The next three weeks won’t lack for Pirates trade speculation.
Such is life when the last time the organization signed a free agent to a multi-year contract was December 2016 (Ivan Nova) and the current group could lose 95-plus games.
Andrew Heaney, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Caleb Ferguson, Tommy Pham and Adam Frazier are on expiring deals and will almost assuredly be moved, but that should be the end of the Pirates’ trade activity.
Yes, seriously.
As frustrating as this season has been, I’d rather see them take a conservative approach at the deadline — with one exception — and resist the temptation to sell, sell, sell.
Allow me to explain.
Read More
First and foremost, I don’t trust general manager Ben Cherington to maximize value on potential deals involving Mitch Keller, David Bednar or Dennis Santana, pitchers under club control who are having solid years and could theoretically help procure offensive help.
Whether it’s been with hitting coaches, an over-arching philosophy, analytics, free agent signings or trades, Cherington has been terrible in this area:
• Since 2020, the Pirates are last in MLB in runs (3,095), slugging percentage (.368), OPS (.670), home runs (724) and on-base percentage (.302).
• They're 29th in runs scored (319) this season, but that's also just one more than the White Sox, who had played one fewer game as of Thursday morning. They’re last or tied for last in slugging percentage (.340) and OPS (.641) this season.
• Of the 14 hitters Cherington has added within a week of the trade deadline since 2020, the eight who’ve made MLB have added a grand total of .3 bWAR.
As I’ve written, no, I don’t understand or agree with keeping Cherington. My opinion is also meaningless. The Pirates have their reasons, and those could matter here when we discuss what happens beyond the MLB draft and (theoretically) the trade deadline.
Put another way: Is Cherington still here because it's easier to make a move in August, September or October? Or is there genuine belief in the GM? I'd bet the former.
During my one-on-one with Pirates owner Bob Nutting in May, I asked why Derek Shelton was fired while Cherington and president Travis Williams remained, followed up when Nutting didn’t actually answer, and asked a third question about how fans should interpret canning the manager but not the other two decision-makers.
Nutting said bigger changes would be “distracting” and wouldn’t “make us better right now,” emphasizing a need to prioritize 2025. I sort of saw that at the time, but how could you bring back the guy who went from 76 wins in 2023 and ’24 to potentially 10 fewer in 2025?
My opinion: You can’t.
Which is why Nutting, if nothing else, should prevent Cherington from attempting a Hail Mary trade that almost assuredly won’t connect while preserving the few assets the Pirates do have for the new person in charge and beyond.
After all, remember what the Pirates are trying to do here. They need to win with Paul Skenes. That should’ve happened this year. They damn sure better make decisions oriented toward winning in 2026 — and that should include players, not number-crunchers.
Having a starter like Keller helps, the same for someone in Bednar — who has recaptured his two-time All-Star form — and as good of a setup man or secondary closing option as you’ll find in Santana.
If you want to win, and they should, don’t gut the bullpen. But really don’t give away more pitching for nothing in return.
One name we’ve already heard is Bryan Reynolds. No, no, no and no. Obviously Reynolds isn’t having his best year (83 OPS+ compared to 119 for his career), but that’s why you stand pat. Treat 2025 as an aberration. Don’t sell an asset at its lowest point.
The cases for Heaney, Ferguson (2.77 ERA in 40 games), Kiner-Falefa and Frazier are simple. Return might be minimal, but it’s something. It’s also incredible how Pham (MLB-best .444 average since June 22) has become a trade candidate now that he can actually see.
But again, the Pirates should not trade anyone with a contract that runs beyond this season, at least not until they reset this offseason.
The lone exception is Ke’Bryan Hayes, who has apparently attracted interest from the Yankees and others. If the Pirates can find someone swayed by Hayes’ .273 average since June 1, great. He’s a fantastic player but a poor fit for the Pirates.
They’re among the best in baseball at preventing runs. They need help producing them.
It’s why I hope Cherington doesn’t take a big swing later this month. I can’t fathom what reason the Pirates would have to bring him back, and the past six years — literally and figuratively — haven’t exactly been filled with a lot of home runs.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.