Canon-McMillan had not won a playoff game since 2019 and had not advanced past the first round since it became the rarest of teams: a No. 8 seed that won a PIHL Class 3A Penguins Cup title in 2015.
But if the Big Macs are going to have the opportunity to play in their first title game in 11 years, they will have to unseat defending champion Avonworth to get there.
“I got a chance to see them for a little bit last week because I went to see the Butler-North Catholic game,” Canon-McMillan coach Chuck Fink said. “They’re a good team. They’re going to be a good challenge for us. But like anything else, you’re going to have to put it out there and see what happens.”
Here is a breakdown of the Antelopes and Canon-McMillan as well as the rest of this week’s PIHL Penguins Cup semifinal games with predictions. All games will be played at Robert Morris University Island Sports Center:
Class 3A
The game: No. 1 Seneca Valley (18-0-1-0-2) vs. No. 4 Pine-Richland (9-5-2-3-2) at 7:15 p.m. Monday
The scoop: These two teams have already met twice this year and, in fact, opened the season against each other on Oct. 2. That was when the Raiders staked their claim as the team to beat in the classification with an 8-1 running-clock beatdown behind a hat trick from Cooper Hoehn. But the defending champions didn’t have as easy of a time with the Rams the second time around as Cullen Campbell scored the first two goals and Carson Verszyla added another as Pine-Richland opened up a 3-1 lead after the first period. Seneca Valley rallied, however, tied the game and pulled out a 4-3 win in a shootout. But that was on Dec. 15 and it’s been nearly three months since these two teams saw each other. Verszyla (12 goals, 21 assists, 33 points) was the leading scorer in the classification during the regular season, and Campbell (20-6-26) was in the top 10 overall and led in goals, but Seneca Valley has only allowed an average of 1.00 goals per game including the playoffs thanks to senior goaltender Christopher Nichols and the Raiders defense.
Read More
Predicted winner: Seneca Valley
The game: No. 2 Peters Township (15-4-0-1-1) vs. No. 3 Thomas Jefferson (11-7-0-0-2) at 9:15 p.m. Monday
The scoop: These two teams are as familiar as any in the tournament. Not because they played more than twice, but because of when they played each other. Peters Township took the first game between the two, 3-0, on Oct. 21 when Jordan Cox stopped 22 shots for the shutout. But against South Fayette in the postseason opener, it was Anthony Herman who got the nod between the pipes and he turned aside 17 of 19 in a 5-2 win. He was also the goaltender of record when the Indians and Jaguars last met on Jan. 29, a game Thomas Jefferson won, 2-1, in a shootout as Owen Michael got the tying goal at 14:27 of the third period. Ben Baldacci has improved in the net since he gave up three in that first game between the two and Lucas Blose, who had two against Central Catholic in the first round, is getting hot at the right time.
Predicted winner: Thomas Jefferson
Class 2A
The game: No. 1 Hempfield (17-3-0-0-1) vs. No. 4 Bethel Park (14-5-1-0-1) at 7 p.m. Tuesday
The scoop: Neither of these teams were overpowering in their first-round wins. Hempfield let defending champion Cathedral Prep hang around for a long time before Max Gromoll gave the Spartans a two-goal cushion at 3:33 of the third period in their 4-2 win, while Lukas Crisson scored at 11:19 of overtime for the Black Hawks to pull out the victory against Bishop McCort. Hempfield took both games during the regular season, in a 3-2 shootout victory on Oct. 28 and a much more decisive 8-0 running-clock romp on Jan. 22. The Spartans offense has been clicking on all cylinders and has put up 62 goals in its last seven games, an average of 8.88 per game. Nino DiPietro, who had a hat trick the last time they played, has been on a tear for Hempfield and was the Class 2A PIHL Player of the Month in January. Spartans teammate Colby Herron was the February selection.
Predicted winner: Hempfield
The game: No. 3 Penn-Trafford (15-5-0-0-1) vs. No. 7 Latrobe (8-9-1-1-2) at 9 p.m. Tuesday
The scoop: There was not a bigger upset in the first round of the Penguins Cup playoffs than Latrobe bouncing No. 2 Armstrong behind a goal and an assist from both Colton Goodlin and Preston Miller. Goaltender Reese Myers stopped 33 shots against one of the more potent offenses in the classification to pick up the win. And this one may end up being one of the best games of the tournament. Penn-Trafford won both regular season matchups in very different one-goal affairs, 2-1 on Oct. 30 and 7-6 in a shootout on Feb. 16. Both times the Warriors had to come from behind, with two third-period goals from Sean Goodman and Brody Parsons in the first and three in the third from Jordan Tucek, Brock Bieneman and Goodman to force the shootout in the second. Maybe the Wildcats are just due.
Predicted winner: Latrobe
Class 1A
The game: B No. 1 Canon-McMillan (19-1-1-0-0) vs. G No. 2 Avonworth (17-3-1-1-0) at 7 p.m. Wednesday
The scoop: Sometimes an unstoppable force does meet an immovable object, which will be the case when these two teams clash. The unstoppable force is the Antelopes offense, which has been putting rubber in the net at an incredible pace. Avonworth led the PIHL with 161 goals in the regular season (8.05 gpg) but have incredibly increased their pace to 9.0 with a pair of nine-goal outings in the preliminary round against Beaver and the quarterfinals against a Moon team that had given up just 44 in the regular season. Now will be the test for the defending champion Antelopes as Canon-McMillan has surrendered just 24 goals in 21 games, including its 4-1 win against Butler in the opening round. Big Macs goaltender Aiden Bobbs has played out of his mind at times during the season and will have to be on a swivel to keep up with Avonworth. Of note, the last three games Canon-McMillan has won in the Penguins Cup playoffs, the opener this year, its Class 3A play-in game in 2019 and the Penguins Cup final in 2015, were all against Butler. This isn’t Butler.
Predicted winner: Avonworth
The game: G No. 1 Mars (16-1-2-2) vs. B No. 2 Quaker Valley (19-1-0-0-1) at 9 p.m. Wednesday
The scoop: There were years not so long ago when this matchup would have been the championship game, but both are now looking to end long title droughts. The Planets have not won the Penguins Cup since 2015, while the Quakers last championship was in 2014. Mars, in fact, defeated then three-time reigning champion Quaker Valley, 4-1, in the 2015 final. Because they were in different divisions, the two teams did not face each other during the regular season. The Quakers were pushed to the brink in their quarterfinal by Chartiers Valley before Matthias Lezama, the leading scorer in the regular season in the classification, scored the game-winner at 9:53 of overtime. Mars had an easier time with Plum in is quarterfinal, but will need a huge game from goaltender Carter Gallagher against an offense that has scored 135 goals (6.43 gpg) this season.
Predicted winner: Quaker Valley
Last week: 8-4, .667
Postseason: 13-5, .722






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.