Varsity Xtra 2018: Ties in high school football — good or bad?

I’m Just Sayin’

The Steelers tied the Browns and everyone in Steeler Nation was upset. After all, a tie is supposed to be like kissing your sister.

Well, did you know there used to be a lot of sister smooching in WPIAL football?

WPIAL football started in the early 1900s and the league had tie games all the way through the 1994 regular season. That’s when the PIAA and WPIAL instituted an overtime procedure that broke ties. If you’re not familiar with high school overtimes, each team gets a possession at the 10-yard line. If the game is still tied, the process is repeated until one team wins.

Advertise with us

Through the 1994 season, ties were a big part of WPIAL football. Consider that in 1994, 33 WPIAL teams had a tie and two had two ties. From 1989 through 1993, at least 17 WPIAL teams had at least one tie. And how about this for teams fit to be tied: In 1986, the top five teams in the Class A Tri-County North Conference all had at least one tie. Shenango missed the playoffs because it had two ties.

And did you know that when the WPIAL playoffs first started in the 1970s, the league did not have an overtime procedure?

The most infamous tie — or almost tie — came in a WPIAL semifinal playoff game at Three Rivers Stadium in 1972 between Jeannette and Monessen. The score was tied, 14-14, after regulation. So what did the WPIAL do? Go to the numbers. The WPIAL ruled the winner would be decided by total yardage. Joe Mucci was Jeannette’s coach back then and remembers teams looking up to the press box when the game ended.

“Apparently, there was someone up there from the WPIAL. Between that person and the various sports writers covering the game, they came up with the total yardage,” Mucci said. “Then somehow or other, they announced it on the public address system.”

And Jeannette won, 254-177.

Advertise with us

It’s nice that high school football is no longer all tied up.

• Yough’s football program hasn’t had much to boast about over the years. The Cougars have made the WPIAL playoffs only eight times since the school started playing football in 1969. But Yough will soon have a running back join the 4,000-yard club. Dustin Shoaf, a senior, has 3,687 career rushing yards, including 646 this season.

• Is it too early to start talking playoffs for Southmoreland? The Scotties are 2-1. Southmoreland hasn’t been to the WPIAL playoffs since 1979, the longest drought in the WPIAL.

• Speaking of Southmoreland. Remember Brandon Stone, the former Southmoreland basketball standout who thought he would be better off finishing his high school career elsewhere? Stone made a verbal commitment last week to La Salle. Stone, a 6-foot-11 forward, left Southmoreland after his junior year. He reclassified and attended Christ School (N.C.). He played last season and is attending Christ School for one more year. And he is playing football this season.

• I’m just sayin’ some are shocked that Woodland Hills is 0-3. Don’t be. This is certainly not a good Woodland Hills team and the Wolverines might struggle to win games this year. But remember that Woodland Hills had two 0-3 starts under legendary coach George Novak (2007 and 1992) and a few other seasons where it started 1-3.

Advertise with us

• Speaking of Woodland Hills, how bizarre was it that two former runners in the same Woodland Hills backfield had their first 100-yard games in college — on the same night? Miles Sanders rushed for 118 yards for Penn State against Pitt Saturday, while Jo-El Shaw ran for 105 yards for Kent State against Howard. Sanders and Shaw both rushed for more than 1,000 yards in 2015 for Woodland Hills.

• Cornell is 2-0 this season, a nice start for a team that won one game the past two seasons. The school started the football program again in 2016 after a four-year hiatus. What would’ve happened to this team if Ed Dawson got the Aliquippa job? He was a finalist.

• Rochester senior Noah Whiteleather obviously has running talent. But running talent also runs in his genes. Whiteleather rushed for 356 yards in a game last Friday and has more than 600 yards in three games. Fourteen years ago, his brother, Brent, rushed for more than 1,000 yards for Rochester during the regular season and won a WPIAL title. Another Whiteleather brother, Toni, also played at Rochester. Both Brent and Toni went on to play defense at California University of Pa.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh

Schedules and Results
STANDINGS: WPIAL | City League
Team Pages | Sortable Statistics