Ask any coach at any level what sports are all about, and they will reel off a litany of cliches.

At their core, the messages will all turn to one central theme: Whether or not you win championships or ride the bench on the worst team in the league, sports teaches life lessons players can take with them and rely upon for guidance for the rest of their lives.

Baldwin High School taught its football team a lesson on Wednesday — one that players can be saddled with for a long time.

It told its student-athletes and the rest of the sports community that its players weren’t good enough to win.

Advertise with us

After consulting with WPIAL chief executive officer Vince Sortino, Baldwin athletic director Tony Cherico sent a letter out to the five remaining teams on the football team’s schedule and pleaded with them to play the games with running clocks and to use their junior varsity players.

This came on the heels of an apparent consultation with the school’s administration, board and head coach Dana Brown Jr.

According to the letter, the team, which plays in Class 5A, only has around 30 players remaining on its roster, some of which were not healthy. Starting quarterback Noah Mickolay had transferred to Seton LaSalle, and the Highlanders have lost a WPIAL-worst 24 consecutive games.

To put it into perspective, South Fayette, the team Baldwin will face on Friday night, has 69 players on its roster. The Highlanders are 0-5 this season, have been outscored 277-32, have allowed the most points of any team in the WPIAL or City League regardless of classification, and are among the lowest-scoring teams, as well.

All of that is cause for concern, to be sure. Cherico even said in his letter that having to send an email of this nature made him sick but that he had to look out for the kids.

Advertise with us

Again. Understandable. No one wants to see kids get hurt.

But go back to what this letter said. It told opponents that the kids aren’t good enough to win. That “you will win with your JV getting significant time.”

These are high school kids who gave their time in the summer showing up for optional offseason workouts. Who went through a week of heat acclimatization drills and two weeks of training camp. Who donned their helmets and put on pads in 90-degree heat to take the field and represent their community and their school.

Now after all that work, when the season outlook appears grim as compared to the preseason when optimism reigned supreme, the adults in the room are begging for their players to be mollycoddled.

This also isn’t the first time a school has sent a letter of this nature out this season.

Advertise with us

On Sept. 3, Shady Side Academy, a Class 2A private school, contacted Clairton and asked that their non-conference game scheduled for Sept. 5 be postponed and potentially forfeited as the team only had around 25 healthy players of the 40 on its roster that were able to dress. Clairton, a Class 1A school, only has 30 players total on its roster.

When word got out about the postponement, Shady Side Academy issued a statement the next day clarifying that 31 of its players were physically unable to participate in the game against Clairton, meaning that 77.5% of its roster was incapacitated.

A few days prior to this request, Shady Side Academy had defeated a Class 3A Burrell team, 56-26. A week after the postponement, the Bulldogs won a mercy-rule game against winless Ligonier Valley, 42-6.

Last season, Shady Side Academy lost to Clairton 50-0, and the Bears, the Friday prior to their scheduled meeting with the Bulldogs, demolished Serra Catholic 79-0.

Because there is still time to make up the game, the WPIAL has not made any kind of a ruling on Shady Side Academy postponing a contest without first notifying the governing body.

Advertise with us

Both of these have a common theme. Neither wanted their kids to play games in which they were likely to lose by a substantial margin citing health and safety concerns.

To be fair, there are plenty of teams in the WPIAL in the same boat as Baldwin.

Valley in Class 3A has lost 20 in a row and will still host Freeport tis week.  The Vikings came oh-so-close to a win last week in a 29-20 loss to Quaker Valley.

Springdale, which has a 20-game losing streak in Class 1A, has had problems getting enough players all season and had only 20 players listed at the start of the season on its roster on MaxPreps. After playing four games the school announced late Wednesday afternoon it was postponing its scheduled Friday matchup with Leechburg and there are rumors it is considering shelving the season.

That is still a far cry from a school with 30 players available to play begging teams to take it easy on them.

Advertise with us

If Baldwin, a school that has never won a WPIAL football title, really doesn’t believe it can ever build a program to compete in its classification, it could always follow the path of Butler and Uniontown and play an independent schedule.

Albert Gallatin did it, and the Colonials are 5-0 this season with wins against Greensburg Salem and Northern Garrett (Md.).

When administrators and coaches send out letters begging off playing games or asking for opponents to treat their players with kid gloves, it does nothing to bolster confidence in the program or make students on the fence want to play. The kids know, in their hearts, no matter how much effort they put in, the adults in the room don’t think they’re good enough.

And that’s not a lesson that should be taught to any child.