HERSHEY, Pa. — Saturday was supposed to be the coronation of Thayne Lawrence’s remarkable high school career at Frazier.

Instead, Lawrence’s final high school match turned out to be one of the most controversial championship bouts in PIAA history.

In what was surely the most anticipated matchup of the 2020 PIAA Class 2A individual wrestling championships, Lawrence (24-1) dropped an 11-8 decision to Notre Dame-Green Pond’s Andrew Cerniglia (46-1) in the 160-pound final. Cerniglia was a returning PIAA champion at 145 pounds and ranked No. 4 in the country at 160 pounds by Intermat Wrestling, while Lawrence was a two-time defending champion and ranked No. 3 nationally.

“It’s all kind of a blur looking back at it,” Lawrence said. “As the match went on, I felt like I kept my composure and kept wrestling.

Advertise with us

“I had some bad calls, but that’s the life of wrestling.”

Cerniglia took the action to Lawrence right from the opening whistle, scoring a takedown just 16 seconds into the bout before adding another takedown 28 seconds later after a Lawrence escape. Cerniglia tacked on two near-fall points with a cradle after the second takedown, then scored a third takedown with 23 seconds left in the period to open up an 8-2 lead — but that’s when Lawrence got rolling.

First, Lawrence reversed Cerniglia with nine seconds left in the period to cut the deficit to 8-4. He added a takedown late in the second period to make it 9-6 before the official whistled Lawrence for an illegal hold and awarded a penalty point to Cerniglia. Lawrence appeared to take Cerniglia down again just before time expired, but the official waved it off and he trailed, 11-6, entering the third.

Lawrence started the final period on bottom and reversed Cerniglia just nine seconds in to make it 11-8. That’s when the controversy really began.

Knowing he needed at least a three-point near-fall to tie the match, Lawrence locked up a near-side cradle — one of the most potent pinning combinations in the sport. Cerniglia defended it well as Lawrence fought to turn him over to his back. After about 20 seconds, the official ruled a stalemate and ordered a restart back in the center of the mat — something that should never happen while a pinning combination is being applied.

Advertise with us

With only 30 seconds left to tie the match, Lawrence did his best to muscle Cerniglia onto his back, but to no avail. Cerniglia held on to win, 11-8, as the crowd loudly voiced its displeasure. Lawrence received a standing ovation from fans as he jogged off the mat.

“It’s something I’ll never forget, going back and looking at this,” Lawrence said of the crowd reaction. “It was one thing to be proud of, listening to all those people out there cheering for me.”

Although Lawrence’s career didn’t end the way he had hoped, Ellwood City senior Austin Walley couldn’t have scripted a better finale to his high school career.

After a fourth-place finish in the 2019 PIAA tournament, Walley (45-1) used a late reversal to break open a 4-4 tie in the third period on his way to a 6-5 victory against Montoursville’s Dylan Bennett in the 182-pound championship.

“It feels great,” Walley said. “Standing on top of the podium — that’s what I’ll remember most. Finally getting it done, walking up those steps — I almost tripped like three times. I didn’t even know where I was going.”

Advertise with us

Walley was the only one of the six WPIAL wrestlers competing Saturday in championships to take home a gold medal.

At 113 pounds, South Park junior Joey Fischer (44-3) dropped a 4-2 decision in overtime to Reynolds’ Gary Steen in a rematch of last year’s third-place bout, which Steen also won in overtime. Elizabeth Forward senior Ryan Michaels (45-3) then lost a 7-4 decision in the 120-pound final to returning state champion Sheldon Seymour of Troy.

In the 132-pound final, Burrell junior Ian Oswalt (45-7) lost a 5-1 decision in overtime against Glendale’s Brock McMillen, another returning state champion. Fellow Buccaneers junior A.J. Corrado (45-8) then lost a 3-2 decision to St. Joseph’s Catholic Academy’s Caleb Dowling in the 152-pound finals.

“I was really excited coming into the match, but I wasn’t satisfied. I’m still not satisfied,” Corrado said. “But the good thing is I still have a year to work on everything I need to work on and get back into it next year.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein