The controlled archery hunt in Mt. Lebanon is beginning its third week. And that’s about all residents know about it.
Nita Fandray of Longuevue Street, manager of the Coalition for Coexistence in opposition to lethal deer control, wants to know the addresses of properties being hunted “in the interest of public safety.”
Mt. Lebanon resident Darl McMahon says she’s “100 percent in favor of the hunt” but wants incremental updates of the hunters’ progress.
“They’re saying to taxpayers, we’re spending your tax money but we’re not going to let you know how the program is going until the end,” she said. “Surely we have the right to know more than they’re telling us.”
The commonwealth of Pennsylvania disagrees, citing the constitutional rights of landowners.
“There is no requirement that landowners ever tell us where legal hunting is occurring on their property,” said Jason Raup, an attorney with the state Game Commission’s Bureau of Wildlife Protection. “It would be a violation for the state to require that information.”
Read More
Mr. Raup suggested that a government demand for information about lawful hunting on private property would be akin to demanding to know what books the landowner is reading.
Citing statistical evidence of increasing deer-vehicle collisions, Mt. Lebanon commissioners set a goal of reducing those traffic accidents by 50 percent in five years. In September they voted to pay $15,460 to nonprofit wildlife management organization White Buffalo to organize a controlled archery hunt to help reduce the municipality’s deer density. In a controlled hunt, vetted participants pay for their own equipment and licenses, and are bound by all relevant state hunting laws, Game Commission regulations and private property restrictions, but their hunting activities are organized and coordinated.
White Buffalo project manager Jody Maddock said scores of hunters were tested, interviewed and researched, but just 11 were chosen to participate — some are police officers from nearby districts. Dozens of residents volunteered their land for the hunt, but Mr. Maddock included just 18 “property clusters” that met White Buffalo specifications for safety and potential productivity.
By design, residents and municipal officials were not given the names of hunters and hunt managers, or the addresses at which hunting is taking place. The hunt began at dawn Sept. 19.
“Since this is a regular hunt complying with the regulations of the regular hunting season and not a special permitted hunt, the contractor will only provide a final report at the end of the season [in January],” said Mt. Lebanon police Chief Aaron Lauth.
Municipal planning officer Keith McGill said there’s a good reason White Buffalo did not inform commissioners about the locations of the hunt.
“We don’t want to know,” he said. “Because, again, what we’re doing is a controlled, managed, legal hunt. [White Buffalo] has not identified for us, nor do we want to know, the private properties where hunting is occurring. We have no documents bearing that information. There is no legal requirement for the private property owner to disclose where they have authorized someone to hunt on their property.”
Witold “Vic” Walczak, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, said he agrees a constitutional issue is at stake in Mt. Lebanon, and in this case the government got it right.
“As an organization that fights for the right to privacy, I’d endorse that position,” he said. “What homeowners choose to do on their property is their own business. The question is whether or not citizens can get access to the information about where the hunt is taking place. One thing about the Right to Know Act, you have the right to any contracts the government has, but if they don’t have the information, that’s another story.”
Mr. McGill said the deer hunt contract authorizes payment to White Buffalo for organizing and coordinating the hunters with no incentives, bonuses or penalties for number of deer killed. The document does not include hunters’ names or property addresses.
“People should remember that we’re required to hold this hunt as a condition of the special permit we were granted for the attempted cull earlier this year,” Mr. McGill said.
The hunters volunteer their time, and venison is donated to a Game Commission program that supplies food to shelters and food pantries. Landowners are not compensated for property use, which could include actual hunting sites, permission to hunt within state-mandated 50-yard safety zones and pre-use permission for potential deer retrieval areas.
“White Buffalo will provide a report at the end of the program,” Mr. McGill said. “It will give us a summary of the overall program that will include hunters’ diaries, number of deer killed and other information that will be used in deciding how to continue.”
When contractors are hired to do other work for the municipality, he said, incremental progress reports are rarely required.
“I don’t know if there’s a purpose in getting a weekly or daily report,” he said.
“That’s comparing apples to oranges,” said Ms. McMahon, the Mt. Lebanon resident who supports the hunt but wants updates. “He’s full of baloney.”
Ms. Fandray of Coalition for Coexistence, opposed to the hunt, said that in a 6.06-square-mile community of 33,000, the most important issue is public safety. Applying lethal means to high deer density doesn’t make sense in an area with high human density, she said.
“Don’t taxpayers have a right to know when their safety is at risk? We have ‘safe walking routes’ so kids will know a safe way to walk to school,” Ms. Fandray said. “We’re worried about our kids because of the secret nature of this thing.”
In a Sept. 11 letter to the Mt. Lebanon School District, outgoing municipal manager Steve Feller outlined safety precautions and listed the public lands where hunting will occur.
“No hunting will take place on school safe-walking routes,” he wrote. “Only police officers certified for the program will hunt on public property.”
The program hunt list includes the Mt. Lebanon conservation district, public works lands and wooded areas of the public golf course, as well as parts of Twin Hills, McNeilly and Robb Hollow parks. Parks will remain open during the hunts, and no hunting will occur on Saturdays. Hunting is prohibited in Pennsylvania on Sundays.
On Friday, neighboring Scott Township filed a civil suit against Mt. Lebanon for conducting the hunt in Twin Hills Park, purchased by Mt. Lebanon in 1994 but located within the boundaries of Scott. Scott solicitor Robert McTiernan said the suit’s central issue is Mt. Lebanon’s alleged violation of a conditional use agreement, but Scott leaders were also concerned about public safety.
Since 1995, White Buffalo has removed about 10,000 deer from urban environments. In that time, its archers have never experienced a hunting-related shooting incident, according to cofounder and president Tony DiNicola. Another nonprofit group, Whitetail Management Associates, operates controlled archery hunts to help manage deer in Allegheny County parks, regional communities and some corporate properties in southwestern Pennsylvania. President Joe McCluskey of Cheswick said in 19 years of operation, Whitetail Management has never had an archery-related accident.
Chris Bergman, a Game Commission wildlife conservation officer who patrols Allegheny County, said he met with Mt. Lebanon police and Mr. Maddock months ago to discuss the hunt and was in the municipality on the day the hunt began. No incidents have been reported.
While planning the hunt, White Buffalo discovered a tree stand hung illegally in a Mt. Lebanon park. It was reported to police. Nevertheless, Mr. Bergman said illegal hunting is rare in Mt. Lebanon, and residents might be surprised to learn that there are more independent archers legally hunting on private property than are involved in the White Buffalo hunt.
“They’re discreet and some are very successful,” he said. “Since I’ve been overseeing this district, I haven’t gotten any calls for unlawful hunting in Mt. Lebanon. Nobody’s violating safety zones, nobody’s hunting illegally and there are no accidents.”
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.