The shrinking number of high school football players across the country in recent years already has been documented. But the compelling evidence of declining participation hits home in Western Pennsylvania — in ninth grade.
Many varsity teams in the WPIAL have considerably smaller rosters than a decade or so ago. But freshman football in the WPIAL should be on the endangered species list. It’s moving closer and closer to extinction.
The WPIAL has 122 schools with varsity football teams. Of those schools, only 18 have ninth-grade teams, a statistic that WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley calls “alarming.”
Maybe three or four decades ago most WPIAL schools had a ninth-grade team, a junior varsity and a varsity. To put today’s ninth-grade numbers in perspective, consider the WPIAL still had 34 ninth-grade teams only three years ago. Even more unpalatable is the fact that, only 14 years ago, the WPIAL had 88 schools with junior high (ninth-grade) schedules and 89 in 2003.
That means the number of teams playing ninth-grade football has shrunk by 80 percent over 13 years.
There are a few reasons why ninth-grade football is disappearing. Some coaches in the WPIAL decided it is better to get rid of a separate ninth-grade team and simply have freshmen practice with the JV and varsity teams. It gets the freshmen used to the “varsity way” earlier than before. But the main reason for the abolition of ninth-grade teams is declining participation. It is hard to field a team when the number of freshmen players barely reaches double digits.
Read More
And everyone from coaches to athletic directors will tell you one of the main reasons for declining participation in football at all levels is fear of concussions. According to the National Federation of State High School Associations, there were 29,000 fewer high school players last year than 2008.
On the Western Pa. level, smaller schools were the first to struggle with fielding ninth-grade teams. But declining participation also is a problem at bigger schools. Just this year, Upper St. Clair, Woodland Hills, Fox Chapel, Knoch and North Hills folded their ninth-grade programs. North Hills has only 13 freshmen on the JV-varsity roster. Upper St. Clair coach Jim Render remembers when he began coaching the Panthers in 1979, the school had two ninth-grade teams. Woodland Hills also had two ninth-grade teams for a while after it opened in 1987.
“Is this alarming? Yes, a little,” said Render, the all-time winningest coach in WPIAL history. “The ideal situation would be to have 25-30 freshmen and they would play their own schedules. But then there is another part of me that thinks we should run the program the way colleges run theirs. The college coaches coach four classes.
“But I still don’t think there is a great argument for dropping a freshmen program. There just isn’t. Football has gotten its fair share of bad publicity and I think [participation] numbers are reflected. But I have to believe the game is still very popular. The amount of attention given to pro, college and high school football. I don’t know, but they aren’t packing stadiums to watch other sports like they do football.”
Football isn’t the only WPIAL sport where the number of ninth-grade teams have declined. There is no longer ninth-grade girls basketball in the WPIAL.
“I think the fear and concern goes to the fact that, in football, there are ninth-graders who maybe aren’t physically and emotionally ready to compete at JV and varsity practices for the whole season and might become disenchanted and stop playing,” said O’Malley. “Everyone has their own reasons for what they are doing with ninth-graders. But from a long-term perspective, the reality is by putting kids in an environment with kids who are two and three years older, are they able to adjust in a favorable way, or do they say, ‘I will find something else to do?’”
The nine schools with ninth-grade schedules from the WPIAL are Bethel Park, Canon-McMillan, Central Catholic, Mars, Mt. Lebanon, North Allegheny, Pine-Richland, Penn Hills and Seneca Valley. The only other WPIAL schools known to have ninth-grade teams play in a nine-team league created by the Westmoreland County Athletic Directors Association (WADA). Those teams are Altoona, Armstrong, Connellsville, Hempfield, Latrobe, McKeesport, Mount Pleasant, Norwin and Penn-Trafford.
Some of those ninth-grade teams have between 25-35 players. Central Catholic has 50. Hempfield has 34 players on its ninth-grade team. Hempfield athletic director Greg Meisner, a 1977 graduate of Valley High School who played at Pitt and in the NFL, used to be the head coach at Hempfield. When he became coach in 2005, Hempfield had 45 players on the ninth-grade team.
“I think the biggest reason you see this decline [in ninth-grade teams] is concussion awareness,” said Meisner, who schedules all games for the WADA teams. “You see kids in school and ask them why they’re not playing football, and a lot of them say their parents won’t let them.”
Some schools that don’t have a freshman team have started to play what has been termed “JV B” games. The varsity plays Friday, the JV Saturday and the JV B team Monday. The JV B game is for ninth-graders, but they still sometimes face sophomores.
Pine-Richland coach Eric Kasperowicz is a big proponent of separate ninth-grade games. He believes it is good for many players, including talented ones. Phil Jurkovec is Pine-Richland’s star junior quarterback who already has committed to Notre Dame. When Jurkovec was a freshman, Kasperowicz didn’t move Jurkovec up to even the JV. He had him play on the ninth-grade team.
Many ninth-grade teams practice by themselves and have their own coaches. But at Pine-Richland, the ninth-graders practice at the same time as the JV and varsity, and are coached by JV and varsity coaches. But the ninth-graders practice among themselves.
“You hate to say it, but the drop in ninth-grade teams I guess is an example of fewer kids playing,” said Kasperowicz. “With all these other sports today and a lot of other things, there are more options for kids. Football has gotten a bad rap in the media. But as coaches, I think it’s our job to be ambassadors and protect the game a little. We’ve made a conscious effort. We don’t hit like we used to. We’re in full pads only once a week.
“Absolutely, I think ninth-grade football is still a good thing. As long as there are quality teams to still play, I want to keep doing it.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.