Ignore the blazing velocity, ridiculous splinker, in-game adjustments, finishing kick or lockdown work with men on base. The most impressive thing about Paul Skenes might not be specific to baseball.
Better yet have been traits like work ethic and humility. Perspective that belies his age (22). The duality that exists when it comes to Skenes’ intensity and laser-focus mixed with an awareness of what he represents, not to mention deftly toeing the line between confidence and cockiness.
There are strands of Sidney Crosby in there. It’s also a way to explain Skenes’ brilliance through 10 starts, the entire, dominant force now heading to Arlington, Texas, for the MLB All-Star Game, as Skenes will join Bryan Reynolds in representing the Pirates for the midsummer classic.
"Obviously starting the year in Triple-A, the odds of going to the MLB All-Star Game are pretty slim, so that wasn't one of my goals necessarily or expectations for this season," Skenes said. "It's just a huge honor that I'm able to do it after playing just a short span in the big leagues."
I love what Major League Baseball did here, acknowledging how good Skenes has been and disregarding the fact that he debuted on May 11. He’s been among the best pitchers in baseball since that time. Why wouldn’t he be an All-Star?
“He obviously deserves it,” Reynolds said. “I think it’s the right call.”
Read More
How could anyone disagree?
Skenes has a 2.12 ERA in those 10 starts, with 78 strikeouts and a 1.01 WHIP. The only National League pitcher with a better ERA since May 11: Atlanta’s Reynaldo Lopez (1.82) through the same number of starts.
Nobody in the NL has struck out more than Skenes since he toed a major league rubber for the first time, the Air Force and LSU product long ago becoming must-see TV.
“Paul has done really good things, and I think people in the game have realized that,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said. “It’s a credit to him, and it’s a really cool honor that a guy who came up in the middle of May that he has put himself on this platform.”
Shelton was disappointed that Mitch Keller won’t be joining Skenes and Reynolds at Globe Life Field — and I certainly get it. Colin Holderman has a case, too. But as much as I respect Keller and Holderman and know they’ve been outstanding for the Pirates, at 42-47 after Sunday’s heartbreaking loss, it would be tough to justify Pittsburgh getting three.
There’s also more competition when it comes to starting pitchers than outfielders, which takes us to the circus that will surround Skenes in this setting — and why I hope it doesn’t put him in an unenviable spot.
Given what he’s done, becoming the first-ever No. 1 overall pick to make the All-Star Game the season after his draft year, Skenes might become the biggest non-Shohei Ohtani story there, the attention constant, the questions plentiful and the media hordes massive.
I don’t question whether Skenes can handle it.
Given what he’s experienced in his life, there’s little that can genuinely overwhelm Skenes. The best hitters in the American League will inevitably become nameless gray faces.
Asked Sunday to pick somebody he was most eager to face, Skenes said he couldn’t settle on anyone in particular.
“It's tough to pick one just because of how concentrated the talent is,” Skenes said. “There are so many good players around the league."
None will attract a bigger crowd — and there’s nothing wrong with that. Watching him pitch is fun, as we know well. Anyone who hasn’t seen Skenes will find out soon enough.
It’s the job of MLB to grow the game and market stars. Skenes fits the description. But I hope the idea of starting or attention paid to Skenes doesn’t ruffle the feathers or anyone else attending the event.
“That would be cool,” Skenes said when I asked about the possibility of starting. “I have no expectations. I don't know how that works or who gets to decide that kinda thing. But that would definitely be cool."
As much as I’ve loved watching Skenes pitch, Chris Sale, Ranger Suarez, Lopez and Zack Wheeler have solid cases. They’ve all made between 6-8 more starts than Skenes. Lopez has a better ERA. Sale has the best WHIP (0.91) in the NL and 49 more strikeouts.
Would veterans get upset if a 10-start rookie was handed the ball first because he piqued the curiosity of fans? I hope not. But if we’re talking about performance bonuses in a contract, you never know.
More than anything, I want Skenes to enjoy the experience. As he reflected on this honor following Sunday’s loss, Skenes recalled his childhood spent as an Angels fan and really liking Mike Trout, as well as taking note of pictures in opposing ballparks depicting various All-Stars.
Skenes’ appreciation for the game’s brightest stars is cool. He’s now officially one of them.
But think for a second how special it would be to have Skenes start the game and for the country to embrace another Ohtani moment, where the right-hander splinkers someone, blows heat past Aaron Judge or whatever the case may be. Entertainment value, off the charts.
If Skenes starts, I hope and expect others to welcome him — because he’s certainly earned it. I know it will mean a lot for him to operate in that setting.
We should also hope Skenes gets a few seconds to sit back and consider all he’s accomplished over the past year: a national championship at LSU, the MLB draft, his path to the big leagues, the success here, all of it.
It’s not by accident, and Skenes should be proud of how quickly he has adjusted.
"You definitely can't expect it,” Skenes said. “I think it's just a product of being present and doing the work that it takes, that kinda thing.”
Whether Skenes gets the ball first or not, it’s also incredible to think that we’re only getting started with this storyline.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG on X.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.