A state representative is ready to propose legislation that would force the PIAA to have separate postseason tournaments for public and parochial/private high schools. And the organization representing Catholic schools in Pennsylvania apparently is on board with the idea.

Rep. Aaron Bernstine, R-Beaver/Butler/Lawrence County, will hold a news conference Tuesday morning to discuss a bill that he believes has a good chance at eventually being signed by Gov. Tom Wolf. Bernstine said the Pennsylvania Catholic Conference, which represents all Catholic dioceses in the state, has agreed to the bill. Pennsylvania Catholic Conference officials and public school representatives also will attend the news conference.

“We have a great piece of legislation that has been agreed to by the Catholic Conference as well as public schools,” Bernstine said. “I would say this is something that people have tried to address for the last 40-plus years.

“This is historic because since 1972, there has been a situation where two sides have disagreed on an issue. We collaborated and brought both sides together over the past year. That doesn’t happen enough here in Harrisburg. There’s no reason for the House to hold it up. We’re not going to hold it up. I’m sure the Senate will do their job as well.”

Advertise with us

For many years, coaches, athletic administrators and fans have long complained that private and Catholic schools have a competitive advantage in high school sports because they do not have geographical boundaries from which to draw students. Lately, the complaints also have included charter schools, which are public schools that also have no geographic boundaries.

Public schools can only take students from their geographical area.

The complaints about the private and Catholic schools have become louder and more common in recent years, partly because of the huge success that Philadelphia Catholic League schools have enjoyed, especially in basketball. There are cries that Catholic and private schools recruit excessively, especially in Philadelphia.

Bob Lombardi, executive director of the PIAA, has said the league has no desire to have separate tournaments unless forced by the state Legislature. Lombardi and other PIAA officials have contended that a 1972 law forced the PIAA to accept Catholic schools into membership. Critics contend the law only says the PIAA must accept Catholic schools. It did not say there can’t be separate postseason tournaments.

Under this new bill, public and Catholic/private schools will continue to play in the regular season but have separate postseason tournaments. In the sport of basketball, there could be a tournament of champions, like New Jersey conducts. Under that plan, the public school state champs would play the Catholic/private school state champs.

Advertise with us

“I think a major hurdle in this issue is failing to sit down and listen to each other’s concerns,” Bernstine said. “We sat back and facilitated the first meeting a while ago. I think it was important to get all things on the table. At the end of the day, the sides actually agreed on a whole lot more than they disagreed on.”

Bernstine did not want to say exactly what his bill would entail, except that it would call for separate playoffs. One question would be how charter schools fit in with postseason tournaments.

Bernstine hopes the House will pass the bill before recess later this summer. The Senate could then examine the bill when it returns in September.

“It’s a pretty common sense bill,” Bernstine said. “By statute, the PIAA would have to implement what the law states.”

Leonard Rich, superintendent of Laurel School District, is part of a superintendents group called the Pennsylvania Athletics Equity Committee. Rich, one of the more vocal critics of private/Catholic school sports, will attend the news conference.

Advertise with us

“Our ambassador, if you will, has been Aaron Bernstine,” Rich said. “He has been working with our committee and the Catholic Conference. Why we believe this bill has a chance is because we’ve done some homework. We’ve done things together. This bill represents a compromise rather than the current situation we have.

“The PIAA has said they needed legislation to change. This legislation will direct them to change.”

Asked if the bill has any kind of actual plan, as far as brackets or playoff setup, “that would be up to the PIAA,” Rich said. “This won’t fix things overnight. But it’s certainly a step in the right direction.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.