Walk into Scott Heinauer’s office at Mars High School and his hobby as a collector is quite evident. Heinauer has a mini-football helmet on shelves of every college team in the “power 5” conferences. Heinauer also collects Hallmark Christmas ornaments and he keeps hundreds of those in boxes at his home.

As the football coach at Mars, Heinauer is a hoarder of wins – and no coach in Butler County history can match his collection.

Last Friday, Heinauer became the winningest coach in the history of Butler County when the Planets defeated Indiana. It is a terrific achievement, if for no other reason than the man Heinauer passed. The previous leader for wins in Butler County history was Art Bernardi, the legendary former coach at Butler High. Heinauer has been Mars’ coach since 1992 and his record in 26 seasons is 180-99. He coached Peters Township for four games in the late 1980s during a teachers strike and had a 3-1 record to make his all-time mark 183-100. Bernardi was 179-64-1 at Butler from 1961-85.

“I think this does mean something because if you mention to anyone football in Butler, Art Bernardi is the first thing that comes to mind for many people, said Heinauer, who also is Mars’ athletic director. “Maybe at some point when you say Mars football, people might think of my name. But the thing is, we’re not done yet.”

Advertise with us

Mention the best coaches in the WPIAL and the names of Cherpak, Zmijanac, Palko and Render come to mind right away. Maybe not Heinauer, but partly because he hasn’t won a WPIAL championship. He came close twice, losing in a title game in 2002 and 1996. But if you look at pure numbers, Heinauer has turned into one of the WPIAL’s best coaches, albeit almost quietly. Consider that of all the coaches in the WPIAL who have been around since 2000, the only ones with more wins than Heinauer since that year are Aliquippa’s Mike Zmijanac, Thomas Jefferson’s Bill Cherpak, Rochester’s Gene Matsook, Upper St. Clair’s Jim Render, West Allegheny’s Bob Palko and North Allegheny’s Art Walker.

This season, Mars has qualified for the playoffs for the 16th consecutive season and the Planets need one more win to have at least seven victories for the 11th time in the past 12 years.

Heinauer has managed to win his way, an old-fashioned way. His teams continue to run the old winged-T offense, although they use some different variations of the old-school attack. The 57-year-old Heinauer is a former Sto-Rox player who can be a tough, demanding coach with a no-nonsense type of attitude on the field. Those who know him well will tell you he has a vocabulary with words and terms all his own, like “all busted up.” Winning has become a big part of his vocabulary at Mars.

“At times, we throw the ball a little more than we have in the past,” said Heinauer. “But we’re big into teaching fundamentals. I don’t know anyone around here who runs the winged-T much any more. But that’s what suits us. We have a couple good-sized kids, but we’ve always had a lot of little guys and that offense suits them. You can have kids in any shape or size and that offense will suit them.”

And Heinauer has suited Mars well.

Advertise with us

The other Carmody

Robby Carmody is a well-known basketball player at Mars, widely regarded as one of the best senior players in the state who has committed to Notre Dame. There could be another Division I college player in the Carmody family, but in a different sport.

Mike Carmody, Robby’s younger brother, starts at tight end and defensive end for Mars – and he is only a sophomore. This is his first year of high school football and Carmody is 6 feet 5, 240 pounds.

“I think there’s some pressure on Mike, not from coaches, but from himself,” said Heinauer. “Having a brother as talented as Robby is not easy. But Mike is a kid who is still growing and maturing and he’s starting to understand what’s expected of him. He’s a smart kid and I would think he might be [a Division I college player]. Someone will take him because of his size and athletic ability. He’s got a long way to go, but remember he’s only a 10th-grader.”

Mike Carmody also plays basketball and should start in that sport for the Planets this year also.

Advertise with us

Fallen Tigers

Beaver Falls won WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A titles last season, but the Tigers have had a long and hard fall this season, taking a 1-7 record into their final game of the season.

No one really expected much from Beaver Falls this season. After all, first year coach Nick Nardone had only two returning starters from last season. That might or might not have played a small role in coach Ryan Matsook’s decision to step down as coach, although Matsook said it didn’t. Whatever, the fact is that no WPIAL team that has won a PIAA championship has ever fallen so far, so fast.

Heading into this season, 39 WPIAL teams had won PIAA championships. Only three of them had a record below .500 the next season. The worst was South Side Beaver, which won a PIAA title in 1999 and finished 2-8 the next season. The only other PIAA champs from the WPIAL that finished with a below .500 record the next season were 1988 Central Catholic (4-5-1 the next year) and 1993 North Hills (4-5-1 the next season).

Woody High and NFL

Advertise with us

George Novak is no longer the coach at Woodland Hills, but the school’s pipeline to the NFL is still open.

An NFL survey of opening-day rosters showed Woodland Hills was one of only 10 high schools in the country with five or more players in the league. They are Rob Gronkowski (New England), Quinton Jefferson (Seattle), Rontez Miles (New York Jets), Lafayette Pitts (Jacksonville) and Ejuan Price (Los Angeles Rams). Price is a rookie and is the 12th former Woodland Hills Wolverine to play in the NFL since the school opened in 1987. St. Thomas Aquinas (Fla.) has the most NFL players with 12, followed by Long Beach Poly (Calif.) with seven, Glades Central (Fla.) Glenville (Ohio) with six and five others with five.

Penn Hills had two players on opening-day rosters, but it’s now three in the NFL because Aaron Donald was not on the Rams’ roster opening day because of a contract holdout. The two other former Penn Hills players in the NFL are Barry Church (Jacksonville) and Treyvon Hester (Oakland Raiders).

Overall, 21 former WPIAL players were on NFL opening-day rosters, but 22 if you count James Conner (Steelers). Conner played at McDowell, which was in the WPIAL when he played there.

Two City League players are in the NFL – Brashear’s John Wetzel (Arizona) and Allderdice’s Will Clarke (Tampa Bay).