A Class 5A football team starts the season with a 2-2 record. But the team, which features a Big Ten Conference college recruit, rebounds and makes it to the district final to face an undefeated team that is the No. 1 seed for the playoffs.
The upstart team knocks off the undefeated opponent in the title game by three points, and wins its first district championship in school history, using a big game from that Big Ten recruit.
If this sounds like the story of the Penn-Trafford Warriors — it is.
But it’s also the exact same story of the Exeter Township Eagles.
And now, the teams with the same tales meet head to head in a state semifinal game. As far as seasons go, these two are mirror images of each other.
Penn-Trafford (11-2) meets Exeter (10-3) Friday night at Bald Eagle High School near State College in a PIAA Class 5A semifinal. The winner plays for the state title in Hershey Dec. 10 against the winner of Friday’s other semifinal between Imhotep (10-1) and Strath Haven (13-1).
Read More
Penn-Trafford won its first WPIAL title with a 24-21 victory against Moon last Saturday at Heinz Field, and running back-defensive back Cade Yacamelli, a University of Wisconsin recruit, had a big game.
Exeter, located just outside of Reading, won the District 3 championship with a 31-28 victory against a Governor Mifflin team that was the Post-Gazette’s No. 1-ranked Class 5A team in the state. The Big Ten recruit for Exeter who had a big game was 6-foot-6, 210-pound junior receiver Joey Schlaffer, who has committed to Penn State and had five receptions for 55 yards and two touchdowns.
“I’m not going to sing our own praises, but we had a feeling going into this season that this was a special group of kids,” Exeter coach Matt Bauer said. “There was a lot of pressure on ourselves as coaches, too, because a group of kids like this doesn’t come along too often.
“Losing to [Landisville] Hempfield in Week 4 was really a wake-up call for us. Out of all the games we played, that was one we let slip away. We were kind of at a crossroads then. The kids had their own meeting and we went in the right direction and haven’t looked back.”
There was a 54-21 loss to Governor Mifflin in the regular season. Governor Mifflin featured Nick Singleton, a Penn State recruit who is ranked among the top senior running backs in the country. When Governor Mifflin beat Exeter, Singleton rushed for 244 yards on 18 carries.
In the rematch, Singleton was held to 41 yards on eight carries.
“We preached to the kids that in order to be successful, you have to be playing your best in November,” Bauer said. “To shut down the No. 1 team in the state is saying something. I think our front seven is pretty stout overall. We’ve had some good defensive performances, but that one ranks right up there.
But Exeter’s offense can be potent also. Against Governor Mifflin, junior running back Eric Nangle (5-10, 175) ran for 213 yards on 40 carries and he has 1,769 yards rushing on the season. Quarterback Colin Payne, a 6-3, 170-pound senior, has completed 118 of 199 for 2,163 yards. Schlaffer has 41 catches for 728 yards.
“[Schlaffer] has started every game since his freshman year and he played his best game Friday night,” Bauer said. “I would’ve said before that, his best game was Governor Mifflin earlier in the season. He has a knack at playing his best in big games.”
And now comes another big game — for Penn-Trafford and Exeter. Neither team has been this far in the postseason. Penn-Trafford is coming off the emotional WPIAL victory. The team bus got a police escort from Heinz Field back to the school. The bus went to Penn-Trafford’s stadium, where about 1,000 fans were waiting. The whole night provided quite a memory for a high school team.
Bauer believes there is a key to this Friday’s game.
“They’re very physical and come off the ball,” Bauer said. “In order for us to be successful in any game, we have to at least manage the game up front. If our line can match their physicality, we should have a shot.”
Class 6A
Mt. Lebanon has been impressive all season, rolling to a 13-0 record, a WPIAL title and outscoring opponents by an average of 38.2-9.8.
The Blue Devils’ opponent in the PIAA Class 6A semifinal has been quite the opposite. State College doesn’t have an impressive record (8-5) and was 3-3 at one point. But the Little Lions are a much different team than early in the season and have peaked at the right time. They have won four in a row, including a 16-13 victory in the PIAA quarterfinals last week against a pretty good Harrisburg team. State College won on Kajetan Kaszubowski’s third field of the game with three seconds left.
Now, State College will play Mt. Lebanon in the semifinals Saturday, 1 p.m. at Altoona’s Mansion Park Stadium.
This is State College’s first semifinal appearance since 2009 and first under coach Matt Lintal, who is in his eighth year. This is only Mt. Lebanon’s second semifinal appearance. The other came in 2000 when Mt. Lebanon, coached by Chris Haering, lost to Cathedral Prep of Erie.
“We’ve got a younger team, and I think it took some battles and the grind of the Mid-Penn Commonwealth Division to get where we are now,” Lintal said. “Our kids trusted in the process. Our assistants did a tremendous job of coaching them up, with the focus of peaking at the right time, making a run and seeing what we can do.”
State College is much different — personnel-wise — than at the beginning of the season.
“We played three quarterbacks the first game, and neither of them are starting now,” Lintal said.
The quarterback now is sophomore Owen Yerka, who has completed 30 of 57 for 329 yards. State College’s passing game won’t wow anyone, but the running game can be effective. Brady Bendik is a 6-3, 215-pound running back who had 132 yards on 34 carries against Harrisburg and has 831 yards on 196 carries for the season. Bendik is committed to the Naval Academy to be a baseball pitcher.
State College isn’t a fancy team, but the Little Lions’ style has been successful lately. They held Harrisburg to 9 yards rushing.
“They’re big. They’ve got some big son of a guns,” Mt. Lebanon coach Bob Palko said. “They’ll try for those, six-, seven- and eight-minute drives. They have a couple game breakers, too. They’re good at what they do.”
But so is Mt. Lebanon.
Lintal knows Palko because Lintal used to be an assistant coach at Bucknell University and recruited some West Allegheny players when Palko coached there.
“Mt. Lebanon is one of those teams that you know is going to be coached up and play sound, fundamental football in every phase,” Lintal said. “Their No. 5 [RB-DB Alex Tecza] and No. 8 [WR-DB Eli Heidenreich] are phenomenal football players. They play the game the way it’s supposed to be played. Trying to slow those guys down is going to be a task.”
The winner plays in the title game Dec. 11 in Hershey against the winner of the other semifinal between St. Joseph’s Prep (10-2) and Garnet Valley (14-0). St. Joseph’s Prep has won three of the past four PIAA Class 6A titles.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.