It was not easy for Mars players to talk about their 5-2 loss to Bayard Rustin in the Pennsylvania Cup Class A hockey championship.

Not after having a one-goal lead with just over 10 minutes to play and a plus-26 advantage in shots in the game.

“They did a good job of blocking shots or we could have had even more than what we had,” Mars coach Steve Myers said. “I thought they blocked some key opportunities that we had, some shots from the high slot that our ‘D’ were walking in on…we felt this was a very good matchup for us and we thought we carried the play and just couldn’t win.”

Leading, 2-1, after senior forward Kyle Thomas deflected a right-point shot from senior defenseman Ian Houk-Graves that gave Mars its only lead at 2:31 of the third period, Bayard Rustin scored four unanswered goals, including a crazy carom off the boards that turned into an empty net goal for Michael Grande with 0.5 seconds remaining, to win its second consecutive title and third in seven years.

Advertise with us

Before the playoffs opened, though, Mars would have been hard-pressed to find people outside its inner sanctum that would have seen the team as a viable contender for a Penguins Cup title much less a viable state championship contender. Despite finishing with the second-best record in Class A the Planets were only 3-2-1 in their final six games, had been knocked around in its two games against Tier 1 Western Conference champion and three-time defending champion Quaker Valley and even dropped a game against a Freeport team that finished in third place in its division.

That loss to Freeport, though, turned into a rallying cry for the team as it headed into the playoffs.

“I think we did a really good job coming together this season,” Myers said. “We missed guys a lot this season, probably more than most teams for amateurs and things like that and, when we lost a tough one to Freeport at our house, 6-2, that kind of got the guys to rally and, mentally we were a different team.”

Winning the Penguins Cup will also make Mars a favorite rather than just a contender, something the Planets haven’t been since they won state championships in 2010-11. None of the current players were on those teams that won consecutive titles and will have to learn on the fly how to handle being the team to beat.

“I think it will be a different mindset for these guys for sure.” Myers said. “I’ve had experience with this in our first run, but it’s something these guys are going to have to adjust to. They’re going to have to bring it every night and we had a couple of off-nights this season, but it’s just something else they’ll have to adjust to.”

Advertise with us

Still, shaking off such a tough loss will be difficult, at least in the short term.

“I’m proud of every one of them and they played great all year,” Mars goaltender Tyler Spreng said. “It [stinks] it has to end like this, but we won our side of Pennsylvania. We didn’t get the cherry on top, but we got the prize.”