WASHINGTON, Pa. -- Long after Memorial Day, when the leaves turn and nights get colder, many Pennsylvania anglers stow the fishing rods until spring. A growing number anxiously await the first steelhead runs. Almost no one is thinking about crappies.

That’s the way Stephen Kuhajda of South Park likes it.

From the spring ice-out through December, on some 30 trips annually, Kuhajda’s crappie-fishing destination of choice is Cross Creek Lake in Washington County. This time of year, he says, he pretty much has the 244-acre impoundment to himself -- just Kuhajda, a fishing rod and 70 to 80 crappies a day.

“There’s a lot of fish here,” he said, over the steady grind of his outboard on a bright October morning. “Granted, only 12 or 15 are [the minimum] 9 inches or better, but it’s a lot of fun. You’re catching fish all day.”

Advertise with us

Located less than an hour southwest of Pittsburgh, Cross Creek Lake is the centerpiece of Cross Creek County Park, near Avella. The county installed two paved launches, courtesy docks and an accessible fishing pier. It enforces a 10-horsepower limit and requires the purchase of an Annual Use Permit ($10 for non-Washington County residents, 724-228-6867).

“Crappie catches here go up and down throughout the year,” said Mike Milvet, owner of Cross Creek Bait and Tackle, tying on a jig. “But the best fishermen can find them -- keepers up to 15 inches.”

Managed since 2000 under the state Fish and Boat Commission’s Panfish Enhancement and Big Bass programs, Cross Creek Lake is fertile and productive with a woody bottom augmented with habitat-improvement structures. In 2014, Pennsylvania’s second biggest recorded largemouth (22.2 inches) and largest sauger (27.5 inches) were taken there with crankbaits.

According to a 2007 trap net study, black crappies were the impoundment’s most abundant fish with 1,672 counted by Fish and Boat, and only eight white crappies.

Since then, the lake has changed.

Advertise with us

“This year black crappie numbers went down and the white crappies went up,” said fisheries biologist Bob Ventorini, who assisted in a trap net study conducted in April and expected to be published later this year. Fish and Boat researchers found 1/3 as many black crappies (588) as during their previous visit, while the white crappie count had risen to 346.

“That could have happened a couple of times since 2007 when we were here,” said Ventorini. “White crappie populations fluctuate; black crappies don’t do that. When white crappies go up, it’s not unusual for the black crappies to go down.”

This year, Kuhajda said he’s caught more white crappies, at a ratio of 3 to 1.

Near the dam, waters reach about 60 feet, deep enough to separate into stratified temperature levels that turn over twice a year. When the lake flips, it brings up weeds and turbidity that limit the ability of the fish to see the bait, while making vegetation hanging from the line more apparent.

Often, anglers anchor over pods of crappies. Kuhajda’s technique for nearly year-round crappie catching is to drift while fishing at a particular depth, no matter how many fish are marked elsewhere on the depth finder.

Advertise with us

“There’s a range of depths where you find crappies -- anybody with a depth finder can do that. But there’s a particular temperature where they feel comfortable enough to eat,” he said, dropping his third keeper of the morning into the live basket.

As water temperatures at various depths change, the crappies suspend at the most comfortable level. Kuhajda said the preferred temperature, and depth, often varies. Ventorini added that visibility at various depths could also be a factor.

“It’s about finding where they want to bite,” said Kuhajda. “Earlier we marked fish at 23 feet. They were there -- a lot of them -- but they didn’t want to bite at that depth. I don’t know why. Right now we’re marking them at 10 feet in 50 feet of water and we’re catching fish.”

When wind pushes the boat over a submerged creek channel and adjacent structure, Kuhajda lets it drift. When the wind shifts, he advances at the slowest trolling motor speed. The best conditions, he said, are cloudy skies and a light wind-whipped chop on the water.

Milvet grew up in Cross Creek valley. He fished in the stream before it was flooded to create the lake.

Advertise with us

“There are some old creek channels that come in and a couple submerged roads that cross,” he said, pointing toward the shoreline. “Places where that structure is at about 10 to 12 feet deep, you find crappies.”

Kuhajda’s strategy requires knowledge of crappie habits and habitat preferences, but his rig-up is simple. On a couple of ultra-light spinning rods strung with 4-pound test, he tied a 1/8-ounce jig (1/16-ounce will work, too). He likes bodies of split tail or feathers -- anything that sparkles, he said.

He pinched on a single No. 2 split shot about 18 inches up the line, tipped the jig with a 1-inch lip-hooked fathead and dropped it over the side, counting off to the critical correct depth. With the boat motoring slowly, Kuhajda counted to 12 before closing the bail. In less than a minute, he set the hook -- hard enough to bow the rod -- and reeled in another crappie.

“Basically it’s just pulling the minnie behind the boat and making the fish chase it, thinking their meal’s getting away,” he said. “Works all the time.”