When Robert Phelps signed his letter of intent to play baseball at Ole Miss last week, it brought to an end the recruitment of a player who doesn’t fit the profile of a major-college recruit.

Phelps is a senior shortstop at Allderdice who has played only four games of high school baseball and has just two varsity hits, both coming last season — a single against Butler and a two-run home run against PIAA Class 6A finalist North Allegheny.

In addition, Phelps hasn’t been a regular on the showcase circuit, which is often a big deal for high-end talents like himself. Most of his experience, at least domestically, has come playing for Pittsburgh Hardball Academy and the Allegheny Pirates, both local travel teams.

But there Phelps was last Wednesday, sitting in a classroom at Allderdice signing his NLI with Ole Miss, an SEC power that last season advanced to the NCAA Super Regionals. Phelps first visited Ole Miss in March and took his official visit there this past weekend. His trip included watching the Ole Miss football team beat Texas A&M.

Advertise with us

“When I saw it in person, I just loved the atmosphere and stadium,” Phelps said. “They play good competition and are in such a good conference. And the campus is beautiful.”

Phelps’ story is interesting. When asked if he has “athletic genes,” he replied, “I really don’t know.” That’s because Phelps was adopted when he was five-weeks old. He was taken in by the Phelps family, Robert and Melody. The family resides in Highland Park.

When Phelps was in seventh grade, the family moved to the Dominican Republic after the elder Robert took a job at a school there. The family lived in Jarabacoa, and the younger Robert attended a bilingual school there for three years. He said the transition was difficult, but that it had its perks, particularly when it came to baseball.

“It was great,” he said. “First of all, the weather was amazing. It made it so we could play all year round. We practiced every day. The fields were not in the greatest conditions, but we were able to play at a high level all of the time and even through the winter.”

The family then moved back to this area in early 2020. Phelps was a sophomore at Allderdice that year, but there was no high school season due to the pandemic. He verbally committed to Kent State that year before decommitting in February of this year. Ole Miss began recruiting him, and he made a verbal commitment there soon after arriving home from his first visit there. He said he chose Ole Miss over Oregon State. It was a tough decision considering Oregon State is his father’s alma mater.

Advertise with us

Phelps was set to make an impact for Allderdice in 2021, but played only a handful of games. His season ended abruptly due to an “altercation,” one which he chose not to elaborate on. He said he has not decided if he will play for the Dragons his senior season.

Despite his minimal exposure in the states, Phelps is highly regarded. Baseball America ranked the Ole Miss recruiting class No. 9 in the country, and mentioned Phelps as being one of the key pieces. Baseball America’s Teddy Cahill said of Phelps, “Shortstop Robert Phelps is a bit under the radar because he didn’t play in all of the big events, but he could be an important pickup player for the Rebels. His athleticism and glove play well at shortstop, and he figures to take a step forward offensively as he physically matures.”

Like many young baseball players, Phelps has a goal of playing in the big leagues. He could get there one day, albeit using a path less traveled.

“My dream since I was a kid has been to play in the big leagues,” he said. “It’s something I really want to do. Hopefully, God willing, I’ll be able to do it.”

LaSala says ‘Hail to Pitt’

Advertise with us

A Beaver County teen who has grown up in a “Pitt house” has decided to continue his education and baseball career at the Oakland school.

Hopewell senior shortstop Anthony LaSala signed with Pitt last week. He had given a verbal commitment to the Panthers in September. LaSala said he chose the Panthers over a list of schools that included California (Pa.), Mercyhurst and Grove City.

“It’s just a great school and the baseball team is on the rise. They’re building a great program,” LaSala said.

LaSala knows Pitt extremely well. His dad, Chris, is in his 25th season as a member of Pitt’s football staff. He’s currently the associate athletic director for football administration.

“It was always a goal of mine [to play for Pitt], and then they offered me,” Anthony said.

Advertise with us

Back in June, LaSala played a key role in Hopewell winning its first WPIAL title since 2010. The Vikings defeated South Park, 6-5, in the Class 3A final. LaSala, an all-section pick, made a couple of dazzling defense plays in the game, two of which likely saved runs from scoring. Teammate Roman Gill said afterward, “Those were major league plays.”

For the season, LaSala batted .343, drove in 17 runs and boasted an on-base percentage of .473. He was also one of the team’s top pitchers, going 6-2 with a 2.62 ERA.

Nicholls to Johns Hopkins

One of the WPIAL’s top all-around athletes will attend Johns Hopkins. Winchester Thurston senior Lance Nicholls has decided to run cross country and track for the Blue Jays. Nicholls is an excellent student who boasts a 3.98 GPA. He also considered Washington University and Carnegie Mellon. Some Ivy League schools showed interest, as well.

“I knew what I really wanted in a school, and the first thing I was looking for was great academics,” Nicholls said. “I loved the feel of the campus. You have access to the city [Baltimore], but at the same time it’s a suburban campus. It felt like a perfect fit as a student and as an athlete.”

Advertise with us

Nicholls, who lives in Shadyside about a block away from Winchester Thurston, has accomplished a lot in his high school athletic career, which has seen him become a standout in not only cross country and track, but also soccer and basketball.

A midfielder in soccer, Nicholls has helped Winchester Thurston to a 22-0-1 record. The Bears will play for a PIAA title Saturday when they take on Faith Christian in the Class 1A final in Hershey. In cross country this fall, Nicholls placed second at the WPIAL Class 1A championships and sixth at the PIAA Class 1A championships. As a junior, he averaged 18.1 points per game for the Winchester Thurston basketball team. And in track, he was third in the 3,200-meter run and fifth in the 1,600 at the WPIAL Class 2A track and field championships.

Baseball commitments

Avonworth’s Neo Miller (Pitt Greensburg); Franklin Regional’s Louie Kegerreis (Delaware); Montour’s Dylan Mathiesen (California); Moon’s Marco Vesce (Marietta); North Allegheny’s Erik Sundgren (Denison); Norwin’s Jake Awenowicz (Gannon); Pine-Richland’s Tyler Armstrong (East Georgia State); Shaler’s Bryan Rincon (San Jacinto).

Football commitment

Advertise with us

Penn-Trafford’s Ian Demeri (Grove City).

Softball commitment

Central Valley’s Macy Littler (Youngstown State).

Wrestling commitment

Latrobe’s Vinny Kilkeary (Ohio State).

Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BREAL412.