Welcome to Joe Starkey’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Buffalo, Bob Dylan and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jraystarkey@gmail.com. On to the questions:

Ricky Kolar, @Ricky_Kolar3: Was it weird seeing Burfict act all buddy-buddy with people on the Steelers after the final kneel down?

Starkey: Your question prompted me to go back and look at the final snap, Mr. Kolar. Mostly, cameras showed Mike Tomlin whooping it up on the sidelines. I saw Burfict shake hands with Marcus Gilbert. He also hugged Le’Veon Bell. The only surprise there is that he didn’t dive at Bell’s legs or knee him in the groin during their exchange. Rest assured, whatever fake pleasantries may have transpired after the game, the Steelers have no respect for a player who tries to rob people of their livelihoods every time they play.

Eli Rogers had an apt description of Burfict a day later when I asked him to describe his first Burfict experience: “He’s like a chicken with his head cut off, wild man out there.”

Advertise with us

Your question made me contemplate two other related issues:

What exactly, could be the psychological explanation for the Bengals’ blowups against the Steelers?

How does Marvin Lewis still have a job?

Taking the second one first, Lewis is 2-14 at home against the Steelers, including playoff games. Think about that. What would happen to a college coach who was 2-14 at home against his team’s biggest rival?

(Answer: He never would have gotten past 2-13, given the nature of last season’s final loss).

Advertise with us

Then there is the small issue of Lewis owning ZERO PLAYOFF WINS in 14 years. Picture Chuck Noll, having arrived in Pittsburgh in 1969, still sitting there without a playoff win in 1983. It’s ridiculous. The only other coach in NFL history, besides Lewis, to have worked for 14 or more seasons without a single playoff win was Jim “Playoffs!” Mora. He was 0-6. Lewis is 0-7.

For all the good work Lewis has done — and he did turn a perennial loser into a consistent winner — he should have been fired after last year’s playoff debacle. His team blew up emotionally (again), in historic fashion, and that is always a reflection on the head coach. But the Bengals brought him back, and you got what you got Sunday. Another meltdown, after which Lewis could only blame the officials, calling out one by name.

As for his players, it’s almost sad to watch them in games against the Steelers. Their ill-timed, pathetic celebrations seem to be classic little-brother-feels-inferior-so-he’s-overdoing-it cries for help.

Jeremy Hill, the guy who was so busy mocking William Gay in last year’s playoff game that he forgot to hold onto the ball, tried to rip a Terrible Towel in half. In the second quarter.

Pac Man Jones — flagged for 15 yards earlier in the game — went wild when the Bengals stopped a two-point conversion (except it was right after they gave up a back-breaking touchdown).

Advertise with us

Domata Peko gestured to the Steelers bench after he stopped Bell (except the game was basically over as the Steelers shoved the ball down the Bengals’ throats to run out the clock).

Dre Kirkpatrick blamed the officials. Just like his coach. (I’m only surprised the Bengals didn’t celebrate stopping the Steelers in victory formation).

Oh well, I’m sure Marvin will get this all straightened out.

Mr. Matthews, @dante3346: With 2016 coming to a close, what athlete’s had a year like Crosby?

Starkey: Other than Phil Kessel, Mr. Matthews? Only one comes to mind, although if somebody had a big year in UFC, I wouldn’t know. I’m a little behind on soccer, as well. So I would put Sid and LeBron James atop my list.

Advertise with us

All LeBron did was bring the sports-sick city of Cleveland its first championship since 1964. It was no ordinary run, either. The Cavaliers stormed back from a 3-1 series deficit against the greatest regular-season team in NBA history. Sid led his team to a Stanley Cup, won the Conn Smythe Trophy, captained Canada to World Cup win, basked in the enormous glow of one Phil Kessel and is off to a ridiculous start this season, with 21 goals in his first 26 games.

He’s pretty good.

Robert Egan, @Robdogg039: Top 5 greatest NBA players of all-time?

Starkey: Thank you for the question, Rob Dog.

FIVE GREATEST

Advertise with us

5. LeBron James

4. Wilt Chamberlain

3. Magic Johnson

2. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

1. Michael Jordan

Advertise with us

FIVE FAVORITE

5. George Gervin

4. Pistol Pete

3. Magic Johnson

2. Bernard King

Advertise with us

1. Bob McAdoo

FIVE YOU WOULDN’T THINK COULD BEAT ANY OTHER TEAM BUT COULD

Point guard: Isiah Thomas (unguardable in prime)

Shooting guard: Kevin Durant (I kind of like a 6-9 shooting guard who makes all his shots)

Small forward: Charles Barkley (not his fault his teams weren’t good enough)

Advertise with us

Power forward: Bill Walton (yes, I’m pulling him out of 1976 and putting him at power forward)

Center: Shaq (The most un-movable player in history)

Sixth man: Vernon Maxwell, because he wasn’t afraid of anyone — especially Jordan.

Seventh man: Steph Curry. He’s not a microwave. He’s a nuclear reactor.

Chris B, @cbeddick66: A friend of mine lost out on $5,000 on a block pool when Norwood missed wide right. Do you still have nightmares regarding that?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Yes.

Zach, @zbb5006: If you put all the Penguins players on the Pirates, and all the Pirates players on the Penguins, who has a better winning percentage?

Starkey: Great question, Mr. zbb5006, and I can only say this: Skating is really hard. The Pirates would have no chance, especially after Bob Nutting made them rent plastic skates. The Penguins have Sidney Crosby. Did you ever see footage of him pounding baseballs over the right-field wall at PNC Park during batting practice? He’d make things interesting.

Meanwhile, speaking of Pirates and Penguins mixing, my friend Adam Gretz wrote a piece about the old Pittsburgh Pirates hockey team on SBNation a few years ago. I will borrow part of it now:

The Pirates lasted in the NHL for five seasons between 1925 and 1930, playing their home games at the Duquesne Gardens, an old trolley barn that was repurposed into a multipurpose sports arena in the Oakland section of Pittsburgh. ... While the team had very little success on the ice, winning only 67 of its 212 games and qualifying for the playoffs twice in five tries, it was a team under player/coach Odie Cleghorn that was, in some ways, ahead of its time.

Apparently, old Foghorn Cleghorn was the first to institute line changes. So there’s that.

Advertise with us

Mike, @coachpsu316: Thoughts on when Kasparaitis scored the GWG against Buffalo in 2001 playoffs?

Starkey: My first thought was, did Dominik Hasek have a bet on the game? My second thought was to get my story in as fast as humanly possible. And I couldn’t think of a lede. I distinctly remember that. Darius Kasparaitis had just beaten Dominik Hasek on a wrist shot in Game 7 of a playoff series, and I couldn’t think of a lede. It was horrifying. I don’t remember what I came up with, but I do remember Kasparaitis sitting at his locker with the puck, smiling like a butcher’s dog, and Kevin Stevens saying, “He has the worst wrist shot in the league!”

Thanks, kiddies. Happy Holidays, and be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jraystarkey@gmail.com).