After lighting up the American Hockey League to start the season, Avery Hayes got a call-up to Pittsburgh last month. He was one of the Penguins’ best players Oct. 24.

But he was sent back to Wilkes-Barre after that one game.

“It was a weird feeling because I was really proud of how I played,” Hayes said over the phone Friday.

He knew Penguins forwards were returning from injury, so it wasn’t unexpected. Hayes went down and kept scoring for the Baby Penguins.

Advertise with us

Now, he’s headed back to the NHL and hopes to provide a spark the Penguins sorely need.

They recalled Hayes on Friday, as Nick Robertson is headed to injured reserve with a lower-body injury and Evgeni Malkin is out for this weekend’s road back-to-back with an upper-body injury.

“If I get the chance in a game, I know I’m ready for it, and I’m just gonna try to bring some energy,” Hayes said. “I feel like the team can use that.”

They certainly can.

Hayes leads Wilkes-Barre/Scranton in goals (9), points (16) and rating (plus-9) in 15 AHL games this season.

Advertise with us

When asked Wednesday about why Hayes hasn’t been given more games in the NHL, Penguins president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas acknowledged the 24-year-old winger’s production. But he said they’re looking for Hayes to show a more complete game.

“It was the message to him in camp. It was the message to him when he went back down after he had the one-game opportunity. We want him to dominate that level in more than just the production. So his puck battles, penalty killing, defensive play,” Dubas said.

Hayes was cut from the NHL roster earlier than expected in September. The Penguins wanted him to work on his playmaking. He has since produced assists at the highest rate of his career.

After his strong game against the Nashville Predators on Oct. 24 and his subsequent demotion to the AHL, the team told Hayes to focus on his play away from the puck, including penalty killing and disrupting passing lanes.

Hayes has scored three shorthanded goals this season.

Advertise with us

“He’s been given a very specific track from us in terms of a plan, in terms of what we want to see,” Dubas said.

Dubas referenced Wilkes-Barre/Scranton’s overtime loss to Hershey last week.

“First part of the game, he wasn’t noticeable. Then, he gets active, he gets physical, he gets involved, and he can really take over the game that way,” Dubas said. “But it’s just doing that on a consistent basis to earn his way up.”

As Dubas noted, there’s no one who wants Hayes to have success more than he does. Hayes went undrafted, but Dubas brought him to the Toronto Maple Leafs’ development camp.

Once in Pittsburgh, Dubas signed Hayes to an AHL contract. They converted it to an NHL deal in March 2025.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been together for a while, which is pretty cool,” Hayes said.

Hayes made an unforgettable NHL debut in February, scoring twice in Buffalo. Hayes tallied five goals in 16 NHL games overall last season. That taste of the highest level could make it hard for Hayes to get up for a Friday night game in Utica. He said the opposite is true.

“If anything, it makes you hungrier to get back,” Hayes said. “Because when you get that feeling of being up with Pitt, and that’s your dream and that’s your goal … you’re willing to do whatever it takes to get back there.”

It’s not guaranteed that Hayes will play in this latest call-up. He didn’t make it to Pittsburgh in time for practice Friday, and Andrei Kuzmenko slotted back in.

But if Hayes does get some runway to prove himself, the small but feisty winger knows one way he can stand out.

“I just feel like it brings energy when you’re on the bench and you see guys being physical and hitting and finishing checks and mixing it up after the play or whatever it is,” Hayes said. “... Whether you’re playing five minutes or 15, that’s something that you can always control.”