Telling the story about the one that got away is never as satisfying as forwarding a photo, showing off a mount or feeding the family with the one that didn’t get away.
A week into firearm deer season, a lot of hunters can’t stop thinking about a momentary opportunity — a crucial few seconds — that didn’t pan out. The big buck zigged when you thought he was going to zag, or maybe you caught a glimpse of those magnificent antlers but never got a chance to pull the trigger.
That deer might still be out there. How can you find him again?
Hunting for a specific animal is generally not a strategy for firearm deer season. But some of the tactics used by archers can help a firearm hunter to find and target Mr. Big.
Smart archers get close — 30 yards or so — to ensure a clean kill. They start scouting in the spring, discover particular animals of interest, learn their food and water sources, find natural traffic patterns, take advantage of the rut, hang multiple stands for various conditions, camo up and keep their scent down, play the wind and wait, wait, wait for the shot.
Rifle hunting is an entirely different animal. Range is less of an issue, and at distance wind is less of a concern. By firearm deer season the rut is waning or over. Hunter pressure and confusion after the first shot push the deer in every direction, giving smart rifle hunters a variety of strategic advantages.
Targeting a specific deer in gun season, however, requires adaptations to standard gun-hunting strategies. Consummate archer Steve MacBride, owner of The Archer’s Edge bow shop in Oakdale, said hunters returning to the site of a memorable encounter in search of a particular deer should ask themselves a few basic questions.
“Was he chasing something? Was he running with his tail up? Was he hiding? Did he see you? Did he smell you?” said MacBride. “Once you’ve answered those questions, you can make an assessment about whether to go looking for him.”
If the deer was behaving naturally in his own territory — chasing a doe, perhaps — he’ll almost certainly return. If he was panicked and running for his life with his white tail
high, he might live in a different ZIP code. If the deer was spooked but didn’t identify you, he’s more likely to return within a few days, said MacBride. If he knew he was seen by a potential predator, forget it.
“If he was chasing and not hiding, I’d look for scrapes and bedding areas,” said MacBride. “With not a lot of time, they have cameras now that will send the photo to your phone, but they’re expensive. Take pictures of the scrapes. If they look bigger when you come back, they’ve been used and you’ll know he’s still around.”
With a week of rifle hunting left, there’s no time for a lot of research and you probably feel pressured to find that deer before someone else does. If the rut is still on, don’t bother focusing on feeding stations.
“Bucks lose 25 percent of their body weight because of not eating and running themselves down during the rut,” said MacBride. “They’ll sit on the outskirts of food sources looking for does.”
In a hormonally addled state, bucks aren’t thinking about the wind, he said. But if your trophy has snapped out the rut, reducing your scent is suddenly a big deal. At gun-hunting distances, motion detection is more important than color. MacBride recommends oranging up for safety, and although archers usually hunt from treestands, he’d rather stand behind a tree during high-pressure firearm seasons.
Another strategy to finding a particular deer, although MacBride said he has never tried it, is simply walking around. Kick up the deer, climb into a tree and wait.
“It’s a pretty interesting tactic, especially if he smelled something but didn’t see what scared him,” said MacBride. “He’ll come back — circle around, play the wind — to see what it was. But you’d have to recognize that particular deer without him seeing you, and that’s difficult.”
Archers don’t drive. But putting on a well-organized drive that moves deer toward standers is a long-established strategy for rifle hunting. Where is the best cover — the best bedding area — relative to where you saw Mr. Big? Post yourself at a strategic choke point, topographical or otherwise, within range of your spot while the rest of your party tries to bust him out of cover.
MacBride said the most crucial element in locating a particular deer is attitude. And he doesn’t mean the deer’s.
“As an archery hunter, if I know there’s a big buck in that area, I will sit in that stand from sunup to sundown if my wife lets me for five days in a row. I’m patient.”
Archers, in general, don’t mind the wait. Or they’re constantly considering the physics of the shot, or just enjoying the scenery. When searching for a specific deer, patience is more than a virtue — it’s a necessity.
“A lot of rifle hunters, if they don’t see anything they’ll get up and go to Eat’n Park,” said MacBride. “You know, when there’s a full moon during the rut, some of the best times to be in the woods are 11 o’clock in the morning to 1 o’clock. Guys are out eating and that’s when the deer are eating. At those times, let other people move them around.”
The trick to patience, he said, is knowing when you’re just wasting time.
“If you haven’t scouted and you sit in a tree for five days and don’t see anything, that’s the definition of insanity,” said MacBride. “But when you know something’s there and you wait for it, patience is a very sane approach.”
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.