Most local high school baseball historians likely remember former Steel Valley pitcher Justin Fry as one of the best hurlers in the WPIAL during the 1990s.

Soon, Fry has a new title to go by — Ohio State Athletics Hall of Famer.

Fry was announced as part of his alma mater’s Hall of Fame Class of 2019 on June 6, and will be inducted alongside former men’s basketball coach Thad Matta, former star linebacker A.J. Hawk and others during a ceremony Sept. 6 in the Ohio Union. The 10-member class will then be introduced on the field at halftime of Ohio State’s football game against Cincinnati Sept. 7.

“It’s very humbling,” said Fry, a 1994 Steel Valley graduate. “It caught me off guard, to be honest with you … It’s a great accomplishment, a great honor, but that happens because of playing on great teams.”

Advertise with us

Although Fry played on some decent teams at Steel Valley in the early 1990s, winning a couple of playoff games here and there, the Ironmen never made a run deep in the postseason. Once he got to Columbus and put on a Buckeyes uniform, though, he experienced plenty of team and individual success.

Fry graduated from Ohio State in 1999 as the program’s all-time leader in wins (36), strikeouts (382) and innings pitched (419 ⅔), and he still holds those records to this day. He helped lead the Buckeyes to a pair of Big Ten championships and was named a first-team All-American in 1999, as well as the Big Ten Pitcher of the Year as both a sophomore and senior.

Despite all the individual accolades and team accomplishments, though, the one thing Fry didn’t get a chance to experience is what he remembers most about his college career.

As a senior, Fry led Ohio State to the Super Regional round of the NCAA postseason, where the Buckeyes matched up against Cal-State Fullerton in a best-of-three series for a spot in the College World Series. Fry pitched in Game 1 and earned the win, but could do nothing but sit in the dugout and watch as the Titans won the next two games, ending both the Buckeyes’ season and Fry’s college career just one game short of playing on college baseball’s biggest stage.

“We competed hard, but they came out on top,” Fry said. “I always think about it. It’s one of the things I definitely think about, but hey, it wasn’t meant to be.”

Advertise with us

Fry was drafted by the Philadelphia Phillies in the 26th round of the 1999 MLB draft and played four seasons in the minor leagues before injuries cut his career short. In the end, Fry’s competitive nature that brought him to that point wound up contributing to his demise.

“I was actually a closer in the minor leagues, and I actually tried to throw through an injury, and that’s kind of what led to my downfall,” Fry said. “I never had surgery or anything, but I was lifting and I injured my [pectoral] muscle, and just kind of being stupid, I tried to throw through it and developed some elbow issues and I could never recover from that.

“I look back and I kind of regret doing that, but I’m just a competitor, man. I didn’t want someone to take my position. But hindsight is 20/20.”

Fry admitted he would have been more cautious if he knew then what he knows now about the dangers of rushing back from injuries. Still, he doesn’t spend much time dwelling on what could have been. While balancing his role as a project manager with DQE Communications with raising three children ages 14, 12 and 10, the 42-year-old Munhall native doesn’t have much time to think about the past.

He does still have time to attend his oldest daughter Elizabeth’s softball games and his son Justin’s baseball games — just don’t expect to see him barking orders from the dugout.

Advertise with us

“I like sitting back and kind of watching things happen,” Fry said. “I don’t want to be the guy that always coaches [Justin], and then he gets to high school or whatever level and the only voice he’s ever heard is from his dad. I think it’s good to have other people involved, other coaches, other voices. Nobody knows it all.”

Now, 20 years after donning an Ohio State uniform for the final time, Fry is set to receive an honor reserved for only the best athletes in the history of a school filled with them. And maybe, just maybe, Fry will accept an individual award without deferring all the credit to his team for once.

Then again, probably not.

“For me, it’s probably [going to be most exciting] just seeing some of my teammates that are going to be there,” Fry said. “They were a huge part of that, this honor. Without them fielding and hitting, I’m nothing.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.