In December, the executive director of the PIAA said the organization would not think about separate playoff tournaments for public and private/Catholic/charter schools unless the state legislature intervenes.

Well, one state legislator is about to start a push.

State Rep. Scott Conklin, a Democrat from Centre County, said he will soon introduce a bill that would allow the PIAA to create separate postseason tournaments for public schools and private/Catholic/charter schools. Conklin will discuss his bill with hundreds of football coaches from high school to midget leagues Thursday night at the Pennsylvania Scholastic Football Coaches Association clinic at Penn State.

“The bill will be introduced Monday,” Conklin said. “This is a long process. Our hope is that before we break for the summer, we get the bill moving, get it passed and that will give the PIAA time and opportunity to set up the rules on how to legislate it.”

Advertise with us

The bill would have to pass votes at the House and Senate before being signed by Gov. Tom Wolf. It should be pointed out that the bill would not force the PIAA to create separate tournaments.

“The idea of the bill is it gives the PIAA the tool they need to create separate tournaments,” Conklin said.

The public vs. private school topic has long been a subject of debate in Pennsylvania athletics. But it has become a hotter topic in recent years as more private/Catholic/charter schools, especially those from the Philadelphia Catholic and Public Leagues, win championships. Public schools complain that the other schools have an unfair advantage because they have no geographic boundaries from which to take students. Public schools, however, can only take students from their geographic district.

For example, St. Joseph’s Prep is a Catholic school in Philadelphia that has become a perennial power in football. This year’s team won a PIAA title for the fourth time in six years, and standout sophomore quarterback (Kyle McCord) lives in New Jersey.

PIAA administrators have expressed little interest in separate tournaments. The PIAA has said repeatedly that the reason it can’t have separate tournaments is because of a 1972 law that forced the PIAA to take Catholic schools into membership. Critics contend the law is outdated and simply says the PIAA had to take Catholic schools, but it didn’t say the PIAA couldn’t have separate tournaments.

Advertise with us

“The PIAA has said for years that they can’t change the law of 1972,” Conklin said. “What I’m doing is fixing that law, so the PIAA would not be open to litigation if they made a dual playoff system.

“The idea for this bill was brought to me by many different coaches. During the crafting of this bill, I was in close contact with many different coaches. In no way does this bill say that the local prep, private or Catholic schools can’t play public schools during the [regular season]. What it says is when we get to the playoffs, what we want to do is level the playing field [with separate tournaments]. This bill allows the PIAA to come in and set the parameters of how it’s going to be done.”

Bob Lombardi, executive director of the PIAA, said it’s hard to comment on Conklin’s bill because the PIAA has not seen it.

“Our board of directors has already passed a competition formula that we believe addresses some of these things,” said Lombardi. “As far as segregation of tournaments, we think that’s contrary to the 1972 legislative intent.”

Conklin contends the current system of high school athletics in the state is “unfair” to many schools.

Advertise with us

“The way the system is now, the playoffs become inherently unfair and even unsafe in some cases,” Conklin said. “Many of these schools are — I don’t know any other way to put it — able to recruit players from other areas, other states and even other countries.”

Garry Cathell is the executive director of the Pennsylvania Scholastic Football Coaches Association and said the PSFCA is neither for nor against Conklin’s bill.

“We thought it would be good for him to have an opportunity to speak to the coaches who are on both sides of the issue and let them hear what he is presenting,” Cathell said. “About a year-and-a-half ago, we had a meeting of our directors, and our general statement was it is important to do what’s best for high school football in Pennsylvania. We support the PIAA in investigating or any legislative group investigating and coming up with what’s best for our players and schools.”

What’s interesting with Conklin’s bill is that it doesn’t have complete support of the Pennsylvania Equity Committee, a group of school superintendents that has been pushing for separate tournaments for public and private schools. That committee has met with the PIAA about the issue and had a big meeting last summer with about 150 representatives of schools.

Len Rich, superintendent of the Laurel School District in Lawrence County and member of the WPIAL board of directors, is an Equity Committee member who has been very vocal about having separate tournaments. But he throws caution at Conklin’s bill.

Advertise with us

“We’re appreciative of his efforts and passions and share them. But we don’t see a path to success for his version,” Rich said. “I question what parties has he talked to and who has he involved? The superintendents of the Equity Committee were not at the table and the Catholic Conference wasn’t at the table.

“We appreciate his bill, but I am foreshadowing a number of political hurdles. I don’t know if it’s idealistic to make it through a state legislature that is controlled by Republicans. Is this bill going to have Republican support? Will it have the support of a Democratic governor? My concern is does this bill have enough room for compromise?”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh