Canon-McMillan had a magical run through the PIHL Class AAA playoffs to win the second Penguins Cup in school history.

Playing in the state finals, though, turned hopes of a Pennsylvania Cup championship into a disappointing ride home from Penn State’s Pegula Ice Arena after the Big Macs allowed four goals to Nicholas Bohatiuk and another two to Kyle Peters in a 6-4 loss to Holy Ghost Prep.

Canon-McMillan played a game that was different from anything the team had seen in its run through the western half of the state. Holy Ghost Prep played an extremely physical game and hit the Big Macs at every turn, frustrating them into several critical penalties, some of which were of a retaliatory nature, which forced them to take a defensive posture for two periods.

They were called for 10 penalties and surrendered a power-play goal, a 4-on-4 goal and another short-handed in a three-goal Firebirds second-period outburst that gave Holy Ghost Prep a 4-1 lead heading into the third period. In addition, Canon-McMillan lost its cool at the end of the game as two fights broke out at the final horn.

Advertise with us

“I thought the refereeing was fine. They were calling what was there,” Canon-McMillan coach Terry Virtue said. “They were all penalties. There were no complaints about the penalties, They were calling the penalties right.”

Canon-McMillan also had a power-play goal waved off in the first period that would have given the Big Macs a two-goal lead and could have conceivably altered the outcome. But after a brief explanation, the team accepted the referee’s decision without complaint.

“It was directed in by a skate,” Virtue said. “It was moved. We saw it right from our bench and he directed it in. I know they say you’re allowed to turn your skate, but you can’t have a kicking motion toward the net and that’s what it was.”

To its credit, Canon-McMillan never quit. The team had been down in the playoffs before, in its first game against Seneca Valley before it scored the tying goal and came up with another in overtime, but a three-goal comeback against a team of this caliber was a little too much to ask.

Canon-McMillan, though, twice got it to within one. Coleman Slain and Austin Tonkovich, both of whom took bad penalties in the second period, redeemed themselves with goals in the first 11:40 to cut the deficit to 4-3. Even after a Bohatiuk goal at 13:06, the Big Macs came up with another strike with goaltender Conor Hartnett out of the net as Zachary Mansmann converted on a 6-on-4 power play with 1:37 left in regulation.

Advertise with us

At the end of the day, though, Canon-McMillan will have to be satisfied with being the Penguins Cup champion. It wasn’t the outcome it wanted, but it had to be pleased it didn’t go down without a fight.

“It [stinks], and I said it to these guys, that the best team didn’t win,” Virtue said. “We just didn’t show up the first two periods and it was more of our game in the third period where we took the game to them and played harder. We just didn’t in the first two periods.”