With the preliminary rounds in Class 1A concluded and the final regular season games in the books for the other two classifications, it’s time for the PIHL Penguins Cup quarterfinals to begin.
All three reigning champions from 2025, Avonworth in Class 1A, Cathedral Prep in Class 2A and Class 3A Seneca Valley, all qualified for the postseason and will be on the ice to defend their titles.
Here is a breakdown of the quarterfinal games with predictions:
Class 3A
Champion prediction: Seneca Valley
Quarterfinals
The game: No. 8 Upper St. Clair (5-9-3-1-2) at No. 1 Seneca Valley (17-0-1-0-2), 7 p.m. Monday at Baierl Ice Complex
Read More
The scoop: There is no doubt Seneca Valley is a prohibitive favorite to win not only this game but the Penguins Cup. The Raiders are the reigning state champions and have done nothing to dissuade anyone from believing they can repeat. The two teams have not played one another since Seneca Valley posted a 3-0 victory on Dec. 22, but the Raiders also won the first meeting, 4-2, on Oct. 23. Goaltender Christopher Nichols stopped 37 of the 39 shots he faced in the two games. Seneca Valley’s only loss this season came in a shootout against North Allegheny. Seneca Valley has allowed only 17 goals this season and has a plus-75 goal differential.
Predicted winner: Seneca Valley
The game: No. 7 South Fayette (7-10-1-0-2) at No. 2 Peters Township (14-4-0-1-1), 9 p.m. Tuesday at Printscape Arena
The scoop: Peters Township may need the home ice advantage considering that South Fayette took a 4-3 decision when the two met in the Indians’ regular season finale on Feb. 19. To be fair, Peters Township didn’t really have much to play for as it was locked in as the No. 2 seed for weeks. Peters Township defeated the Lions, 5-3, in their first meeting on Nov. 11. The Lions’ Nathaniel Keller has been one of the top scorers in the classification this year, but the Indians can counter with Chay Lamagna and Jacob Hlawati, who each had 11 goals and 25 points. Don’t sleep on Peters Township senior forward Cole Neupaver, who is back in hockey shape after football season and has seven goals and 10 points in 11 games.
Predicted winner: Peters Township
The game: No. 6 Central Catholic (10-7-1-1-1) at No. 3 Thomas Jefferson (11-7-0-0-2), 7 p.m. Monday at Ice Castle
The scoop: Thomas Jefferson has been as hot as any team in the classification down the stretch, winning six of its final seven with the only loss coming against Seneca Valley, but this matchup becomes more intriguing considering the Jaguars lost both regular season meetings against the Vikings. Even so, the two have not seen each other since Chris Sargo scored a pair of goals and Mason Barbieri made 20 saves in a 4-3 Central Catholic victory on Dec 1. The Vikings are stumbling into the postseason a bit, with losses in four of their final six games and the only two victories in that time were a pair of one-goal affairs with Mt. Lebanon and South Fayette.
Predicted winner: Thomas Jefferson.
The game: No. 5 North Allegheny (9-6-1-2-2) at No. 4 Pine-Richland (8-5-2-3-2), 8:30 p.m. Tuesday at Baierl Ice Center
The scoop: These teams tied each other in the standings with 34 points apiece and the two teams split their season series, but because North Allegheny won its game in overtime the Tigers lost out to the Rams on the first tiebreaker, percentage of points earned in the two games between the teams. Pine-Richland won four of its past five down the stretch with the only loss being in overtime against Fox Chapel. William Hanner, who was in goal for the Rams regulation win, has seemingly taken over as the team’s No. 1 netminder down the stretch. He is 7-3-1 with a 2.99 GAA and a .890 save percentage. Chris Costa was in the net for both games against Pine-Richland and is 10-4-3 with a 2.04 GAA and a .917 save percentage.
Predicted winner: North Allegheny
Class 2A
Quarterfinals
Champion Prediction: Armstrong
The game: No. 8 Cathedral Prep (4-13-1-2-0) at No. 1 Hempfield (16-3-0-0-1), 7:15 p.m. Monday at Kirk Nevin Arena
The scoop: Hempfield has never won a Penguins Cup title but can make a statement in the opening round by knocking out the reigning champion. The Spartans led the classification in scoring with 131 goals, a goal-differential of plus-86 and were a plus-14 in two games against the Ramblers during the regular season. Hempfield won the two games against Cathedral Prep by a combined 16-2 as Guerin Gardner and Nino DiPietro each had seven points in the two games. Cathedral Prep only mustered 31 shots combined in the two games against the Spartans.
Predicted winner: Hempfield
The game: No. 5 Bishop McCort (8-9-1-1-1) at No. 4 Bethel Park (13-5-1-0-1), 9 p.m. Tuesday at Bethel Park YMCA
The scoop: Bethel Park won both regular season meetings, including a 3-2 victory at the Cambria County War Memorial, which is a notoriously tough place for visitors. The Black Hawks will have to keep an eye on Zakhar Bryndin, who scored three of the Crimson Crushers four goals – and assisted on the other – during the regular season. Kai Decker led Bethel Park with four goals in the two games, including a hat trick in their first meeting on Nov. 4.
Predicted winner: Bethel Park
The game: No. 7 Latrobe (7-10-1-1-1) at Armstrong (16-3-1-0-0), 7:30 p.m. Tuesday at Belmont Complex
The scoop: All Armstrong needed to be the No. 1 seed in the tournament was to get a point off Wheeling Park in its season finale. Instead, the River Hawks blew a 4-1 third-period lead, took a 5-4 regulation loss on the chin and had to settle for the No. 2 spot. Kohlt Eshbaugh gave up five goals on only 14 shots against the Patriots and will have to be much better if they are to beat an always scrappy Latrobe squad. The Wildcats lost both regular season meetings to Armstrong by a combined score of 13-6, including a 5-2 loss at The Belmont on Jan. 22.
Predicted winner: Armstrong.
The game: No. 6 Shaler (8-9-2-0-1) at Penn-Trafford (15-5-0-0-0) 7 p.m. Monday at Palmer Imaging Center
The scoop: These two teams have not seen each other in nearly three months. The two split their regular season meetings with the Titans winning the first meeting, 4-2, on Oct. 9 and the Warriors taking a 2-1 decision on Dec. 15. Penn-Trafford fell off a cliff down the stretch, losing three of its last four and barely squeaking out a 7-6 win against Latrobe in that time. Shaler has not been much better with losses in two of its last three, including a season-ending defeat against 11th place Baldwin.
Predicted winner: Shaler
Class 1A
Champion Prediction: Quaker Valley
Quarterfinals
The game: G No. 4 Butler (15-4-1-1-0) vs. B No. 1 Canon-McMillan (18-1-1-0-0), 7 p.m. Tuesday at Printscape Arena
The scoop: The Golden Tornado already had a huge taste of postseason drama when Jase Renwick scored the overtime game-winner against North Catholic in the preliminary round. Because the teams were in different divisions they did not play in the regular season, but they do have the Trojans as a common opponent. Canon-McMillan won in regulation and in a shootout against North Catholic. The Big Macs have won two straight since losing their only game against Quaker Valley. Canon-McMillan had 18 players score goals this season, led by Brayden Edgar with 16 and Michael Traynor with 15. Butler can go toe-to-toe scoring with anyone after putting 109 in the back of the net during the regular season, but the Golden Tornado will have a tough time getting rubber behind Big Macs goaltender Aiden Bobbs, who is 16-1 with a 1.18 goals-against average and a .946 save percentage.
Predicted winner: Canon-McMillan
The game: G No. 2 Avonworth (16-3-1-1-0) vs. B No. 3 Moon (15-3-1-1-1), 7:15 p.m. Monday at Robert Morris University Island Sports Center
The scoop: This might be the most intriguing matchup of the Class 1A quarterfinals. The Antelopes are one step closer to defending their title after their six-goal blowout of Beaver in the opening round. Avonworth led the PIHL with 162 goals in the regular season and now has 171. Cooper Powell (25 goals, 27 assists, 52 points) is the team’s leading scorer followed by Linus Jesionowski (27-23-50), but the team can come from all angles as evidenced by the seven goal scorers the team had in the opener against the Bobcats. Moon had a slightly tougher time in the first round against North Hills but got two goals from Jordan Rieke and an outstanding performance in the net as Tyler Zeigler stopped 22 of 23 goals.
Predicted winner: Moon
The game: G No. 5 Plum (12-6-3-0-0) vs. G No. 1 Mars (15-1-2-2), 9 p.m. Monday at Baierl Ice Complex
The scoop: Oddly enough, this will be the only matchup between division foes in the quarterfinals. The two teams split their two regular season meetings, with Mars taking the first, 4-1, at home and the Mustangs with the rematch in overtime at Pittsburgh Ice Arena. Because of typical PIHL scheduling quirks, these two teams haven’t played since Dec. 11. After that loss, Mars went 7-1 down the stretch, including a pair of one-goal victories against Chartiers Valley. Xavier Bossola had a hat trick for Mars in the overtime loss and Colby Bartos led the Mustangs with three goals in the two games.
Predicted winner: Mars
The game: B No. 2 Quaker Valley (19-1-0-0-1) vs. G No. 3 Chartiers Valley (15-2-1-3-0), 9 p.m. Thursday at Baierl Ice Complex
The scoop: Quaker Valley was a point away from being the No. 1 seed in the tournament. The Quakers have not won a Penguins Cup title since 2014, but this might be the year Kevin Quinn and his program ends the longest title drought in program history. Neither team allowed a goal in their preliminary round victories. Matthias Lezama led the classification in scoring during the regular season and had a goal and three assists in the Quakers running-clock win against Greensburg Salem. Jace Vasbinder had a natural hat trick against the Golden Lions and now has 29 on the season. Chartiers Valley has lost four of its last eight overall and it will be interesting to see how freshman goaltender Ben Waldron holds up to the Quakers offense after a 15-save shutout against Hampton in the opening round.
Predicted winner: Quaker Valley
Last week: 5-1
Postseason: 5-1
Final Rankings (Records through Feb. 28)
Class 3A
1. Seneca Valley 17-0-1-0-2
2. Peters Township 14-4-0-1-1
3, Thomas Jefferson 11-7-0-0-2
4. North Allegheny 9-6-1-2-2
5. Central Catholic 10-7-1-1-1
Class 2A
2. Hempfield 16-3-0-0-1
1. Armstrong 16-3-1-0-0
3. Penn-Trafford 15-5-0-0
4. Bethel Park 12-3-1-0-1
5. Shaler 8-9-2-0-1
Class 1A
1. Canon-McMillan 18-1-1-0-0
2. Quaker Valley 19-1-0-0-1
3. Mars 15-1-2-2-0
4. Moon 15-3-1-1-1
5. Avonworth 16-3-1-1-0






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.