The Mt. Lebanon deer debate has gone Downtown.

On Friday, Scott Township sued the municipality of Mt. Lebanon in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas for its use of Twin Hills Park in an ongoing controlled archery hunt intended to reduce the deer population in Mt. Lebanon.

The 25-acre park at the northern tip of Mt. Lebanon was purchased from Scott in 1994. Mt. Lebanon owns and operates the park, which is located within the boundaries of Scott.

Scott solicitor Robert McTiernan said a conditional use agreement stipulates that Twin Hills Park is to be used for “recreational uses.”

Advertise with us

“They bought the property from a private owner, and it is subject to conditional use,” said Mr. McTiernan. “The only condition is it is an open space for recreational purposes. The legal issue is they’re not permitted to change that use.”

The park is subject to Scott zoning regulations, he said, and the township was not informed in advance about the hunt. Mr. McTiernan said Scott commissioners also were concerned about public safety.

“We asked [Mt. Lebanon] to postpone the hunt, and they refused,” he said. “Apart from the violation of conditional use, this is a callous and unsophisticated way to approach a neighboring community.”

Acting Mt. Lebanon manager Keith McGill and solicitor Philip Weis couldn’t be reached by phone. A municipal representative said officials had not seen the complaint and couldn’t comment on it. The spokeswoman said she’d been told Scott had been informed of the plan and Mt. Lebanon officials were willing to talk with Scott counterparts about their concerns.