Plum had done it.

C.J. Hart had capped off another great comeback when he scored on an 11-yard run to give the Mustangs a 4-point lead with 58 seconds remaining in regulation.

At least, that was what everyone on the Plum sideline thought Friday night.

“We just hit them with a play that they weren’t ready for,” Plum coach Matt Morgan said. “We had the lead there at the end.”

Advertise with us

As far as Armstrong was concerned, however, that was a big 58 seconds. And, the amazing thing is, the River Hawks only needed 14.

Senior receiver Kayden Lewis pulled off a fake reverse and returned the ensuing kickoff up the right sideline 90 yards to the house for what turned out to be the game-winning touchdown with 44 seconds left as Armstrong (5-1, 1-0) blew a 24-point fourth-quarter lead yet still managed to escape with a 38-35 victory against Plum (5-1, 0-1) in the Northeast Conference opener for both schools.

“We’ve had that in for the last couple of years. We have the wall set up, always have to have that fake at the top. If that goes in, all the players go run the other side of the field, you just run behind the wall and take it to the house,” Lewis said. “All that went through my mind was, this is it. This is the play I need to make now. It’s great to have this big win.”

Armstrong coach Frank Fabian made the call on the reverse from his press box perch – he’s one of the few WPIAL head coaches who eschews the sideline for the bird’s-eye view from up top – but he was quick to point out that, although he had the final decision on the usage, he wasn’t the one who originally concocted the play.

“We run that every Thursday and we were going to run it earlier in the game but they sky-kicked,” Fabian said. “I’ve got to give credit. The first coach I ever coached for, Ed Wasilowski at Redbank Valley, that was his baby and he kind of taught it to me. We’ve had it for 20 years, but he’s the author of that return.”

Advertise with us

That play may have taken the circuitous route through New Bethlehem and the Keystone Shortway Athletic Conference into the heart of the WPIAL, but it was a security blanket worth having.

Armstrong had done extraordinary work limiting Plum through most of three quarters. The River Hawks had a 24-0 lead, shut down an offense that came into the game averaging 41.0 points per game and limited John Nonnenberg, who led the WPIAL with more than 1,300 yards and 17 touchdowns, to 128 yards.

But Nonnenberg and Plum had been in this position just last week when they rallied in the fourth quarter to come back and beat Kiski Area, 29-28, so they knew what they had to do. The Mustangs took over on their own 34 and ran an up-tempo set that had Armstrong in disarray.

They drove the ball to the River Hawks 11 as the third quarter expired and, just 1:17 into the fourth quarter, officially began the comeback when Nonnenberg connected with Matt Lyle from 2 yards out to get Plum back into the game, 24-8.

Armstrong then went into a bit of shell, which played right into Plum’s hands. Nonnenberg, who completed 33 of 57 for 281 yards overall, connected with Tyler Baleno for one of his 10 receptions for 125 yards, on a 15-yard scoring strike that got the Mustangs back within a score, 24-16, with 5:23 remaining.

Advertise with us

Not satisfied, Plum went for an onside kick and recovered at the Armstrong 15. Just three plays later, Hart took a reverse inside handoff on a Statue of Liberty play and went 21 yards for the score to get the Mustangs back within two, 24-22, with 4:14 left.

Nonnenberg came up a yard short on a scramble on the 2-point conversion try, which appeared, at the time, to be a devastating miss. On the second play after the kickoff, Armstrong quarterback Jaydon Oliver, who passed for 102 yards, ran for 145 and accounted for four touchdowns, scored for the final time on a 71-yard draw that put the River Hawks back up by two scores, 31-22, with 3:22 left.

Armstrong seemingly put a capper on the game when Quinton Olsen intercepted Nonnenberg at the River Hawks 1 with 3:07 to play, but the game was just getting interesting.

Armstrong couldn’t get out of the shadow of its own goalposts and had to punt from its own end zone. Plum linebacker Maddox Roedersheimer got a hand on the ball, which came down to Semaj Robinson at the 12. Robinson easily took the punt to paydirt and got the Mustangs back within two, 31-29, with 2:39 remaining.

With no timeouts, Plum had to go for a second onside kick – which Robinson somehow recovered at the Armstrong 41. A late-hit penalty on the Mustangs helped their cause and Hart went in from 11 yards out for a 35-31 lead with 58 seconds left.

Advertise with us

It also set the stage for Lewis to pull off a ‘Redbank Special.’

“We were actually trying to kill off as much clock as we could at the end there, but we ended up scoring pretty quick,” Morgan said. “It’s just tough. It’s hard. I’m speechless.”