dunk first-ballot Doorman Hall-of-Famer “Carlton The Doorman” from the sitcom “Rhoda.” His disembodied voice (coming from a man named Lorenzo Music, who also voiced “Garfield” the cartoon cat) delivered the trademark phrase: “Hello, this is Carlton, your doorman.” Check out his work here.
Anyway, what follows is Officer Abel describing his pass-blocking technique in the police report. In this scenario, picture Neskow, the doorman, as the quarterback.
“I placed my hands on Porter’s chest to prevent him from advancing back toward Neskow,” Abel wrote. “Porter grabbed both of my wrists, pushing them back toward me. Porter’s grasp was so strong and he was holding my wrists so tightly that I could not pull them away from him, no matter how hard I tried.”
Defensive holding?
Unfortunately for Porter, the play went to review. Abel had turned on his body camera midway through it. The Steelers put Porter on leave, which is a major story, of course, but not nearly as interesting as the social media confusion over which Chris Mueller broke the story and whether it was, in fact, a real story. A national radio outlet even mistook one Mueller for the other.
People, @ByChrisMueller covers the Steelers for the @timesscores (and you should follow him!), this is not someone trying to prank me.
— Chris Mueller (@ChrisMuellerPGH) January 9, 2017
Radio guy Mueller was forced to release a statement of sorts, via Twitter, late Sunday night: “People, @ByChrisMueller covers the Steelers for the @timesscores (and you should follow him!), this is not someone trying to prank me.”
All of which, believe it or not, leads me to LaMarr Woodley. I can’t help it. I just saw his name at No. 5 among Steelers all-time sack leaders, and I feel like he deserves more credit, even if he did expand faster than the Big Ten Conference the minute he signed that fat new contract.
All you need to know is that the top five postseason sack leaders of ALL-TIME read like this:
Player...Games...Sacks
1. Willie McGinest...18...16.0
2. Bruce Smith...20...14.5
3. Terrell Suggs...17...12.5
4. Reggie White...19...12.0
5. LaMarr Woodley...8...11.0
6. Charles Haley...21...11.0
7. Clay Matthews...13...11.0
That’s right: 11 sacks in just eight games, one of which he did not start! Compare that to Hall of Famer Kevin Greene, who had all of 1.5 sacks in six playoff games with the Steelers. Greene, by the way, is willing to take Joey Porter’s place on the coaching staff. He tweeted the following to @Steelersdepot : “If My Steelers need me, I’m there,” he wrote, failing to add, “except in playoff games during my career.”
I’m not saying LaMarr Woodley is a Hall of Famer, by any means. I’m just saying he should be remembered as a guy who brought it, big-time, when the chips were down. Playing on James Harrison’s opposite side sure helped. Harrison has 10 playoff sacks, and counting, in 17 games. But Woodley did his own work.
I feel quite comfortable saying Super Bowl No. 6 doesn’t happen without LaMarr Woodley. Never forget that. He had six sacks in three playoff games that year. Two in each game, or one for every Chris Mueller who writes sports for the Beaver County Times.
Joe Starkey, @JoeStarkey1: Did your research on Steelers sack leaders lead you to any impossibly obscure but somewhat interesting statistical nuggets?
Starkey: It did, as a matter of a fact, and thank you for asking. I will present these in trivia form, to be answered at the bottom of this mailbag. All stats courtesy of the miracle that is profootballreference.com.
Who is the Steelers all-time regular-season leader in ….
a.) Fumble recoveries
b.) Passes defensed (guys from ‘70s not included here)
c.) Fumbles
d.) Longest interception return
e.) Forced fumbles (no ‘70s guys)
d.) Safeties
e.) Kick return touchdowns
Peter F., @petefrompitt: Which Steelers coach besides Joey Porter is most likely to end up in handcuffs on the South Side?
Starkey: I’m going to say none, Peter F. I think Peezy might have the market cornered on this one, but I’ll also say this: My information, unconfirmed, is that Porter was going to meet ex-teammates and possibly one current Steelers player, at The Flats. So the idea that he was going to party with a bunch of current players is not one I’m buying. Did he need to walk away from whatever confrontation occurred? Absolutely. But I need to know more about the policeman and the doorman before I’m willing to crush Porter here.
Ryan Hall, @Bankonit23: Does a high school football coach leave his superstar QB in a decided playoff game?
Starkey: Actually, Mr. Bankonit23, most NFL coaches leave their quarterbacks on the field in decided playoff games — and you can bank on that.
Mike McCarthy sent Aaron Rodgers onto the field leading 31-13 with 8:31 left the other day, and Rodgers passed twice on a long TD drive. Or consider that Tom Brady dropped back to pass with 6:30 left in a 2011 playoff game against Denver with his team leading 45-10.
But I still vehemently disagree with Mike Tomlin putting Ben Roethlisberger on the field with 5:55 left the other day and the Steelers leading 30-12 — and especially for calling a pass on third down.
My reasons for that:
• Few quarterbacks play the position as recklessly as Roethlisberger. That’s why you love him, but it’s also why you should take extra precautions. Did you see him try to make the tackle on his second-quarter interception? That was insane. But that’s Big Ben. If you put him on the field, he can’t help himself. He competes like a linebacker. As the head coach, you have a decade of evidence of that. SO DON’T PUT HIM OUT THERE WITH A 30-12 LEAD WHEN YOU’VE ALREADY REMOVED YOUR STAR RUNNING BACK. Should Ben know better than to run around and try to make a play when a game’s clearly over? Yeah, but he doesn’t. So don’t give him the chance.
• This was an especially chippy game in which the Dolphins took great exception to their quarterback nearly being beheaded. What’s more, the Dolphins have a guy named Ndamukong Suh, who already injured Roethlisberger once this season on a dirty play and is capable of anything.
• Tomlin, as much as any coach in the NFL, has been damaged by not having injured stars available for playoff runs. If anyone should be taking extra care to protect his A-list players, it’s him. That’s why he sat Ben in Week 17, right? It’s presumably why he also pulled him late in a blowout win over the Chiefs earlier this season.
Tomlin explained that Ben was put out there to help aid the run game with DeAngelo Williams (huh?) but admitted he got “overaggressive” on the pass call.
“I take responsibility for throwing it,” Tomlin said. “I made the call.”
Ben talked about it during his show on 93.7 The Fan, explaining that he’ll never ask to come out of a game and that it was, indeed Tomlin’s decision to keep him in.
“He’s the boss,” Ben said. “He tells me to come out. Sometimes I may fight him on it … but really it’s his call.”
Yes. Yes it is.
Robert Hladio, @HladioR: Do you think Big Ben for some superstitious reason likes having injury problems heading into big games, either real or not?
Starkey: I’m not sure about that, Robert, but some very, very strange things have transpired in this regard.
Just last year, Ben wasn’t OK to take the field for the second-last drive against the Bengals, but he insisted on coming out for the potential winning drive about nine seconds later? I’m not accusing anyone of anything. He’s as tough as any quarterback I’ve ever seen. It’s just flat-out strange.
He also was said to have a shoulder issue coming out of Cincy game but flung it about 109 yards in the air on the first play against Denver. Then you had the broken-toes incident all those years ago (”Ben does not have broken toes, OK?” Bill Cowher said) from the AFC title game against New England, and the concussion-but-not-a-concussion situation at the end of the Baltimore game two years ago.
I’m trying to remember the last playoff game Ben started and finished without injury questions. I guess it was the Tebow game.
Here’s the important thing: Ben looked great, for the most part, against Miami. He had the third-highest playoff passer rating of his career (105.3). So whether his “right shoulder stuff,” as he put it Tuesday, is bothering him, or whether this old-foot-injury-aggravated situation pops up again, he needs to stay hot. Or hotter.
In his past six playoff games, Roethlisberger has seven touchdown passes and seven interceptions. That kind of ratio won’t cut it against Kansas City and possibly New England.
Josh Williams, @No1PittSports: Was there ever a time you nearly walked away from your profession for another line of work?
Starkey: Every night, at precisely 6 p.m., right after I say, “Good night, Chris.”
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: What would you do to make the college football championship game longer? More reviews? More commercials?
Starkey: Is it over yet? My God, nothing ruins a great game like having it last longer than “Dances With Wolves.” I fell asleep. I missed the last two drives. Of course, millions and millions still watched, but college football games have become ridiculously long. Longer than ever before, actually. ESPN recently reported that games this year averaged a mind-numbing 3 hours, 24 minutes.
“I would like to see shorter games,” Pac-12 commissioner Larry Scott said.
We all would, Larry. But how? Some suggestions in the ESPN story included a running clock on first downs (until the final two or five minutes of each half), shortening halftime, limiting the number of replays, reducing the number of timeouts, a shorter play clock, changing in-game substitution rules and limiting the number of commercial breaks.
Yes to all of it. Thank you.
TRIVIA ANSWERS
a.) Ben Roethlisberger (27)
b.) Ike Taylor (33)
c.) Franco Harris (90)
d.) Lawrence Timmons (89 yards, vs. New England in 2008)
e.) Greg Lloyd (34)
d.) Ernie Stautner and Bill McPeak (3 apiece)
e.) Lynn Chandnois (3)
Chandnois is a fascinating figure. A star at Michigan State before the Steelers took him 8th overall in 1950, he remains third in NFL history in kick-return average at 29.6, behind only Gale Sayers (30.6) and Cordarrelle Patterson (30.4) and still ahead of luminaries such as Fitzgerald Toussaint.
Thanks, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.